Thomas Welton1 and Thomas Teo2
1Research, National Neuroscience Institute; Duke-NUS Medical School, Singapore, Singapore, Singapore, 2Research, National Neuroscience Institute, Singapore, Singapore
Synopsis
Keywords: Parkinson's Disease, Diffusion Tensor Imaging
Motivation: The genetic variant rs9638616, is associated with Parkinson’s Disease (PD) risk in Asian populations.
Goal(s): To provide insight into the neural correlates of rs9638616 in Asian PD, to inform risk models and idiopathic PD aetiology.
Approach: Using imaging and genotyping data from 116 early-PD patients and 57 controls of Chinese ethnicity, we performed voxelwise analyses to assess rs9638616 T-allele association with brain microstructure, morphology and function.
Results: Our results suggest that rs9638616 may confer PD risk in Asian cohorts via lower white matter fractional anisotropy and reduced supplementary motor area functional connectivity.
Impact: In an imaging-genetics analysis, the Asian PD risk variant
rs9638616 was associated with altered brain structure/function. This rationalises
rs9638616’s role in PD risk, and may be useful in improving PD stratification
and risk modeling.
Introduction
The majority of Parkinson’s disease (PD) cases are
idiopathic, involving multiple small genetic-risk contributions. An Asian PD
GWAS variant, rs9638616, was recently reported [1],
and maps to the WBSCR17/GALNT17 gene, which influences synaptic transmission
and neurite development. We need to understand the associated brain changes in
a race-specific context, to inform PD risk stratification and aetiology [2].
Neuronal changes resulting from rs9638616 may manifest in brain imaging. We assess
the relationship between rs9638616 and PD through an imaging-genetics approach.
We hypothesised that rs9638616-T would be associated with imaging-derived measures
of brain structure and function. Methods
We analysed 3-Tesla MRI and genotyping data from 116 early
PD patients (aged 66.8±9.0 years; 39% female; disease duration 1.25±0.71 years)
and 57 controls (aged 68.7±7.4 years; 54% female) of Chinese ethnicity. MRI
included T1-weighted (TE=0.002s, TR=1.9s, TI=900ms, FA=9°, in-plane voxel
size=1x1mm,slice thickness=1mm, matrix=256x256x256), DTI (TE=0.102s,TR=10.118s,
FA=90°, in-plane voxel size=1.8x1.8mm, slice thickness=2.5mm,matrix=112x112x55,
anterior-posterior phase encoding, 60 diffusion-weighted volumes (30 at
b=1000mm/s2 and 30 at 2000mm/s2) with each shell evenly distributed on the unit
sphere and 3 volumes with b=0mm/s2) and RS-fMRI (TE=0.030s, TR=3.0s, FA=90°,
in-plane voxel size=2.127x2.127mm, slice thickness=3.3mm, matrix=94x94x44,
interleaved slice acquisition order, 150 volumes, scan time=7 minutes 30 seconds).
We performed voxelwise analyses of rs9638616-T
with RS-fMRI (dual regression), morphology (VBM) and fractional-anisotropy
(TBSS), with age and gender as covariates, and post-hoc mediation analyses,
while controlling for Results
In the absence of significant interaction effects, we used
the combined groups’ data. rs9638616-T was negatively associated with lower
white matter FA (t=-1.75, p=0.042) distributed broadly across the entire brain,
and lower functional connectivity of the occipital lobe network to the right supplementary
motor area (SMA) (t=-5.05, p=0.001). We did not observe any significant
voxelwise effects for grey matter volumes. These imaging-derived phenotypes significantly
mediated the association of rs9638616 to MDS-UPDRS-III reflecting motor
severity (indirect effect: β=-0.21 [-0.42,-0.05], p=0.031), and digit span
reflecting cognitive performance (indirect effect: β=0.15 [0.04,0.26],
p=0.045). Discussion
We identified significant imaging-genetic associations between
rs9638616 and two types of voxelwise brain imaging measure, namely reduced
widespread white matter FA and reduced functional connectivity of the SMA. The
observed imaging-genetic associations are consistent with changes noted in
previous PD studies [3, 4].
The associations were not limited to the PD group but extended to the control
group, suggesting that the results reflect susceptibility rather than
subclinical PD pathological processes. While rs9638616 was not directly
associated with working memory or motor function, mediation analyses revealed
significant indirect associations through the phenotypes identified, supporting
a plausible causal chain where neurologic effects of rs9638616 confer cognitive
and/or motor deficits. Thus, our significant mediation findings highlight a
potentially important yet unexplored approach for prioritizing future PD GWAS
results: through the “intermediate phenotype” concept. It should be noted that rs9638616
confers increased PD risk in Asian [1]
but not European [5]
populations – as such, our findings may be specific to the Asian PD population,
which emphasizes the need to account for ethnic variance in studies of PD
genetic risk.
Our study was limited in several ways. While genetic factors
contribute to PD risk, environmental and epigenetic factors could not be fully
accounted for in the analysis. Furthermore, a wider range of disease durations and
severities may have provided greater power to detect significant effects. Conclusion
We have shown that a novel GWAS variant which is
biologically linked to synaptic transmission is associated with white matter
tract and functional connectivity dysfunction in the SMA. These effects are
present in both PD and nominally-healthy individuals, and are associated with
reduced cognitive and motor functioning, supporting their clinical relevance. This
provides pathophysiologic clues linking rs9638616 to PD risk and might be
useful for stratification of Asian at-risk individuals.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Foo, J.N., et al., Identification
of risk loci for Parkinson disease in Asians and comparison of risk between
Asians and Europeans: a genome-wide association study. JAMA neurology,
2020. 77(6): p. 746-754.
2. Nalls,
M.A., et al., Identification of novel
risk loci, causal insights, and heritable risk for Parkinson's disease: a
meta-analysis of genome-wide association studies. The Lancet Neurology,
2019. 18(12): p. 1091-1102.
3. Wei,
X., et al., White matter abnormalities in
patients with parkinson's disease: a meta-analysis of diffusion tensor imaging
using tract-based spatial statistics. Frontiers in aging neuroscience,
2021. 12: p. 610962.
4. Tessitore,
A., M. Cirillo, and R. De Micco, Functional
connectivity signatures of Parkinson’s disease. Journal of Parkinson's
disease, 2019. 9(4): p. 637-652.
5. Grover, S., et al., Replication of a novel Parkinson's locus in
a European ancestry population. Movement Disorders, 2021. 36(7): p. 1689-1695.