Chathura Kumaragamage1, Peter B Brown1, Scott McIntyre1, Terence W Nixon1, Henk M De Feyter1, and Robin A de Graaf1
1Radiology and Biomedical Imaging, Yale University, New Haven, CT, United States
Synopsis
The
utility of ECLIPSE, a pulsed second order gradient insert allowing elliptical
localization, was previously shown to provide high axial coverage for single
slab MRSI acquisitions with robust lipid suppression. In this work we extend the
ECLIPSE method with multi-slab localization that provides improved coverage, for
applications in 3D MRSI acquisitions. A two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS method providing >
100-fold in mean lipid suppression was developed, with improved
superior-inferior coverage. Simulation results show that a four-slab ECLIPSE
method, based on OVS and IVS, can provide high-quality lipid suppression with whole-brain
coverage.
Introduction
Magnetic Resonance Spectroscopic Imaging (MRSI) is a
powerful technique that can map the brain metabolic profile non-invasively. Whole
brain extracranial lipid suppressed 3D MRSI acquisitions is however challenging
to achieve with linear gradients due to the curvature of the brain. Recent
work with a second order gradient insert, ECLIPSE1, provides
high axial coverage for single slab MRSI with robust extracranial lipid suppression for both inner volume selection (IVS)
and outer volume suppression (OVS) variants. However, divergence of the elliptical
ROI in the Z-direction, characteristic of a Z2 field, limits the use of ECLIPSE
to one ~ 4 cm slab along the superior-inferior axis. In this work we demonstrate
the extension of ECLIPSE in a multi-slab configuration, that allows improved Z
coverage for whole-brain lipid-suppressed 3D MRSI acquisitions.Theory
The
total gradient field Gtotal(x,y,z) utilizing ECLIPSE and system
gradients to produce an elliptical ROI can be described as:
Gtotal(x,y,z)
= GZ2·(2z2–(x2+y2))+GX2Y2·(x2-y2)+GXY·(xy)+GX·(x)+GY·(y)+GZ·(z).
Here GZ2,
GX2Y2,
and GXY
are quadratic magnetic field amplitudes in Hz/mm2, and GX,
GY,
and GZ
are linear magnetic field amplitudes in Hz/mm. The ratio between GZ2
and
GX2Y2
amplitudes
determine the axial elliptical shape (Figure 1 A-B), and GX,
GY,
and GZ
amplitudes
allow translation of the ellipse along the three primary axes, as previously
described1-2. An example of outer
volume elliptical ring selection (used for ECLIPSE-OVS) or inner volume
elliptical selection (used for ECLIPSE-IVS) is illustrated in Figure 1 C-D, and
E-F respectively.Methods
A two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS method executed with two-sets-of-four
RF pulses was developed utilizing a 3 ms GOIA-WURST (12-4,7) pulse3-4
(BW = 15 kHz) (Figure 2A). A two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS method creates three unique
ROIs in which 1) spins are only perturbed by one OVS module or, 2) spins are
perturbed by both OVS modules. To maintain a high level of lipid suppression,
OVS pulse angles and inter-pulse delays were optimized simultaneously over all
three regions, in addition to covering T1 species
spanning 300 – 700 ms, and a B1+ variation of ±
65%.
The two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS method can be supplemented
with a two-slab ECLIPSE IVS method (Fig. 2C) to achieve near-complete 3D
coverage of the human brain. The two-slab ECLIPSE IVS method closely resembles
a sLASER method, whereby adiabatic refocusing pulses 1A-1B select one ECLIPSE
ROI, and 2A-2B select a second ECLIPSE ROI.
ROI placement and brain coverage was evaluated in vivo with the
two-slab ECLISPE-OVS method on two volunteers. Whole brain coverage achievable
with a four-slab ECLIPSE method was evaluated in simulation using acquired
anatomical images from a volunteer.
All MR experiments were performed on a 4 T 94 cm
Medspec scanner (Bruker corporation. Ettlingen, Germany) with actively shielded
gradients capable of switching 30 mT/m in 1150 µs. The ECLIPSE system1
is a home-built, unshielded gradient insert consisting of Z2, X2Y2, and XY
second order spherical harmonic magnetic fields, controlled by a home-built
multi-channel gradient controller5.
