Ismini Papageorgiou1,2, Ansgar Malich1, Lorenz Damian Rossknecht1, and Stathis Hadjidemetriou3
1Institute for Radiology, South Harz Hospital Nordhausen, Nordhausen, Germany, 2Institute for Diagnostic and Interventional Radiology, University Medicine of Jena, Jena, Germany, 3Department of Information Technologies, University of Limassol, Limassol, Cyprus
Synopsis
Keywords: Screening, Artifacts, bone metastases, signal restoration, cancer screening
Motivation: Whole-body MRI, a screening tool for bone metastatic disease, uses parallel coil imaging to cover a large Field of View. Signal inhomogeneities at the coil junction points create jump discontinuities in the signal intensity with a negative effect on serial image stitching.
Goal(s): To correct for signal jump discontinuities between coils using computer vision.
Approach: We engaged piecewise smooth intensity nonuniformities fields using anisotropic diffusion and quantified for improvement in image entropy (H).
Results: Our algorithm smoothens the signal intensity between parallel coils by 8% based on entropy metrics.
Impact: We
implement a novel non-parametric methodology with piecewise
smoothness to improve intensity non-uniformities between parallel
coil images in whole-body MRI (WB-MRI). Optimized whole-body stitched
images render WB-MRI into a one-stop-shop staging method.
INTRODUCTION
Whole-body
MRI (WB-MRI) is an imaging tool for the entire body. In clinical
oncology, WB-MRI is the future first-line diagnosis in cancer staging
and follow-up, currently approved for detecting bone metastasis [1].
WB-MRI images are multi-coil parallel acquisitions over a large Field
of View (FoV) that inevitably suffer from extensive intensity
nonuniformities due to differences in gains, as well as jump
discontinuities between coil junctions. Some of those artifacts
cannot be addressed by conventional intensity correction
methodologies [2,3,4]. The proposed method addresses this problem
with the novelty of estimating piecewise smooth intensity
nonuniformities fields using anisotropic diffusion [5] between joint
image pairs, as published in previous work by the authors [6]. The
methodology has been validated by comparing it with a restoration
using conventional isotropic smoothing in an in-domo dataset. METHODS
Forty
breast and prostate cancer patients were examined with WB-MRI for
possible bone metastases using T1w Turbo Spin Echo (TSE) and Short-TI
Recovery (STIR) T1w+T2w. The datasets were screened for not suffering
from misregistration and resampled to have the exact spatial
resolution, the same size, and two bytes per pixel.
The images
are first denoised with median filtering. The sum of the two images
is processed with Otsu's method. A low-pass and high-pass filter
exclude noise and artifacts. The restoration with statistical
co-occurrence statistics was based on a Gaussian Point Spread
smoothing function linearly increasing in proportion to the intensity
of spatial non-uniformities. Spatial smoothing was achieved by
back-projection with indexing the restoration matrices using an axial
Gaussian filter. The restoration of the images is repeated
iteratively for ten iterations. The spatial restoration fields are
accumulated multiplicatively along the iterations, and the cumulative
fields are smoothed anisotropically along iterations. The optimal
iteration is selected retrospectively as the one which minimizes the
joint entropy of the statistics.RESULTS
Two
examples of initial and restored images of both contrasts are shown
in Figure 1 (patient 1) and Figure 2 (patient 2), respectively. In
the left figure panels are the T1w TSE images, and in the right are
the STIR images. The top rows show the initial images, the middle
rows show the cumulative restoration fields and the bottom rows show
the restored images.
The proposed method was compared to
conventional restoration, where the spatial smoothing filter was
isotropic. The validation used the entropy of the joint histogram
(H). The restoration sharpens the statistics, so it decreases the
entropy. A relative improvement of the anisotropic diffusion compared
to the isotropic restoration corresponds to a positive value for the
measure H-ratio. The H-ratio values were 8.5±9 (mean/SD) and 8.9/-8.9/30.4 (median/min/man). The improvement with the anisotropic method
is around 8%.
Another conventional intensity correction method,
implemented by the module "N4ITK MRI Bias correction" of
Slicer3D, was used for experimentation [7]. It was apparent by the
observation that N4ITK failed to remove the nonuniformities, and led
to an extensive loss of contrast in both the images and in the
statistics. This is mainly because N3/N4 is unable to represent field
discontinuities.DISCUSSION
The
proposed method removes the nonuniformity of the shading together
with its discontinuities for bi-contrast WB-MRI data. It improves the
stitching performance on average by 8% when considering the spatial
nonuniformity compared to when ignoring it.
The proposed
methodology addresses this problem by first performing deconvolution
and restoration of the statistics using the co-occurrence statistics
with a lower variance for the dominant distributions. It provides a
Bayesian posterior estimate for the restored intensities. These are
back-projected to space to give rough estimates of the spatial
restorations. They are then processed with piecewise smoothness
formulated with MDL, or equivalently MAP, that accommodates spatial
nonuniformities discontinuities. Conventional methodologies assume a
uniformly smooth nonuniformity. The spatial piecewise smoothness for
the nonuniformity shading is novel not only for WB-MRI but more
generally for medical imaging and even for computer vision. The
method is non-parametric both in the statistics and in space and
provides the joint intensity uniformity restorations of two anatomic
WB images simultaneously.
Major
weaknesses of this study, which the authors currently address, are
the low data sample and the lack of quantitative comparison to
conventional methods. CONCLUSION
This
work presents a novel non-parametric methodology with piecewise
smoothness for the nonuniformities for effective and simultaneous
joint intensity uniformity restoration of two anatomic WB images. The
proposed method is novel and valuable. The current methodology can be
enhanced by registering multimodal datasets and is integrable into
automated detection pipelines.Acknowledgements
No disclosures or acknowledgmentsReferences
[1]
Papageorgiou, I., Dvorak, J., Cosma, I., Pfeil, A., Teichgraeber, U.,
Malich, A., "Whole-Body MRI: a Powerful Alternative to Bone Scan
for Bone Marrow Staging Without Radiation and Gadolinium Enhancer,"
Clin. Transl. Oncol., 22 (8), (2020)
[2] Tustison, N.J., Avants,
B.B., Cook, P.A., Zheng, Y., Egan, A., Yushkevich, P.A., Gee,
J.C.,
"N4ITK: Improved N3 Bias Correction," IEEE Trans
Med Imaging, 29 (6), (2010)
[3] Hadjidemetriou, S., Studholme,
C., Mueller, S., Weiner, M., Schuff, N., "Restoration of MRI
Data for Intensity Non-uniformities Using Local High Order Intensity
Statistics," Medical Image Analysis, 13 (1), (2009)
[4]
Hadjidemetriou, S., Psychogios, M.N., Lingor, P., Eckardstein, K.V.,
Papageorgiou, I., "Restoration of Bi-Contrast MRI Data for
Intensity Uniformity with Bayesian Coring of Co-Occurrence
Statistics," Journal of Imaging, MDPI, 3 (4), (2017)
[5]
Leclerc, Y.G.: "Constructing Simple Stable Descriptions for
Image Partitioning," Int. J. Comput. Vis. 3(1): 73-102
(1989)
[6] Hadjidemetriou S., Malich A., Rossknecht LD.,
Ferrarini L., Papageorgiou IE., "Restoration for Intensity
Nonuniformities with Discontinuities in Whole-Body MRI,"
Signals. 2023; 4(4):725-745.
https://doi.org/10.3390/signals4040040
[7] Tustison N., Gee J.
"N4ITK: Nick's N3 ITK Implementation For MRI Bias Field
Correction," The Insight Journal. 2010 Dec.
http://hdl.handle.net/10380/3053