Sydney Sherman1 and Michael Cima2
1HST, MIT, Cambridge, MA, United States, 2DMSC, MIT, Cambridge, MA, United States
Synopsis
A low-field
portable MR-based sensor was fabricated for the acquisition of clinical T2
relaxometry measurements in skeletal muscle. We have previously reported methods for designing low-field permanent magnet array configurations with varying sensitive
region profiles. The newly constructed array has a sensitive region 15-20mm
from the surface of the magnet; field maps from the constructed magnet show
good alignment with simulated fields. The exclusion of subcutaneous fat tissue
in the sensitive region will improve sensitivity to fluid shifts within the
skeletal muscle.
Background
Worldwide there are over 2.5 million patients with end stage
kidney disease who depend on life-sustaining dialysis treatments. The
intermittent nature of dialysis exposes patients to wide variations between
fluid overload on non-dialysis days and fluid depletion after hemodialysis
sessions1. Fluid overload has been linked with cardiovascular events
and mortality2,3. Fluid depletion results in intradialytic
hypotension, which occurs in up to 75% of hemodialysis patients and can cause
nausea, vomiting, and cramping. Long-term volume overload and poorly managed
ultrafiltration rates are also common4,5. There is currently no
quantitative standard for fluid status assessment that informs physicians or
patients of their volemic status. An adequate assessment of fluid state in
routine clinical practice is, therefore, an unmet need6. Methods for
quantification of fluid status, including bioelectric impedance analysis,
plasma osmolality, and isotope dilutions, are known to have clinically relevant
limitations7. We aim to
establish the magnetic resonance (MR) based measurement as a rapid quantitative
method for fluid assessment. We have developed a portable, single-sided MR
sensor to collect relaxometry metrics from skeletal muscle, where previous
studies have indicated excess fluid accumulates8.
We have previously demonstrated a single-sided MR relaxometer
(SSR) that is capable of acquiring T2
relaxometry measurements from the lower leg of patients. In a clinical study
with dialysis patients, our prototype MR sensor was compared against a clinical MRI
scanner. Clinical MRI was able to able to detect differences between hyper- and
hypo- volemic patients from lower leg skeletal muscle, but the SSR was unable
to distinguish between those groups due to the presence of unequal amounts of subcutaneous
fat in the sampling volume. SSR measurements did show statistically significant
changes for each patient before and after hemodialysis. The SSR used in the clinical study was
designed with permanent magnets to have a static magnetic field of 0.27 T with
a saddle-shaped homogeneous region 2-7 mm from the surface of the magnet. Physically,
this region includes both muscle and subcutaneous fat compartments when placed
against a patient’s leg. The inclusion of subcutaneous fat in the measurement
confounds the signal from the interstitial muscle space, as shown in Fig. 18.
The purpose of this work is to construct a modified portable permanent magnet array and
RF coil sensor capable of acquiring signal from only the skeletal muscle of a
leg and sufficiently sensitive enough to be used for clinical measurements. Methods
Previously presented results detail the methods and outcomes for designing a portable magnet array using finite element analysis with COMSOL
Multiphysics software. The resulting design, shown in Fig. 2, has a homogeneous region 12-15m above the surface of the array. The array was constructed from 1/2" cube N52 neodymium magnets9. Each serialized magnet was individually
flux tested; only magnets within a single standard deviation of the median flux
density were included in the array assembly to increase field homogeneity, the
rest were discarded. Custom aluminum frames
were fabricated to secure the magnets in the proper orientation, shown in Fig.