Results
The optimized two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS method (Figure
2A) provides a 107-fold in mean lipid suppression in simulation, over the
optimized T1 and B1 span, accounting for lipid
suppression in all three regions described above (Figure 2B). The transition
zone of each RF pulse, however results in a narrow strip with notably poorer
signal suppression, down to 10-fold. Combining one OVS and one IVS module for
two-slab suppression can mitigate the reduced suppression in spatial areas of
overlap. The two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS method results in ~ 1.9-fold
increase in time-averaged power, relative to a single slab ECLIPSE-OVS method
previously reported2.
Figure 3 illustrates experimental ECLIPSE-OVS ROI
profiles in the Y-Z plane for a single slab OVS placed at Z = 0 (A). (B) and
(C) illustrate identical ROI’s to (A) with the ± 2 cm Z-offsets. The ROI
generated when both slab 1 and 2 OVS in (B) and (C) are simultaneously turned
on with the two-slab ECLIPSE OVS method is shown in (D), demonstrating improved
coverage in the Z-direction and effective signal suppression throughout the
cumulative ROI.
Figure 4 illustrates examples of MRI’s obtained with
the two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS method applied on two volunteers. In
both cases the OVS ROI were placed to achieve 5 cm of Z coverage.
Figure 5 illustrates brain coverage in simulation with
up to four ECLIPSE ROI’s, by combining the two-slab ECLIPSE-OVS and two-slab
ECLIPSE-IVS components. For the illustrated example, the four
scenarios provide up to 2.6 cm, 3.6 cm, 7 cm, and 9.4 cm of coverage in terms
of lipid suppression in the Z-direction, respectively. The four-slab ECLIPSE
method allows 94% brain coverage over an 8 cm span in the Z direction. The
inherent curvature of the ECLIPSE ROI in the Z direction can be exploited to
adhere closely to the head shape, as demonstrated by the red and blue ROI’s in
the four-slab method illustrated in Figure 5 D.Discussion
Experimental
implementation of the two-slab ECLIPSE IVS method is currently underway. The
combination of the two-slab ECLIPSE IVS and two-slab ECLIPSE OVS method is
expected to require a sequence TR = 4000 ms to meet time-averaged power
requirements. However, a 3D MRSI data acquisition with a concentric ring
readout6 would allow whole brain acquisitions at 1 x 1 x 1 cm3
nominal resolution in ~ 20 min.Acknowledgements
This
research was supported by NIH grant R01-
EB014861.References
[1]
de Graaf RA, Brown PB, De Feyter HM, McIntyre S, Nixon TW. Elliptical
localization with pulsed second-order fields (ECLIPSE) for robust lipid
suppression in proton MRSI. NMR in biomedicine 2018;31(9):e3949.
[2]
Kumaragamage C, De Feyter HM, Brown P, McIntyre S, Nixon TW, de Graaf RA. ECLIPSE
utilizing gradient-modulated offset-independent adiabaticity (GOIA) pulses for
highly selective human brain proton MRSI. NMR in Biomedicine 2020; 34:e4415.
[3]
Tannus A, Garwood M. Adiabatic pulses. NMR in Biomedicine 1997;10(8):423–434.
[4] Kumaragamage C,
Coppoli A, Brown P, McIntyre S, Nixon T, De
Feyter H, Mason G, and de Graaf R. Short-TE ECLIPSE for
Macromolecular-Nulled MRSI in the Human Brain. Proceedings
of the Anuual Joinnt Meeting ISMRM, Virtual-2021; 0287.
[5]
Nixon TW, McIntyre S, de Graaf RA. The design and implementation of a 64
channel arbitrary gradient waveform controller. Proc Int Soc Magn Reson Med.
2017;25:969.
[6]
Emir UE, Burns B, Chiew M, Jezzard P, Thomas MA. Non-water-suppressed
short-echo-time magnetic resonance spectroscopic imaging using a concentric
ring k-space trajectory. NMR in Biomedicine 20016; e3714.