Zhilang Qiu1, Siyuan Hu1, Walter Zhao1, Ken Sakaie2, Mark A. Griswold3, Derek K. Jones4, and Dan Ma1
1Biomedical Engineering, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, United States, 2Imaging Institute, Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, United States, 3Radiology, Case Western Reserve University, Cleveland, OH, United States, 4Cardiff University Brain Research Imaging Centre (CUBRIC), School of Psychology, Cardiff University, Cardiff, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Keywords: MR Fingerprinting/Synthetic MR, Diffusion/other diffusion imaging techniques
We propose a self-calibrated subspace reconstruction method
for multidimensional MR Fingerprinting (mdMRF) scan for simultaneous relaxation
and diffusion mapping without pulsation gating. It is distortion-free, unlike
EPI-based diffusion MRI. MRF images corrupted by phase errors due to bulk and physiological
motions are automatically detected using an outlier detection algorithm and
corrected, in order to generate artifact-free relaxation and diffusion maps.
Introduction
MR Fingerprinting (MRF) [1] is a fast
quantitative imaging technique for simultaneous multi-parameter mapping. Previously,
a multidimensional MRF (mdMRF) framework was developed for joint relaxation-diffusion
quantification [2], which enables reliable quantification of compartment-specific
microstructural properties.
Because mdMRF employs diffusion-prepared SSFP readouts [3-5],
eddy currents or motion (bulk or physiological) induced phase errors could
affect image magnitude and phase, resulting in shading artifacts in the maps. To
reduce shading artifacts caused by signal dropouts and phase variations due to
brain pulsation during diffusion encodings, peripheral pulsation gating was
used. However, the optimal delay time from the pulse peak is subject-dependent,
which greatly limits method robustness and result quality. This is further
complicated by additional physiologic motions, such as cerebrospinal fluid
pulsation and bulk motion, besides cardiac pulsation. There are also scan
efficiency reduction due to irregular cardiac cycles, and reconstruction issues
when extended to 3D because of shot-to-shot timing inconsistency.
Here, we propose to address the shading artifacts in mdMRF without
pulsation gating using a self-calibrated subspace reconstruction method. Aliasing-free
high-resolution images can be accurately reconstructed, such that the corrupted
segments (or images) can be detected by a customized outlier detection algorithm,
and finally corrected (excluded) to achieve artifact-free relaxation and
diffusion maps.Method
Sequence: As in reference [2], the sequence is
composed of multiple acquisition segments, each starting with a preparation
module (T1 inversion, T2 preparation, or diffusion preparation). In this work, we
used linear encoding (LTE) for diffusion preparation and FISP for MRF readout.
Reconstruction: Figure 1 shows the flowchart of the
proposed self-calibrated reconstruction consisting of two main procedures. The
first one is to obtain fully sampled low-resolution calibration data from under-sampled
central k-space using temporally local (segment-wise) low-rank matrix
completion, which applies low-rank matrix completion [6, 7] for each segment
separately.
The second procedure is to obtain the aliasing-free
full-resolution images from the under-sampled whole k-space, using subspace
reconstruction, where the subspace is estimated from the calibration data obtained
in the first procedure. A temporally global subspace was used here because it benefits
from global data sharing and provides significantly improved image quality compared
to a temporally local subspace.
Correction: Corrupted segments (or images) were
detected using a customized outlier detection algorithm and excluded in the
mapping step. Briefly, in the detection algorithm, the sum of the phase
difference between the first and the last images for each segment is used for
detection.
Parameter Mapping: A dictionary was simulated following
[2] and corrected by excluding segments corresponding to corrupted images.
Pattern matching [1] was performed to generate T1, T2, M0, and ADC maps.