3. Each frame was field mapped with a hall probe and gaussmeter prior to array assembly. The frame
slices were assembled and secured on aluminum rods and the net magnetic field of the completed assembly was
mapped. A surface RF coil (N=8, diameter = 16mm) was constructed and placed on the surface of the magnet assembly to obtain a T2 signal from the
sensitive region.Results
Low-field permanent Halbach magnet array configurations
were modeled in COMSOL Multiphysics until a simulated magnetic field profile met our requirements for homogenous region. The array configuration that achieves the desired field consists of 448 1/2" cube permanent magnets with two 1mm thick
iron yokes. Magnets were arranged in specially constructed aluminum frames. Each frame was field mapped
with a hall probe prior to assembly to ensure magnets were secured in the
correct orientation and identify any variations in frame field homogeneity; representative field
maps are shown in Fig 4. Analysis showed insignificant variation across rows of assembled frames, indicating high magnetic field homogeneity. Individual frames were assembled and fit with an RF coil, the final field was
mapped and a T2 signal acquired. Discussion
A low-field, single-sided, portable MR-based sensor was constructed
for the acquisition of clinical T2 relaxometry measurements in skeletal muscle.
The depth of the homogeneous region, 12-15mm above the surface of the RF coil allows
for the exclusion of subcutaneous fat in the sweet spot – which will improve
sensitivity to fluid shifts within the skeletal muscle. Over 400 cube neodymium
magnets were selected for field uniformity and used in array construction. Modular
sections of the array, consisting of 32-48 magnet cubes were assembled in
custom aluminum frames and field mapped to ensure a high level of slice homogeneity. The frames were then stacked and secured with aluminum rods to complete
the array and field mapped with a hall probe and gaussmeter. A surface RF coil
was fit on the middle of the array and T2 measurements were obtained using a
CPMG sequence. This portable low-field magnet design will
enable clinical assessment of fluid status without the need for full-scale
clinical MRI imaging.Acknowledgements
Funding: NSF GRFP
Cima Lab: Michael Cima, Haley Higgenbotham, Hannah Jackson, Erin Rousseau, Kriti Subramanyam, & Wendy Brown
Cima Lab Alumni: Chris Frangieh, Ashvin Bashyam
MIT Machine Shop: Andy Gallant
References
[1] Hecking M, Karaboyas A, Antlanger M, Saran R, Wizemann V,
Chazot C, et al. Significance of interdialytic weight gain versus chronic
volume overload: consensus opinion. Am J Nephrol. 2013;38(1):78–90
[2] Kalantar-Zadeh K, Regidor DL, Kovesdy CP, Van Wyck D,
Bun- napradist S, Horwich TB, et al.: Fluid retention is associated with car-
diovascular mortality in patients undergoing long-term hemodialysis.
Circulation 119:671–679, 2009
[3] Wizemann V, Wabel P, Chamney P, Zaluska W, Moissl U, Rode
C, et al.: The mortality risk of overhydration in haemodialysis patients. Nephrol
Dial Transplant 24:1574–1579, 2009
[4] J.Q. Jaeger, R.L. Mehta, Assessment of dry weight in
hemodialysis an overview, J. Am. Soc. Nephrol. 10 (1999) 392–403.
[5] J.E. Flythe, S.E. Kimmel, S.M. Brunelli, Rapid fluid
removal during dialysis is associated with cardiovascular morbidity and
mortality, Kidney Int. 79 (2011) 250–257.
[6] S. Ishibe, A.J.
Peixoto, Methods of Assessment of Volume Status and Intercompartmental Fluid
Shifts in Hemodialysis Patients: Implications in Clinical Practice, in: Semin. Dial.,
Wiley Online Library, 2004: pp. 37–43. doi:10.1111/j.1525-139X.2004.17112.x.
[7] S. McGee, W.B. Abernethy III, D.L. Simel, Is this patient
hypovolemic?, Jama. 281 (1999) 1022–1029.
[8] L.Colucci, K. Corapi, M. Li, X. Parada, A Allegretti, H
Lin, D. Ausiello, M. Rosen, M.J. Cima, Fluid assessment in dialysis patients by
point-of-care magnetic relaxometry; Science Translational Medicine,
10.1126/scitranslmed.aau1749, Vol 11, Issue 502, 2019/07/24
[9] A. Bashyam, M. Li,
M.J. Cima, Design and experimental validation of Unilateral Linear Halbach
magnet arrays for singlesided magnetic resonance, J. Magn. Reson. (2018).