Why Go to Super-High Fields (SHF) & What Are the Challenges?
Mark D Bird1
1National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, FL, United States
Synopsis
The
Iseult magnet has reached the limit of human MRI with traditional NbTi superconductor.
Higher field will require Nb3Sn that has been used for preclinical
MRI and large scale fusion magnets. Meeting all constraints of a clinical
system at 14 T or higher presents new challenges. REBCO has enabled high-resolution
NMR to jump from 23.5 T to 28.2 T and shows potential for NMR at 35 T and human
MRI at 20 T. Using resistive materials, NMR is being done at up to 35.2 T dc
with ~1 ppm resolution while 55 T is possible for short pulses.
MRI
at higher fields gives a higher signal-to-noise ratio. The mouse-brain images
in Figure 1 are taken at 21.1 T (left) and 9.4 T (right) using the same spin
echo pulse sequence and imaging parameters. Presently human head imaging is
limited to less than 12 T (≤ 500
MHz). Going to 14.1 T (600 MHz) will require using Nb3Sn
superconductors in human head magnets for the first time. While this technology
has been used for decades in high field magnets such as small animal MRI (Fig.
1) and large magnets for fusion and condensed matter physics (Fig. 2), this
conductor is approximately ten times the cost of the NbTi superconductor
traditionally used for human MRI magnets and the clinical environment is not
conducive to the protection technologies traditionally used for large magnets.
High
resolution NMR (~10 ppb) is now possible at much higher fields due to the
advent of magnets based on the High Temperature Superconductors (HTS). In the
past few years fields available have jumped from 23.4 T (1.0 GHz) to 2.8.2 T
(1.2 GHz) with five systems delivered as of October 2021 and at least five more
on order. This technology shows promise of enabling NMR at still higher fields
with two groups worldwide pursuing 30.5 T (1.3 GHz) NMR and the MagLab
developing a 40 T superconducting magnet for condensed matter physics.
Human
head MRI magnets at the 20 T level will likely become possible in coming years
by scaling up these high resolution HTS magnets to a scale similar to that of
the present Iseult magnet. Importantly, tHigh resolution NMR (~10 ppb) is now
possible at much higher fields due to the advent of magnets based on the High
Temperature Superconductors (HTS). In the past few years fields available have
jumped from 23.4 T (1.0 GHz) to 28.2 T (1.2 GHz) with five systems delivered as
of October 2021 and at least five more on order. This technology shows promise
of enabling NMR at still higher fields with two groups worldwide pursuing 30.5
T (1.3 GHz) NMR and the MagLab developing a 40 T superconducting magnet for
condensed matter physicshe HTS materials not only function at higher field than
the traditional NbTi and Nb3Sn, they also operate at much higher current
density. Hence, the size of a 20 T MRI magnet might not be larger than that of
the present 11.7 T Iseult magnet. While a 20 T heam MRI magnet will require
~1,000-fold larger HTS coils than those presently used in NMR coils, the fusion
community is hard at work building large-scale HTS coils for tokamaks. 20 T
test coils of size similar to that required for MRI have already been built,
although lots of work remains to meet all the requirements of a human MRI
system.
NMR
is now also possible at still higher fields using resistive magnet technology.
The National High Magnetic Field Laboratory has developed and is operating a
resistive/superconducting hybrid NMR magnet at 35.2 T (1.5 GHz) with ~0.1 ppm
homogeneity and stability. NMR has also been done in pulsed resistive magnets
with field strengths up to 55 T. Such systems are only able to maintain field
for ~50 ms and have limited uniformity and stability. Acknowledgements
This work was performed at the National High Magnetic Field Laboratory which is funded by the US National Science Foundation (DMR-1839796) and the State of Florida.References
[1]
Schepkin, et al., MRI, 28 (2010) 400 –
407.
Proc. Intl. Soc. Mag. Reson. Med. 30 (2022)