Martin Francis Phelan1 and Metin Sitti1,2,3,4
1Physical Intelligence, Max Planck Institute for Intelligent Systems, Stuttgart, Germany, 2Mechanical Engineering, Carnegie Mellon University, Pittsburgh, PA, United States, 3Institute for Biomedical Engineering, ETH Zurich, Zurich, Switzerland, 4College of Engineering and School of Medicine, Koç University, Istanbul, Turkey
Synopsis
Keywords: Atherosclerosis, Atherosclerosis, Mechanical Thrombectomy
MR angiography provides high resolution visualization of blood vessels for analyzing arterial occlusions. However, these conditions require the use of a guidewire/catheter for treatment. Catheters integrated with microcoils for actuation under the high (3-7 Tesla), uniform magnetic field within magnetic resonance (MR) scanners have enabled mechanical removal of arterial occlusions. This work introduces an electromagnetic rotablation design, allowing direct tip torque control for both steering and drilling. Results demonstrate in vitro rotational thrombectomy with torque outputs up to 12 mN·m under MR guidance. These results indicate the high MRI external field can provide rotablation for difficult-to-reach areas of the vasculature.
Introduction
Cardiovascular
disease (CVD) is the leading cause of death worldwide according to the World
Health Organization. One of the most common complications in CVDs known as Deep
Vein Thrombosis (DVT), is highly dangerous because clot formation can break off
and travel to the lung causing a pulmonary embolism (PE). For high-risk PE in
which thrombolysis is too dangerous, mechanical thrombectomy is usually
recommended.
Mechanical
thrombectomy includes fragmentation in which a mechanical device is used to
break up thrombi in pulmonary arteries. Arterial stenosis is also a dangerous
disease caused by calcified deposits that form within the arteries to restrict flow.
Commercial systems exist such as the TurboHawk (Medtronic) or Diamondback
Atherectomy system (Cardiovascular Systems) but are limited by their
high-frequency drilling speeds [2].
In this
work, we present the first MRI-driven, Lorentz-force based direct current
electric motor manufactured out of MRI-compatible components for mechanical removal
of arterial occlusions. The motor operates similarly to a direct current brush
motor, however, the stator (which is typically a permanent magnetic housing),
has been replaced by the B0 field of the MRI. This allows for direct
torque transmission on the catheter tip without influencing the rest of the
soft body.Methods
The
catheter driller was manufactured using aluminum for both the drill bit and
rotor while the housing and commutator were 3D printed. All
components were then assembled together using cyanoacrylate and then heat
shrunk to the catheter tip.
Catheter
driller motion was simulated according to the following equations:
$$τ_{out} = m \times B_o$$
$$τ_{out} = m_1 B_0 cosωt β+m_2 B_0 sin(ωt+2π/3)β+m_3 B_0 sin(ωt+2π/3)β$$
$$β = sin α+cosα$$
$$m_1 = m_2 = m_3 = NIAB_0$$
$$τ_{out} = NIAB_0 (cosωt+2 sin(ωt+ 2π/3)β)$$
where N is the number of
coil loops, I is the coil current, A represents the area of a single coil loop,
and B0 represents the magnetic field vector of the
MRI scanner.
To validate
the model equations, the MRI-driven electric motor performance was characterized
at the maximum performance 90° with respect to the B0
field. Currents up to 500 mA were applied with a 3D printed lever arm mounted across
onto a nonmagnetic force sensor (Futek) to measure torque output. Motor rotation
performance was measured with a high-speed camera under the 7 Tesla preclinical
scanner (Bruker 70/30 BioSpec).
To measure
the drilling performance of the catheter motor, the driller was mounted to a 3D
printed fixture with a linear piezoelectric actuator (Piezomotor) to drive
motion. Silicone tubes of 6 mm in diameter were used to create pseudo-thrombi
using a mixing ratio of 3 wt % agar mixed with red dye, and repeated again using
2 wt % /6 wt % CaCO3 to replicate arterial plaque with similar
currents as stated previously.Results
Results
from drilling characterization demonstrated a maximum torque output of 12 mN·m. A standard DC motor performance curve was constructed using the
maximum rotational rate of the motor with no load speed and maximum torque
output. Figure 2 demonstrates a maximum rotational rate of 1200 RPM and maximum
torque output of 12 mN·m. These results closely aligned
with the numerical model, demonstrating a percent error of 8% across all
trials. The maximum power output is shown to be 0.5 W at half torque-speed
output. Given the dimensions of the proposed driller, the torque output remains
to be above literature standards (5.5 mN·m) at worst-case
scenarios (angles closely aligned with the B0 field vector) as shown
in Figure 3. Figure 4 demonstrates the effectiveness of drilling through pseudo-thrombus
and plaque. Occlusion removal was visually observed for both samples after 10
seconds of drilling.Discussion
This work has
demonstrated the feasibility of making an MRI-driven DC electric motor to be integrated
to the distal end of a catheter for both steering into confined workspaces and
removing arterial occlusions under MR guidance. The final prototype was
machined out of nonmagnetic components (aluminum) to reduce the chances of artifacts
or unintended forces/torques during steering. The maximum torque output was sufficient
to drill through thrombus and plaque within reasonable time frames compared to
literature. The proposed numerical model has shown to be accurate within 8 %
error, which enables further optimization for down-sizing. In vitro experiments replicated thrombus and plaque densities but
future work could be done using real porcine blood to also evaluate heating. However,
current inputs in this work remained within FDA guidelines of 1.2 W. Future experiments
should also include MR guided drilling with guidewire integration instead of
direct piezo actuation as well as fully-submerged drilling under simulated flow
to explore possible clotting effects.Conclusion
Utilization of the strong, permanent, magnetic field
within MRI scanners has proven to be an effective method for direct catheter
tip torque control. We have designed and developed the strongest existing catheter driller in the literature for both steering and drilling. The device has been designed
out of MRI-compatible (non-ferrous)
materials to fit within the cardiovascular system (~ 3 mm diameter) for occlusion removal. In vitro experiments
demonstrated thrombus and plaque removal within 10 seconds along with torque outputs twice that of existing catheter drillers in literature. Continued
development on MRI-driven rotational catheter drilling will enable unique opportunities
for cardiovascular MR imaging.Acknowledgements
This work was funded by the Max Planck Society.References
1. Rousseau, Hervé, et al. "Endovascular
therapies for pulmonary embolism." Heliyon 7.4 (2021):
e06574.
2. Heunis, Christoff M., et al. "Design and
evaluation of a magnetic rotablation catheter for arterial
stenosis." IEEE/ASME transactions on mechatronics 27.3
(2021): 1761-1772.
3. Yaeger, Kurt, et al. "A technical
comparison of thrombectomy vacuum aspiration systems." Journal of
NeuroInterventional Surgery 12.1 (2020): 72-76.
4. Cowled P, Fitridge R. Pathophysiology of
Reperfusion Injury. In: Fitridge R, Thompson M, editors. Mechanisms of Vascular
Disease: A Reference Book for Vascular Specialists [Internet]. Adelaide (AU):
University of Adelaide Press; 2011. 18. Available
from: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK534267/