Johnes Obungoloch1, Adesola Emmauel Adepoju2, Petronella Samuels3,4, Mary-Jane Orevaoghene Amadi5, Segun Joseph Ayilara 6, Mary Kamuzora 7, Klenam Dzefi-Tettey 8, Anthonia A Ikpeme 9, Frances Robertson3, Udunna Anazodo 10, Chip Truwit 11, Farouk Dako12, Andrew Webb13, Yaw B Mensah 8, Iris Asllani14,15, Ernesta Meintjes 3,16, and Godwin Ogbole2
1Mbarara University of Science and Technology, Mbarara, Uganda, Mbarara, Uganda, 2Department of Radiology, College of Medicine, University of Ibadan, Ibadan, Nigeria, 3Biomedical Engineering Research Centre, Division of Biomedical Engineering, University of Cape Town, South Africa, Cape Town, South Africa, 4Department of Human Biology, Faculty of Health Sciences, University of Cape Town, South Africa, CapeTown, South Africa, 5Rivers State University Teaching Hospital, Port Harcourt, Nigeria, 6Department of Radiology, University College Hospital, Ibadan, Nigeria, 7Department of Radiology, Muhimbili National Hospital-Mloganzila, Dar-es-salaam, Tanzania, 8Department of Radiology, Korle Bu Teaching Hospital, Accra, Ghana, 9Department of Radiology, University of Calabar teaching Hospital, Calabar, Nigeria, 10Montreal Neurological Institute, McGill University, Montreal, QC, Canada, 11Hyperfine Inc, St. Guilford, CT, United States, 12Perelman School of Medicine, University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, PA, United States, 13C. J. Gorter MRI Center, Department of Radiology, Leiden University Medical Center, Leiden, Netherlands, 14Clinical Imaging Science Centre, University of Sussex,, Sussex, United Kingdom, 15Department of Biomedical Engineering, Rochester Institute of Technology, Rochester, NY, United States, 16Cape Universities Body Imaging Centre, University of Cape Town, CapeTown, South Africa
Synopsis
Keywords: Low-Field MRI, Low-Field MRI, Networking, Innovation
Motivation: Due to rising non-communicable diseases, limited MRI accessibility, and Africa's underrepresentation in ISMRM, the African Chapter (AC) was founded in 2023. An inaugural conference in Ghana focused on emerging MRI technology for improved accessibility.
Goal(s): To provide the inaugural conference report of AC-ISMRM, with the identification of challenges and barriers to MRI access and propose solutions toward democratization of MRI across Africa.
Approach: A white paper approach was adopted
Results: Over 100 scientists from 12 African countries met to identify challenges and propose solutions for advancing MRI access and value in Africa. Low-field MRI was identified as a breakthrough innovation toward this goal.
Impact: The AC-ISMRM conference marks a pioneer event, convening African scientists and clinicians, aimed at establishing a network dedicated to rectify Africa's underrepresentation in MRI research, seeking solutions to challenges on the continent and promoting collaboration and MRI advancements
Introduction
The International Society for
Magnetic Resonance in Medicine (ISMRM) was founded nearly three decades ago
with the overarching mission of promoting worldwide communication, research,
and the application of MR in medicine, biology, and related domains. The
organization is committed to ensuring that scientists and clinicians from all
corners of the globe have equal opportunities to engage in and contribute to
this scientific realm. While ISMRM's influence has been steadily growing on a
global scale, Africa's representation, both in terms of membership and research
contributions, has been notably limited.
Up until 2018, Africa
represented a meager 0.05% of ISMRM's overall membership, and only a small
fraction of those members held active status. Out of a community comprising
over 9,000 professionals from a wide array of disciplines, just 4 individuals from
Africa met the criteria to participate in ISMRM committees. However, a pivotal
moment transpired at the 2023 ISMRM meeting in Toronto when over 40 African
members gathered to create a landmark initiative, officially founding the
African Chapter (AC) of ISMRM, aimed at rectifying this imbalance.
A little over three months after, from September 27 to
30, 2023, the AC ISMRM successfully organized a workshop and hosted its
inaugural annual meeting in Accra, Ghana. These events were dedicated to the
exploration of emerging MRI technologies, encompassing both hardware and
software, with the potential to address the specific needs of African countries
where MRI accessibility has been historically limited1-3. Here, we
present the key outcomes of the conference, illuminate the distinct challenges
and opportunities in the advancement of MRI within the continent, and delineate
practical goals aimed at closing the existing gaps in MRI education and
research throughout AfricaDemographics
As
of October 9, 2023, approximately four months since its establishment, the AC
ISMRM boasts 252 registered members, comprising 190 full members and 62
associates, representing 25 countries. Membership spans across all regions of
Africa, with a small diaspora representation of 8 members (3%),
Figure-1a. Radiographers (78 members, 31%) and Radiologists (58 members, 23%)
form the most prominent professional groups, followed by Biomedical Engineers
(52 members, 20%), Figure-1bPre-conference Workshop
The two-day workshop
drew 102 participants from the 215 individuals who registered through the AC
ISMRM website. Attendees represented 14 countries, with Ghana leading (59%), followed by Nigeria (17%), Figure-2. By profession,
Radiographers comprised the largest group (34%), followed by Biomedical
Engineers (24%), Figure-2The Inaugural AC ISMRM Conference
The two-day conference
attracted 112 attendees, with 45 registering onsite and the rest via the AC
ISMRM website. Participants hailed from 12 countries, both within and outside
Africa, Figure 3. Notably, the professional composition of the conference
attendees differed from that of the workshop, Figure 3. The largest group
consisted of "MRI allied professions" (38%), while Radiologists and
Radiographers each comprised 22% of the attendees.Conference program
The conference's theme
centred on advancing MRI technology and fostering innovation in Africa.