Acquisition: A healthy volunteer was scanned under
IRB approval on a 3T Prisma scanner (Siemens Healthineers, Erlangen, Germany) using
a 32-channel head coil. Two mdMRF scans (with and without peripheral pulsation
gating) were acquired to evaluate the proposed method. In each mdMRF
scan, 28 acquisition segments, each with 96 images, were acquired with the
following scan parameters: TI (21 ms); TE (30, 50, 65 ms); b values (300, 700,
1000 s/mm2) with three diffusion
directions; SSFP with constant flip angles of 10 degrees; FOV 300x300mm2; resolution 1.5x1.5mm2; slice thickness 5mm. The
scan time was 26s for both scans. A conventional MRF scan [8] was performed as
a reference for T1 and T2 quantifications, and an EPI-based diffusion scan was
also acquired for ADC reference.Results
Figure 2 shows reconstructed images using the proposed
self-calibrated subspace reconstruction. In the corrupted segments, there are magnitude variations (signal dropouts) and phase variations along the temporal
dimension (Figure 2B). Typically, the magnitude and phase variations
also exhibit spatial distribution (Figure 2A).
Figure 3 shows the comparison of quantitative maps obtained using
the proposed self-calibrated mdMRF and non-calibrated mdMRF, both without
pulsation gating, as well as reference. While T1 and T2 maps are consistent
between non-calibrated mdMRF and self-calibrated mdMRF, ADC comparison reveals
severe shading artifacts in non-calibrated mdMRF, which appears as
significantly uneven and overestimated ADC values. These shading artifacts are
not observed on the ADC map from self-calibrated mdMRF.
Similarly, Figure 4 compares quantitative maps obtained using
the three methods, but with pulsation gating, to avoid phase variation caused
by cardiac pulsation [1]. However, it failed in this case. Shading artifacts
still exist in the ADC map of the non-calibrated mdMRF. The shading artifacts can
be addressed in the self-calibrated mdMRF.
Figure 5 shows the quantitative analysis for six ROIs. While
T1 and T2 values remain consistent between non-calibrated mdMRF and
self-calibrated mdMRF, ADC values are significantly overestimated in the former
while. Self-calibrated mdMRF provides highly accurate ADC values. Compared to the
reference (conventional EPI-based diffusion MRI), there are no geometric
distortions observed in self-calibrated mdMRF. T2 values in both mdMRFs are
slightly higher than the reference (the conventional MRF), this may be from differences
in signal modeling [2].Discussion and Conclusion
In this work, we proposed and evaluated a self-calibrated subspace
reconstruction method for mdMRF without gating, to retrospectively address
shading artifacts in mdMRF caused by measurement errors. We demonstrate that self-calibrated
mdMRF allows for a more flexible sequence design and improves scan efficiency by
removing the need for pulsation gating, and provides robust and accurate
relaxation and diffusion maps.Acknowledgements
This work was supported by Siemens Healthineers and NIH grant R01 NS109439.References
1. Ma D, et al. Magnetic
resonance fingerprinting. Nature. 2013;495:187-192.
2. Afzali M, et al.
MR Fingerprinting with b‐Tensor
Encoding for Simultaneous Quantification of Relaxation and Diffusion in a
Single Scan. Magn Reson Med. 2022;88:2043-2057.
3. Jeong EK, et al.
High-resolution diffusion-weighted 3D MRI, using diffusion-weighted
driven-equilibrium (DW-DE) and multishot segmented 3D-SSFP without navigator
echoes. Magn Reson Med. 2003;50:821-829.
4. Nguyen C, et al. In vivo
three-dimensional high resolution cardiac diffusion-weighted MRI: a motion
compensated diffusion-prepared balanced steady-state free precession approach. Magn
Reson Med. 2014;72:1257-1267.
5. Lu L, et al. Diffusion‐prepared fast imaging with steady‐state free precession (DP‐FISP): a rapid diffusion MRI technique at 7 T. Magn
Reson Med. 2012;68:868-73.
6. Candes E, Recht B. Exact
matrix completion via convex optimization. Communications of the ACM. 2012 Jun
1;55(6):111-9.
7. Doneva M, et al. Matrix
completion-based reconstruction for undersampled magnetic resonance
fingerprinting data. Magn Reson Imaging. 2017;41:41-52.
8. Jiang Y, et al. MR
fingerprinting using fast imaging with steady state precession (FISP) with
spiral readout. Magn Reson Med. 2015;74:1621-1631.