Sunitha B Thakur1, Olivia M Sutton2, Almir Bitencourt3, Ralph Noeske4, Tara Fahy1, Ricardo Otazo1, and Robert Young1
1Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center, New York, NY, United States, 2Johns Hopkins Medicine, Baltimore, MD, United States, 3A.C.Camargo Cancer Center, Sao Paulo, SP, Brazil, 4GE HealthCare, Munich, Germany
Synopsis
The aim of this study
was to evaluate the clinical feasibility of optimized multi-voxel MR
spectroscopic imaging (MRSI) at 3T using rapid symmetric echo-planar
spectroscopic imaging (EPSI) spatial encoding in patients with brain tumors. We
performed the optimized MRSI at 3T using semi-localization by adiabatic
selective refocusing pulses (semi-LASER), fast spatial encoding using symmetric
EPSI, and robust water suppression with variable power and optimized relaxation
delays. A radiologist with extensive experience in neuroimaging and
spectroscopy assessed the overall spectral quality. This study is an attempt to
integrate high-resolution MRSI in clinical practice for the assessment of brain
cancer patients.
Introduction
MR spectroscopic imaging (MRSI) is an imaging technique to assess
metabolites concentrations in a specific region of interest in vivo. In brain
imaging, Point Resolved Spectroscopy (PRESS) and STimulated Echo Acquisition
Mode (STEAM) sequences are used routinely to acquire single-voxel and
multi-voxel MRSI. Multi-voxel MRSI enables the simultaneous acquisition of
multiple voxels in single or multiple slices. One of the main applications of
MRSI in brain cancer is to distinguish between radiation necrosis and recurrence
of intraparenchymal tumors, which is necessary to select the appropriate
treatment, but it is often difficult based on conventional imaging features
alone.1 Additionally MRSI can be valuable in the diagnosis, radiotherapy
planning, and assessment of treatment response. In PRESS, refocusing pulses have
smaller bandwidths and are thus prone to introducing chemical shift
displacement errors. These errors can be reduced with semi-localization using
adiabatic pulses (semi-LASER or sLASER)2, where refocusing pulses
have broad bandwidths that enable precise volume localization with minimal or
no chemical shift displacement errors. In addition, water can be suppressed
using a VAPOR scheme.3
The clinical applicability of conventional MRSI has been limited due to
long acquisition times (>10–15 min) for high resolution spatial metabolic
imaging and tissue metabolites detection with higher sensitivity, which
increases patient discomfort and increases motion artifacts. Hence,
rapid acquisition strategies for MRSI are of great clinical interest.4,5
Symmetric echo-planar spectroscopic imaging (EPSI) has recently been shown to be promising.
Preliminary results successfully applied this method in the brain to image
spatial metabolite maps with voxel volumes <0.5mL within a clinically feasible
time (2 minutes) in phantoms and volunteers.6 The aim of this study
was to optimize multi-voxel MRSI at 3T using rapid EPSI spatial encoding in
patients with brain tumors and to evaluate the spectral quality from a
clinician’s point of view. Methods
Patients provided
written informed consent under an IRB-approved prospective protocol. Experiments
were performed in 7 patients with brain tumors (IRB13-239) using a
3T clinical scanner (MR750w, GE Healthcare) and an 8 or 12 channel head coil. Two
patients were excluded from MRSI analysis due to non-diagnostic data quality.
Anatomical T2-weighted FLAIR (TR/TE=9000/120ms; flip
angle=90; 320x256; FOV=24; slice thickness=3mm; acquisition time:3-4min) and
single-slice MRSI were performed using the optimized protocol with TR/TE=2s/144ms.6
Prior to the MRSI acquisition, power calibration of
VAPOR was performed for each subject to improve water suppression. Water suppressed sLASER-EPSI was performed using a 24x24
matrix under different experimental conditions (Figure 1).
