Paola Scifo1, Federico Fallanca1, Maurizio Barbera2, Annarita Savi1, Valentino Bettinardi1, Ilaria Neri1, Giovanna Gattuso3, Maura Massimino3, Paolo Verderio4, Sara Pizzamiglio4, Andrea Falini2,5, Luigi Gianolli1, Filippo Spreafico3, Maria Picchio1,5, and Cristina Baldoli2,5
1Nuclear Medicine, IRCCS San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Milan, Italy, 2Neuroradiology Unit, IRCCS San Raffaele Scientific Institute, Milan, Italy, 3Department of Medical Oncology and Hematology, Pediatric Oncology Unit, Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Nazionale dei Tumori, Milan, Italy, 4Unit of Bioinformatics and Biostatistics, Department of Applied Research and Technological Development, Fondazione IRCCS Istituto Nazionale dei Tumori, Milan, Italy, 5Vita-Salute San Raffaele University, Milan, Italy
Synopsis
A preliminary comparison
between the two Atlas and ZTE attenuation correction methodologies in a group
of pediatric patients with brain tumors is presented. The differences of the
two ACmaps and PET images were calculated and the PET parameters were compared.
Our results show that using ZTE or Atlas to generate ACmaps modifies the SUVs,
but the differences in values are very small. Moreover, when metallic artefacts
occur, both ZTE and Atlas show loss of signals but ACmapsAtlas has
smaller artefacts.
INTRODUCTION
Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) plays a key role in pediatric brain
tumors, for diagnosis, response assessment and follow-up monitoring. Nevertheless,
differentiating tumor recurrence from pseudo-progression or other
treatment-induced reactions after radiation therapy and chemotherapy is
challenging on conventional diagnostics, but clinically relevant. Positron Emission
Tomography (PET) imaging with 11C-Methionine would improve
diagnostic accuracy for the detection of recurrent tumor as compared with MRI
alone1. The use of simultaneous hybrid PET/MRI is highly beneficial
in children as it allows for a one-stop-shop examination that limits the scanning
procedures, the need for a second sedation and also reduces the radiation dose
compared to PET/CT. One of the major challenges for PET/MRI is the attenuation
correction that, in brain, is performed with Atlas2, with Zero Echo
Time/Ultrashort Echo Time (ZTE/UTE) sequences3 or, more recently,
with Deep Learning-based methods4. In pediatric patients, and in
particular in oncological pediatric studies where tumor resection may occur,
the size and the abnormal shape of the head maybe critical for a good
attenuation correction. In this work, we have compared the two Atlas and ZTE attenuation
correction methodologies in a group of treated pediatric patients with brain
tumors. As we do not have gold standards (CT-based ACmaps) for ethic reasons,
we have calculated the differences of the two ACmaps and PET images and
compared the PET parameters.SUBJECTS AND METHODS
Nineteen children and adolescents (age 10.1±4.5 years, min/max = 2.6/17.7
years, 8/11F/M) with treated high grade brain tumors (five high grade gliomas, six
medulloblastomas, four germinomas, one pinealoblastomas, three ependymomas) were scanned on
the SIGNA PET/MR scanner (GE Healthcare, Waukesha, WI, USA) using a 32-channel brain
coil as part of an approved research protocol for the suspicious of tumor
recurrence. Six of them were sedated. The patients were injected with a dose of 11C-Methionine
per 1.7 m2of body surface area. The following optimized protocol was used: first, some
of the diagnostic MR sequences were acquired soon after the injection of Methionine,
then, the simultaneous PET/MRI acquisition started after 25 minutes to wait for
the distribution of the tracer in the brain. The PET scan lasted 20 minutes
during which we acquired: first, a two-point Dixon (LAVA-flex) and a ZTE sequence
with 2.4mm isotropic resolution for generation of the ACmaps, then the clinical
coronal T2, 3D Flair, axial T1 pre-contrast, axial DWI sequences. After PET, we
completed the examination with the perfusion and post contrast MR sequences.
PETZTE and PETAtlas images were retrospectively reconstructed
with the TOF-OSEM (3 algorithm iterations, 16 subsets, with PSF modelling,
attenuation, scatter correction) using the two ACmaps.
The maximum and mean value SUVs
on the 42% isocontour VOIs (SUVmax and SUVmean, respectively) were calculated
for the lesions on both reconstructed PET images by an expert nuclear medicine
physician using the AW server Workstation (GE Healthcare, Waukesha, WI, USA)
and compared. Dice index between VOIs has been calculated. RESULTS
Eight/19 patients had a positive uptake in PET images. Two patients showed
artifacts on the MR images due external ventricular drain catheter valve (EVC).
Figure 1 shows an example of ACmapZTE and ACmapAtlas and
the corresponding PET images for a subject 10 years old. Figure 2 shows an
example of ACmaps from ZTE and Atlas and the corresponding PET images for a
subject 11 years old with an EVC valve. In Figure 3 the volume rendering of the
3D FSPGR sequence of the same patient of Figure 2 is shown.
In Figure 4 the table with SUVmean, SUVmax and Volumes of each patients. The SUV
values calculated using ACmapAtlas are always higher than the ones
calculated using ACmapZTE. The corresponding volumes of the VOIs are
variable. The mean values of the difference % between SUVmax is -0,103, SUVmean
is -0,060 and Volume is -0,016. The Dice mean value is 0.98952.DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSIONS
This preliminary work on the effect of attenuation correction on PET
images of brain tumor pediatric patients shows that using of ZTE or Atlas for
the generation of ACmaps can modify the SUVs of the study but the differences
in the values are very small. The corresponding DICE indexes are high. Moreover,
it should be noticed that some of the patients of our sample have EVC valves
that generate artifacts. In these cases both ZTE and Atlas show loss of signals
but ACmapAtlas has smaller artifacts than ACmapZTE.
Further work using Deep learning-based AC will be performed to try to reduce
errors in the PET attenuation correction of these kind of patients.Acknowledgements
This research was suported by “Associazione Italiana per la Ricerca sul Cancro”(AIRC) grant number 2018 Id. IG22162. Signa PET/MRI system (GEMS, Wakesha, Wisconsin, USA) used in the present work has been purchased with funding from Italian Ministry of Health.
References
1.
Xu, W., et al. The performance of 11C-Methionine PET in the
differential diagnosis of glioma recurrence. Oncotarget 2017; 8(53): 91030-91039.
2.
Wollenweber, S. D., et al. Evaluation of an atlas-based PET head
attenuation correction using PET/CT & MR patient data. IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science 2013; 60(5): 3383-3390.
3.
Wiesinger, F., et al. Zero TE MR bone imaging in the head. Magnetic resonance in medicine 2016; 75(1): 107-114.
4. Ladefoged, C. N., et al. Deep learning based attenuation
correction of PET/MRI in pediatric brain tumor patients: evaluation in a
clinical setting. Frontiers in neuroscience 2019 (12): 1005.