Qing-San Xiang1
1Radiology, University of British Columbia, Vancouver, BC, Canada
Synopsis
Keywords: Image Reconstruction, Image Reconstruction, water-fat imaging
Water-Fat Imaging with only a single
acquisition is desirable for its pulse sequence simplicity and scan time
efficiency. However, robust
reconstruction is more challenging due to limited available information. In this work, it is discovered that some previously
unused information can be found by statistical analysis, leading to effective
reconstruction of water and fat images.
In particular, Independent Component Analysis (ICA) was used to
determine the phase error. Well
separated water and fat images were subsequently obtained after phase
correction.
Introduction
Since its initial proposal by Dixon1, Water-Fat Imaging
(WFI) has gone a long way into practical applications2. Typically, WFI is performed with two or more
acquisitions, known as “2-point” , “3-point” or “multi-point” WFI to obtain
more information for robust reconstruction of water and fat images, although
the possibility of “single-point WFI” with only one acquisition was proposed
right after Dixon’s original work3,4.
The challenge behind 1-point WFI is its lack of information for proper
phase correction5-8 without having additional signal acquisition. In this work, it is found that Independent Component
Analysis (ICA)9 can be used to uncover previously unused information for
enhanced reconstruction, resulting in well separated water and fat images from
only a single acquisition.Methods
Theory:
The complex image from
a 1-point WFI acquisition can be expressed as,
$$C=(W+iF)P\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;\;(1)$$
where the water (W) and
fat (F) images are acquired in quadrature, namely 90° out of phase, by a
proper offset of echo time TE; $$$P=exp(iΦ)$$$ is a phasor representing the phase
error due to main magnetic field inhomogeneity etc.
If P is known, it can
be simply removed from Equation (1), then the orthogonal real and imaginary channels R & I of the resulting complex image will be the two component images W &
F respectively; otherwise, each channel will in general contain a mixture of
the two components. So, the challenge of achieving water-fat separation is to
find the correct error phasor P.
Independent Component
Analysis (ICA)9 is a powerful statistical tool with which mixed components
such as signal and artifacts (or noise) can be impressively separated by
minimizing a key quantity known as Mutual Information (MI). As another application of ICA, here W & F
images are separated from the mixed complex image acquired.
In this work, various
phase correction values were applied while the quantity MI9 between the resulting
R & I images were computed. It was
found that MI is minimized when R & I represent the correct W & F
images. This way, a minimization of MI by tuning P will enable the error phasor
to be found. Such tuning procedure can
be applied regionally if the phase error is spatially varying.
Experiments:
Complex images were
acquired from human subjects on 1.5T clinical scanners using spin-echo sequences. The angle between W and F
components were chosen to be (0°, 90°, 180°). Decent Water and Fat images
were reconstructed from the full dataset with 3 acquisitions2. These images
were used as gold standard for comparison.
The middle quadrature dataset acquired at 90° only was used to
test the proposed ICA method.Results
Figure
1 includes Water and Fat images (W & F) obtained from the full dataset at
(0°, 90°, 180°) using proven 3-point reconstruction algorithm2.
Figure 2 represents real and imaginary parts (R
& I) of the uncorrected complex image C, as described by Equation(1). An
arbitrary global phase rotation of 60° was applied to create a zero’th
order phase error across the entire FOV. W & F components were mixed in
both R & I.
Figure 3 shows well
separated resulting W and F images after MI minimization. The phase error was
determined to be 59.0° + 1.0° that was consistent with the known
value of 60°.
Figure 4 is a pair of R
& I images with rather strong spatially varying phase errors across the
FOV, as often seen in a clinical scan.
Figure 5 shows resulting W & F images after an MI
minimization with regional linear 1st order phase tuning10. These were consistent with those obtained from the full 3-point dataset
with (0°, 90°, 180°) sampling scheme.Discussion
A
statistical approach to 1-point Water-Fat Imaging is introduced. It uses the powerful ICA technique to achieve
effective phase correction by MI minimization, leading to well separated water
and fat images. In vivo data were used to demonstrate the method. The newly uncovered information can also be
used to improve WFI reconstruction with two or more acquisitions.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1] Dixon WT. Simple proton spectroscopic imaging. Radiology.
1984;153:189-194.
[2] Hu HH, et al. ISMRM Workshop on Fat–Water Separation: Insights,
Applications and
Progress in MRI, Magn Reson Med, 2012; 68:378-388.
[3] Paltiel Z. Separate water and lipids images obtained by a single
scan, In: Proceedings of the 4th Annual Meeting of SMRM, New York, USA, 1985,
p172-173.
[4] Patrick JL, Haacke EM, Hahn JE. Water/fat separation and chemical
shift artifact correction using a single scan. In: Proceedings of the 4th
Annual Meeting of SMRM, New York, USA, 1985. p174-175.
[5] Ahn CB, et al. Spectroscopic imaging by quadrature modulated echo
time shifting, Magn Reson Imaging. 1986; 4:110-111.
[6] Xiang QS. Improved single point water-fat imaging with virtual shimming.
In: Proceedings of the 9th Annual Scientific Meeting of the ISMRM, Glasgow,
Scotland, 2001. p789.
[7] Ma J. A single-point Dixon technique for fat-suppressed fast 3D
gradient-echo imaging with a flexible echo time. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2008; 27:881-890.
[8] Son JB, et al. Single-Point Dixon
Water-Fat Imaging Using 64-Channel Single Echo Acquisition MRI, Concepts in
Magnetic Resonance Part B. 2008; 33B(3):152-162.
[9]
Hyvärinen A and Erkki O. Independent
Component Analysis: Algorithms and Applications. Neural
Networks. 2000;13:411-430.
[10] Ahn CB and Cho ZH. A New Phase Correction Method in
NMR Imaging Based on Autocorrelation and Histogram Analysis. IEEE Trans Med Imaging. 1987; MI-6(1), 32-36.