Ana Beatriz Solana1,2, Brice Fernandez3, Nikou L Damestani2, Tobias C Wood2, Steven CR Williams2, and Florian Wiesinger1,2
1GE HealthCare, Munich, Germany, 2King's College London, London, United Kingdom, 3GE HealthCare, Buc, France
Synopsis
Keywords: fMRI Acquisition, fMRI, silent, Looping Star, pulse sequence design, non-cartesian reconstruction
Motivation: Silent Looping Star fMRI offers unique advantages for neuroscience investigation, but image quality is affected by undersampling artifacts.
Goal(s): Here, we describe novel methods for improving the spatiotemporal encoding efficiency of Looping Star and thereby further advance its utility for silent fMRI.
Approach: A new Looping Star encoding scheme which adds extra out-of-plane oscillations and thereby improves overall encoding efficiency is introduced and combined with auto-calibrated cgSENSE parallel imaging reconstruction.
Results: The sharpest, most intensity uniform images and lowest background noise are demonstrated by the combination of both enhancements while maintaining BOLD sensitivity in a simultaneous, combined visual and auditory fMRI task.
Impact: The combination of a new trajectory and auto-calibrated parallel
imaging leads to sharper and more uniform silent fMRI images with reduced
streaking artifacts as demonstrated visually and on a visual-auditory fMRI task.
Introduction
Looping Star is a novel multi gradient echo
(GRE) acquisition scheme1. Its singular features include quiet
scanning (≤ 15dBA within scanner ambient acoustic noise), 3D isotropic image
encoding, high sampling efficiency, and acquisition of a free-induction decay
(FID) image. So far, Looping Star has been demonstrated for quiet T2*
BOLD functional MRI (fMRI) and high-resolution susceptibility weighted
structural MR imaging1-4. In this work, we describe further
enhancements of Looping Star in terms of 1) image encoding efficiency and 2)
auto-calibrated parallel imaging.Methods
Figure 1 explains Looping Star (bottom row) as a
modification of standard ZTE (top row) for time-multiplexed gradient-echo refocusing
(middle row). Two enhancements are presented in this work.
Image
encoding: Gradient-refocusing is achieved by choosing spokes so that their
cumulative trajectory rewinds back into the center of k-space. Figure 2 shows a
conventional polygonal Looping Star k-space trajectory and a more efficient encoding
trajectory, named wave trajectory, which includes an extra out-of-plane oscillation.
Image reconstruction: Conventional Looping Star image
reconstruction is based on 3D nearest-neighbor gridding (nnGRID), followed by
Fourier transformation and root-sum-of-square coil combination1. To enhance spatiotemporal encoding performance, parallel imaging in
form of conjugate-gradient coil sensitivity encoding (cgSENSE)5,6 including coil
compression and noise pre-whitening was implemented. The single coil FID images
were used as pseudo coil sensitivities maps thereby providing intrinsic
normalization of the reconstructed images (i.e., normalized relative to the complex
FID image) such that the obtained GRE images can be used directly for
quantitative T2* and/or susceptibility mapping. Since Looping Star acquires FID
and GRE data simultaneously and with identical spatial encoding, the FID pseudo
coil sensitivity maps perfectly match the GRE images without being affected by
spatiotemporal incongruity due to, e.g., motion, geometric distortions, or
resampling errors.
Acquisition: Healthy
volunteers were scanned on a 3T SIGNATM Premier scanner (GE HealthCare, Chicago,
IL) using a 48-channel head coil. Single-echo (FID+GRE) and dual-echo (FID+2GRE, parameters listed in brackets) fMRI Looping Star scans were acquired with the following parameters: 24(16) spokes per loop, BW=±31.25kHz(±41.625kHz), FOV=(19.2cm)^3, resolution=(3mm)^3, FA=3º(2)º, TEs=[0,26.88]ms([0,14.3,28.6])ms. A silent sub-millimeter T1-weighted ZTE scan was also obtained as
an anatomical reference.
