Yi-Fen Yen1, Joseph B Mandeville1, Yin-Ching Chan1, Suk-Tak Chan1, Erin E Hardy1, Jay Janz2, Steven Arkin2, Denis Rybin2, Kelly Knee2, Debra D Pittman2, and James A Goodman2
1Athinoula A. Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging, Massachusetts General Hospital, Chalrestown, MA, United States, 2Pfizer, Inc, Cambridge, MA, United States
Synopsis
We
have assessed cerebral blood flow (CBF), venous T2, and hematocrit (Hct) in
mice to characterize the performance of MR markers of cerebral physiology in
wildtype (WT) mice and the Townes transgenic mouse model of Sickle Cell Disease
(SCD). SCD mice exhibited increased CBF, decreased venous T2, and decreased Hct
compared to matched WT mice. Combining MR measures of CBF and venous T2 with
Hct measurement improved the disease-specific differentiation. Test-retest
variability was approximately 20% for CBF and venous T2 and 10% for Hct. Methods
employed in this study are fully translational to the clinic.
INTRODUCTION
SCD
is characterized by a severe hemolytic anemia characterized by low Hct. This
contributes to elevated cerebrometabolic strain, which manifests in SCD
patients by compensatory increases in CBF and OEF (1-2), even prior to silent
infarct. It is thus thought that measures
of CBF and OEF may be useful translational imaging tools for assessing local pre-ischemic
metabolic stress and may be valuable for assessing ameliorating effect of
pharmacologic intervention. To that end, this study was designed to provide
data to determine MRI variability, test-retest reproducibility, and
disease-related differentiation of CBF and OEF using a Townes model of SCD. METHODS
All
animal procedures were performed under an IACUC-approved protocol. Six WT mice and 6 Townes SC mice were scanned
once per week for 3 weeks. In each scanning session, we measured CBF, venous T2
from the sagittal sinus, and hematocrit (Hct) from tail snips at the end of
each imaging session. Differentiation between WT and SC mice was quantified by
effect sizes based upon Cohen’s D using both primary data (CBF, T2, Hct) and
derived quantities.
CBF measurements employed
unbalanced pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling (pCASL) (3) with 2500 ms
labeling and control RF pulse trains, a 1 ms inter-pulse separation,
progressive phase tables, and a slice plane located 10 mm from the magnetic
isocenter and about 4 mm posterior to cerebellum. Flow phantom studies
demonstrated good insensitivity to fluid velocity across a physiological range.
Data were analyzed both on a voxel-wise level and using a whole-brain index
after spatial normalization using a multi-subject mouse MRI template (4).
Venous blood T2 was assessed using a
T2-Relaxation-Under-Spin-Tagging (TRUST) sequence developed and disseminated by
Johns Hopkins University (5). Based upon a field strength- and hematocrit-dependent
calibration (6,7), results were converted to venous saturation (Yv).RESULTS
Primary measurements are
summarized in Table 1. CBF
demonstrated test-retest variabilities of 9% and 22% in WT and SCD mice,
respectively, and measurements of sagittal sinus T2 showed variabilities of 22%
and 19%. Hematocrit variability was approximately 10%. Figure 1 uses
relative values, normalized to WT averages, to illustrate test-retest
variability across weeks and to demonstrate differentiation between WT and SCD mice
cohorts.
Whole-brain measurements of CBF (Figure
2) illustrate that the highest difference in regional CBF occurs in
occipital regions and may be indicative of reduced transit times due to higher flow
velocities in large feeding arteries of SCD mice (8). The graph in Figure 2
shows that CBF in medial occipital regions is elevated 2-fold in SC animals
(last 18 data points) relative to WT animals (first 18 data points). This
difference is much larger than the 25% whole-brain difference in CBF listed in Table
1.
All measurements yielded large
effect sizes (d>0.8). CBF alone (d=1.3) provided better discrimination than
T2 alone (d=1.1), but neither matched Hct (d=2.2), combined MRI indices like
CBF/T2 (d=1.7), or combined MRI and benchtop indices like CBF*(1-Y) (d=2.2) or
Hct*Y (d=2.8). Table 2 summarizes the effect sizes for SC vs. WT.
Bench measurements of Hct
further helped differentiate animals beyond measurements based only on imaging.
Figure 3 shows CBF versus the product of Hct and Yv, under the
assumptions that 1) CMRO2 is preserved in disease and 2) the ratio of venous
saturations is a proxy for the ratio of
arterial changes. DISCUSSION
SCD
reduces blood oxygen carrying capacity and therefore is associated with
elevated CBF as a response mechanism to preserve oxygen delivery to the brain.
In agreement with another report (8), we found significantly elevated CBF in
this Townes model of SCD. Additionally, we found that TRUST-based measurements
of venous blood T2, which can be related to venous oxygen saturation, provide
additional power to discriminate SCD from WT mice. The combination of these
measurements, along with Hct, provide means to monitor disease progression and
treatment using cerebral markers that may be indicative of deleterious effects.
This
study suggests that CBF appears to roughly compensate for losses in oxygen
carrying capacity. The increase in CBF was greater than the reduction in Hct,
but oxygen carrying capacity also depends upon the ability of blood cells to
bind oxygen. Reduced venous saturation in SCD could indicate either reduced
arterial saturation or increased OEF.
The Hct values in WT mice (46%) were
higher compared to the SCD mice (41%). These Hct values in SCD mice were higher than
expected, which may be due the blood collection via tail snip versus a terminal
collection from the heart.
Alternatively, elevated hematocrit values could be due to dehydration
associated with inspiration gases during scanning, which would have a larger
effect on SCD mouse Hct than WT.CONCLUSION
WT
and SCD mice were easily differentiated with a large effect size using MRI
alone or in combination with Hct, setting the stage for studies to evaluate
treatment effects. Differences between WT and SCD mice were consistent with the
hypothesis that CBF is responding to decreased arterial blood oxygenation in SC
animals, due a combination of lower Hct and lower saturation, to maintain
cerebral oxygen delivery. The methods
employed have been back-translated from clinically available methods, so this
protocol is a fully translational platform on which to assess potential therapeutics for
SCD. Acknowledgements
Pfizer,
Inc provided financial support for this study.References
1. Jordan LC, et al., Brain
139:738-750 (2016).
2. Guilliams KP, et al., Blood
131:1012-1021 (2018).
3. Hirschler L, et al., MRM
79:1314-1324 (2018).
4. Ma Y, et al., Front. Neuroanat 2:1-10 (2008).
5. Wei Z, et al., MRM 80:521-528
(2018).
6. http://godzilla.kennedykrieger.org/cgi-bin/bloodT2T1_cal.pl
7. Li W., et al., NMR Biomed 33
(2020).
8. Cahill LS, et al, JCBFM 37:994-1005
(2017).