Chia-Ying Liu1, Chikara Noda2, Bharath Ambale-Venkatesh2, Yoshimori Kassai3, David A Bluemke4, and Joao A.C Lima2
1Canon Medical Systems Corporation, Ellicott City, MD, United States, 2Johns Hopkins University, Baltimore, MD, United States, 3Canon Medical Systems Corporation, Tochigi, Japan, 4University of Wisconsin, Madison, WI, United States
Synopsis
Keywords: Aging, Aging, thalamus
Motivation: Brain shrinkage does not happen to all areas uniformly and could be sex dependent.
Goal(s): We aimed to assess cross-sectionally the interactive effects of age and hypertension on the subcortical volumes and asymmetries in normal adult brains.
Approach: Brain structural images were acquired in 147 normal volunteers at a 3T scanner.
Results: All volumes demonstrated negative correlation with age but only the thalamic volume in both sexes, and the putamen volume in women reached the threshold of statistical significance of P=0.007. The thalamic asymmetry was the only measure that showed positive correlation to hypertension in women.
Impact: Among seven subcortical structures examined, the thalamic volume
demonstrated a negative association with age in normal adult brains. Further
research is needed to correlate this finding with cognition.
Introduction
Age-associated brain atrophy has been well
studied. However, brain shrinkage does not happen to all areas uniformly and
could be sex dependent. Many factors contribute to brain volume loss including
genetic and environmental surrounding, socioeconomic status and cardiovascular
risk factors but the degree of impact is less understood. The two hemispheres
of the human brain are asymmetric functionally and structurally. Brain
structural asymmetries might provide important clues to the neuroanatomical
basis of lateralized brain functions. Characterizing subcortical asymmetries
besides the absolute volume can increase sensitivity to pathological changes in
neurological disease. However, subcortical asymmetries are subtle and requires
accurate parcellation. Indeed, inconsistent results have been reported, and
there is no consensus of biological normal ranges of subcortical asymmetries. There
are also open questions of how variability in brain asymmetry relates to
biological (e.g. age, sex) or modifiable risk variables (e.g. hypertension,
smoking, diabetes, etc.). In this study, we aimed to assess cross-sectionally
the interactive effects of age and hypertension on the subcortical volumes and
asymmetries in normal adult brains. Methods
All participants were
imaged using a 3T MRI systems (Galan, Canon Medical Systems, Japan). Brain structural
images were acquired in sagittal orientation using a 3D magnetization-prepared
rapid-acquisition gradient echo with 1-mm isotropic resolution. Segmentation and
parcellation of the cortical mantle were processed using default parameters in
FreeSurfer v7.2. Seven subcortical brain structures including thalamus,
caudate, putamen, globus pallidus, hippocampus, amygdala, and nucleus accumbens
were segmented. Asymmetry = (Left – Right)/(Left + Right). Sex difference were
examined by Mann-Whitney U test for continuous variables, and Fisher’s exact
test for categorial variables. Data were stratified by sex. Wilcoxon
signed-rank test was used for comparison between right and left subcortical
volumes. Multivariable regression was conducted for the relationship between subcortical
geometry (i.e. volume and asymmetry) and age or hypertension co-adjusted for BMI
and diabetes. The significance threshold was Bonferroni-adjusted to 0.007 for
the analysis of seven subcortical structures. Results
One hundred and
forty-seven adult participants (mean age 50±13, 56% women) with no history of any neurological or psychiatric
disorder were included in the study (Table 1).
All subcortical volumes showed difference between left and right (P<0.001)
except globus pallidus in men (P=0.1). In both men and women, volumes of the thalamus
and the globus pallidus were larger on the left side. All other structures were
larger on the right side. Results were similar between women and men. Total
volume (right+left) and asymmetry of each subcortical brain structure
stratified by sex is displayed in Table 2. In all segments (with the exception of nucleus accumbens,
P=0.52), men demonstrated larger subcortical volumes than women (all P≤0.007). However,
there was no difference between sex in the asymmetries of all subcortical
structures. Association of subcortical geometries with age and
hypertension stratified by sex are presented in Table 3. The
thalamic volume in both sexes (P<0.007) and the putamen volume in women
(P=0.004) were negatively associated with age. Figure 1 shows the relationship
of thalamic volume to age. There was no relationship between asymmetry and age.
Thalamic asymmetry was the only measure that showed positive correlation to
hypertension in women (P=0.007). Discussion
The present
study analyzed the sexual dimorphism in subcortical geometry and the association
between each subcortical geometry and age/hypertension in normal adult brains. Differences by sex were present in the volumes
of subcortical structures but not to the asymmetries. Age-related atrophy was
demonstrated in the thalamus, while lower putamen volume with older age was
only observed in women, and was generally absent in the other subcortical
structures. We found greater thalamic asymmetry in women with hypertension,
otherwise hypertension has no impact in the subcortical structures. It is known
that anatomical features of the brain are lateralized but these findings have
not been consistent across studies[1, 2]. Our
results are generally in agreement with the meta-analysis conducted by Guadalupe et al. in 15,847 people from
52 studies worldwide[1]. Although
we did not assess the handedness of our participants, handedness was previously
found to have no association with subcortical asymmetry[1]. The
effect of hypertension to the subcortical structures is less studied. We found
greater thalamic asymmetry in women with hypertension, otherwise hypertension
has no impact on subcortical structures of the brain. Conclusions
Among all subcortical segments, we confirmed that the thalamus
demonstrated age-related shrinkage across the adult lifespan, but the asymmetry
was preserved. Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1] Guadalupe
T, Mathias SR, vanErp TGM, Whelan CD, Zwiers MP, Abe Y, et al. Human
subcortical brain asymmetries in 15,847 people worldwide reveal effects of age
and sex. Brain Imaging Behav 2017;11(5):1497-514.
[2] Kong XZ, Postema MC, Guadalupe T, de
Kovel C, Boedhoe PSW, Hoogman M, et al. Mapping brain asymmetry in health and
disease through the ENIGMA consortium. Hum Brain Mapp 2022;43(1):167-81.