Visual-auditory
task: A combined asynchronous visual and auditory fMRI
paradigm was applied involving an 8Hz visual checkerboard with 30s duration and 30s break between
blocks and a variable speed English words recording (30 to 120 words per minute)
with 24s duration and 24s break between blocks. Single-echo Looping Star fMRI (FID+GRE) was
run for 4:38 min, and the same data was reconstructed with nnGRID and with
auto-calibrated cgSENSE.
fMRI Pre-processing & Analysis:
Steady-state signal stabilization was corrected for by
removing the first 4 volumes from the fMRI datasets. Pre-processing included
motion correction using McFLIRT7, smoothing with 6mm FWHM kernel and
registration to the T1w silent structural scan using FLIRT8. First
level GLM with the regressors of interest being the hemodynamic response
function convolved with the interleaved auditory and visual paradigm block
designs was used to obtain two activation maps, one for each task from the same
acquisition. Activation maps were considered statistically significant using
clusters determined by Z>3 and a (corrected) cluster significance threshold
of P=0.059.Results
Figure 3 shows dual-echo (FID+2GRE)
Looping Star (TE=[0,14.3,28.6]ms) reconstructed with nnGRID and cgSENSE. For cgSENSE, the FID images
are illustrated via the first four compressed coil sensitivity maps. Enhanced
image quality with the auto-calibrated cgSENSE reconstruction can be
appreciated via reduced streaking artifacts, decreased background signal, and
increased sharpness. More uniform tSNR maps are obtained for cgSENSE although
with reduced maximum magnitude.
Figure
4 compares single-echo (FID+GRE) Looping Star (TE=[0,26.88ms]) using the
conventional versus the wave trajectory for nnGRID and cgSENSE. Best image
quality is obtained by the combination of wave Looping Star encoding and
cgSENSE reconstruction (i.e., bottom right subplot) and indicated by arrows in
the image.
Visual and
auditory statistical BOLD activation maps for nnGRID and cgSENSE reconstruction
in one representative volunteer are shown in Figure 5 together with the temporal
response signal at the peak voxel. Results with both reconstructions were found
equivalent in localization but cgSENSE revealed slightly better localized and
increased percentage BOLD signal response than nnGRID (~2% for auditory response and ~4% for
visual response)Conclusion
Enhanced image quality in terms of intensity
uniformity, sharpness, and reduced streaking artifacts, for silent
fMRI using Looping Star has been demonstrated by using
auto-calibrated parallel imaging and an enhanced image encoding approach. Future
work will focus on further improvement of spatiotemporal encoding efficiency
and SNR performance.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Wiesinger F, Menini A, Solana AB. Looping star. Magn Reson Med. 2019;81(1):57-68
2.
Dionisio-Parra B, Wiesinger F, Sämann PG, Czisch M, Solana AB. Looping star fMRI in cognitive tasks and resting state. J Magn
Reson Imaging. 2020;52(3):739-751.
3.
Damestani NL, O’Daly O, Solana AB, et al. Revealing the mechanisms behind novel auditory stimuli discrimination: An evaluation of silent functional MRI using looping star. Hum Brain Mapp. 2021 Jun 15;42(9):2833-2850.
4.
Ljungberg E, Damestani NL, Wood TC, et al. Silent
zero TE MR neuroimaging: current state-of-the-art and future directions. Prog
Nucl Magn Reson Spectrosc. 2021;123:73-93.
5.
Pruessmann
KP, Weiger M, Börnert P, Boesiger P. Advances in sensitivity encoding with
arbitrary k-space trajectories. Magn Reson Med. 2001;46(4):638-651.
6.
Wood TC,
Ljungberg E, Wiesinger F. Radial Interstices Enable Speedy Low-volume Imaging.
J. Open Source Softw. 2021; 6:3500.
7.
Jenkinson, M., Bannister, P., Brady, J. M. and
Smith, S. M. Improved Optimisation for the Robust and Accurate Linear
Registration and Motion Correction of Brain Images. NeuroImage, 17(2), 825-841,
2002.
8.
M. Jenkinson
and S.M. Smith. A global optimisation method for robust affine registration of
brain images. Medical Image Analysis, 5(2):143-156, 2001.
9.
K.J. Worsley.
Statistical analysis of activation images. Ch 14, in Functional MRI: An
Introduction to Methods, eds. P. Jezzard, P.M. Matthews and S.M. Smith. OUP,
2001.