Keynote speakers included Prof. Derek Jones, current president of ISMRM, who discussed advanced MRI
techniques, and Prof. James Gee, who explored the potential of AI in enhancing
MRI diagnostics. The conference featured five scientific sessions covering
various aspects of MRI technology, education, neuroimaging, clinical
applications, and imaging in low-resource settings. Moreover, 8 students from 4 different African
countries showcased their research through Pitch talks and Scientific poster presentations.Barriers and Challenges
Limited access to MRI was
identified as the primary impediment to MRI advancement in Africa. For example,
in Sub-Saharan Africa, the number of MRI scanners per million people was <1,
and a concerning 39% of those systems were obsolete yet still in use to meet clinical
demands2. This is exacerbated by the crucial need for improvements
to the maintenance and servicing of these systems. Computational constraints,
which hinder the adoption of AI tools, remain a challenge. Education and "brain drain" were
also recognized as obstacles to MRI research and utility in Africa. Turning obstacles into unique opportunities
Developing low-field MRI
emerged as a major opportunity for advancement of MRI through reduced costs and
portability. Participants emphasized the importance of open-source software and
appropriate sequence selection to leverage MRI's unique capabilities. Training opportunities
within the continent were identified as a way to increase participation and
cross-discipline/cross-country collaborations4. Networking was seen
as vital for securing funding, mentoring, and research output. Collaboration
with other scientific societies in the continent was recognized as an
opportunity for strengthening AC ISMRM. Bolstering ties with manufacturers was
suggested to develop sustainable MRI in the continent. Conclusions
Building upon the success of
the inaugural AC ISMRM Conference, the chapter aims to expand its membership
and enhance the engagement of French-speaking countries. Working together will synergize the
advancement of MRI in Africa.Acknowledgements
We express our deep appreciation to all
the sponsors, partners, speakers, volunteers, and attendees for their
invaluable contributions to the conference's resounding success. Our heartfelt
thanks go to the dedicated Accra Conference LOC team. We are also indebted to
the ISMRM leadership and the ISMRM African Chapter Inaugural Governance
Committee for their pivotal roles in making this conference a reality.
Special recognition is extended to the
following sponsors: Chan Zuckerberg Initiative (CZI); CZI_SMART Africa; Bill
and Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF);
RAD-AID International; African
Stroke Organization; College of
Medicine, University of Ibadan, Nigeria;
EURACARE Ghana; WAM Pharma-GE; Consortium for Advancement of MRI
Education and Research in Africa (CAMERA);
HYPERFINE INC.; EASE Nigeria.
References
1.
Webb A, Obungoloch J. Five steps
to make MRI scanners more affordable to the world. Nature. 2023
Mar;615(7952):391-393. doi: 10.1038/d41586-023-00759-x. PMID: 36918678.
2.
Ogbole, G.I., A.O. Adeyomoye, A. Badu-Peprah, Y. Mensah and D.A. Nzeh, Survey of magnetic resonance imaging availability
in West Africa. The Pan African Medical Journal, 30, 2018.
3.
Anazodo, U.C., J.J. Ng, B. Ehiogu, J. Obungoloch, A. Fatade, H.
Mutsaerts, M.F. Secca, M. Diop, A. Opadele, D.C. Alexander, M.O. Dada, Ogbole,
G.I., R. Nunes, P. Figueiredo, M. Figini, B. Aribisala, B.O. Awojoyogbe, H.
Aduluwa, C. Sprenger, R. Wagner, A. Olakunle, D. Romeo, Y. Sun, F. Fezeu, A.T.
Orunmuyi, S. Geethanath, V. Gulani, E.C. Nganga, S. Adeleke, N. Ntobeuko, F.J.
Minja, A.G. Webb, I. Asllani and F. Dako, A
framework for advancing sustainable magnetic resonance imaging access in
Africa. NMR Biomed. 36(3): p.
e4846. (2023).
4. Ogbole G.I , Adepoju
A.E, Ibrahim A., Togunwa T.O, Nkeakam
F.A, MRI training in Africa. 2023 Annals of Ibadan Postgraduate
(Accepted: in press )