All raw
MRSI data and images were transferred to an offline workstation. Data were
filtered using 3 Hz exponential filtering, and custom in-house MATLAB code was used
to generate MRSI spatial and overlay maps. Further,
all voxels of this data were prepared for LCModel fitting analysis using exact
Hamiltonian basis sets. Basis sets were generated with 26 brain metabolites
including major metabolites such NAA, Cr, Cho, and Lac. Metabolite integrals,
absolute quantification, or metabolite ratio maps were generated using in-house
software. The accuracy of metabolite measurements was assessed using Cramer Rao
Lower Bounds (CRLB). A neuroradiologist reviewed all images to provide the
clinical impression and the overall sLASER-EPSI spectral quality, which was categorized
as non-diagnostic, fair, good, or excellent. A neuroradiologist assessed images and correlated image findings with
clinical outcomes.Results
Patients’ characteristics are summarized in Table 1. Figure
2 shows multi-voxel
sLASER-EPSI MRSI measurements in a healthy volunteer, indicating uniform spatial
localization and accurate estimation of metabolite concentrations such as NAA (standard
deviation is < 15% in most of the voxels within the volume of interest indicated
in a white rectangle) using this technique. Each voxel was fitted using LCModel
as shown in Figure 2C. The scan time was 3 minutes.
Figure 3 shows representative multi-voxel sLASER-EPSI MRSI
measurements in a patient demonstrating higher Cho and lower NAA in the anaplastic
astrocytoma (abnormal FLAIR) compared with normal brain tissue. Additionally,
the presence of lactate suggests necrosis within the tumor. This is correlated
with clinical findings (Table 1). LCM fits are used for calculating metabolite
concentrations.
Metabolite concentration color maps were also used to
show different metabolite
distribution in the tumor and normal tissue (Figures 4 and 5).
Importantly,
the MRSI protocol presented here was scored good (3/7) or excellent (1/7). In
1/7 cases, the neuroradiologist
found the spectra to be fair, and in 2/7 cases the score was non-diagnostic. Discussion
Because MRSI scan times in clinical protocols are
usually long, there is a need for faster imaging methods. Additionally, at
higher magnetic fields like 3T, chemical shift displacements errors are higher
and need to be corrected. Our study shows that MRSI acquisition with adiabatic
pulses and EPSI spatial encoding may enable clinically feasible scan times to potentially
quantify spatial variations of metabolites or to assess response to treatment in
patients with brain tumors.Conclusion
sLASER-EPSI multi-voxel MRSI can be used to image
2D/3D spatial metabolite maps within a clinically feasible time in brain cancer
patients. In cases where spectra quality is impacted by motion, an additional
scan can potentially be acquired while the patient remains in the scanner by
adding 3 minutes to the total scan time.Acknowledgements
NIH/NCI P30 CA008748, NIH/NCI UG3 CA239861, BTC
Foundation, MSKCC Society grant, and B*CURED Foundation.References
(1) Scheenen TWJ, Klomp
DWJ, Wijnen JP, Heerschap A. Short echo time 1H‐MRSI of the human brain at 3T with minimal chemical shift displacement
errors using adiabatic refocusing pulses. Magn Reson Med. 2008;59:1‐6.
(2) Tkác I, Starcuk Z,
Choi IY, Gruetter R. In vivo 1H NMR spectroscopy of rat brain at 1 ms echo
time. Magn Reson Med. 1999;41:649‐656.
(3) Shankar RV,
Chang JC, Hu HH, and Kodibagkar VD. Fast data acquisition techniques in magnetic resonance spectroscopic
imaging. NMR Biomedicine 2019:32:e4046.
(4)
Posse S, DeCarli C, Le Bihan D. Three‐dimensional
echo‐planar
MR spectroscopic imaging at short echo times in the human brain. Radiology.
1994;192:733‐738.
(5) Coello E,
Noeske R, Burns BL, et al. High-resolution echo-planar spectroscopic imaging at
ultra-high field. NMR Biomedicine 2018:31:e3950
(6)
Thakur
SB, Sutton OS, Eduardo J, Noeske R, Lin A, Otazo R, Young R, Rapid acquisition
of semi-LASER MR spectroscopic imaging using symmetric EPSI encoding: A
preliminary study in phantom and human brain. Proc. Intl. Soc. Mag. Reson. Med.
28 (2020), p2913.