Lily Xiang1, Lucy Victoria Hiscox2, Curtis L. Johnson3, and Neil Roberts1
1University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, United Kingdom, 2University of Bath, Bath, United Kingdom, 3University of Delaware, Newark, DE, United States
Synopsis
On average the human brain has a global structural asymmetry comprising a counter-clockwise twist in the transverse plane and which is referred to as the cerebral torque. We have investigated whether there is a relationship between the magnitude of the torque and measures of brain shear stiffness obtained using Magnetic Resonance Elastography (MRE) in a group of Older Adults (AD) and a group of patients with Alzheimers DIsease (AD).
In our previous MRI studies, the prominent brain asymmetry referred to as the cerebral torque has been found to be specific to the human brain (Xiang et al.
2019) and considered as a potential neural substrate for the functional
lateralization of human cognitive abilities and language (e.g., Barrick
et al. 2007; Josse et al. 2009). However, it remains unclear (i)
whether the morphologically asymmetric brain also shows stiffness asymmetry, (ii)
whether there is a relationship between indices of the cerebral torque and the
pattern of brain stiffness and (iii) whether the cerebral torque and potential shear stiffness asymmetry are altered in Alzheimer's DIsease (AD)
compared to Older Adults (OA). Predictions to test is whether the left occipital lobe
becomes more stiff, or less stiff, the further it protrudes or bends and whether the asymmetry
patterns change due to neurodegnerative disease.
2.
Method
Shear stiffness values were computed for the occipital
lobe and related to indices of the cerebral torque. First,
we examined brain structural asymmetry based on structural MRI data, namely occipital
petalia, occipital bending and inter-hemispheric brain length asymmetry of
individual diagnostic groups using the protocol proposed in (Xiang et al. 2019) (see Figure 1). Secondly, we
computed average values of MRE measures, namely shear stiffness and
damping ratio of the occipital lobe and examined the inter-hemispheric
asymmetry, in the form of an asymmetry index (AI) defined as the normalized
difference between the left and right cerebral hemispheres. As FreeSurfer allows
the classification of brain voxel into gray matter, white matter, major
subcortical regions and also specific neuroanatomical regions based on the atlas-based
labelling function, the occipital lobe was extracted automatically, and the
statistics of MRI and MRE measures can be computed for the relevant regions
(Figure 1). Lastly, we investigated the correlation between
the indices of cerebral torque and MRE asymmetries of the occipital lobe.
3.
Results
3.1.
MRI Asymmetries (12 OA and 12 AD subjects)
Two-sample
t-tests revealed no significant difference in structural asymmetries between OA
and AD groups (occipital petalia: [t(22)=1.44, p=0.16]; occipital bending:
[t(22)=-0.59, p=0.56]; length asymmetry: [t(22)=-0.61, p=0.55]) (see Figure 2). Although
one-sample t-tests revealed that both groups have significant (i) leftward
occipital petalia (OA: [t(11)=-2.41, p=0.03]; AD: [t(11)=-4.27, p<0.005]) and
(ii) rightward occipital bending (OA: [t(11)=3.14, p=0.01]; AD: [t(11)=7.06,
p<0.005]), as well as (iii) leftward length asymmetry (OA: [t(11)=2.32,
p=0.04]; AD: [t(11)=2.36, p=0.04]).
3.2.
MRE asymmetries (12 OA and 11 AD subjects)
For
the MRE shear stiffness measure, there is a significant reduction in the
occipital lobe in AD compared to OA for gray+white matter volume by 7.40% and
12.86%, respectively, for the left cerebral hemisphere [t(21)=2.76, p=0.01] and
right cerebral hemisphere [t(21)=4.00, p<0.005], on gray matter volume by
7.17% 11.96%, respectively, for the left cerebral hemisphere [t(21)=2.51, p=0.02]
and right cerebral hemisphere [t(21)=3.75, p<0.005] and for white matter
volume by 7.69% and 13.73%, respectively, for the left [t(21)=2.92,
p=0.01] and right cerebral hemisphere [t(21)=4.07, p<0.005] (see Figure 3).
Two-sample t-tests of the AI values revealed significantly increased shear stiffness asymmetry
of the occipital lobe in AD compared to OA, respectively in gray+white matter
volume [t(21)=-2.28, p=0.03], gray matter volume [t(21)=-2.21, p=0.04] and
white matter volume [t(21)=-2.21, p=0.04]. The correlation
analysis showed that the increasing of asymmetry in AD is significantly related
to the reduction of shear stiffness in the right cerebral hemisphere [gm+wm: r=-0.67,
p<0.005; gm: r=-0.61, p<0.005; wm: r=-0.72, p<0.005], but not the left
cerebral hemisphere.
For
the MRE damping ratio measure, there was no significant difference between AD
and OA in either absolute values of individual cerebral hemispheres or the inter-hemispheric
asymmetry.
3.3.
Relationship between MRI and MRE asymmetries (12 OA and 11 AD subjects)
For
the damping ratio measure, the correlation analysis revealed (i) significant
association between the inter-hemispheric asymmetry of the occipital lobe and brain
length asymmetry [gm+wm: r=-0.52, p=0.01; gm: r=-0.53, p=0.01; wm: r=-0.50,
p=0.02] and (ii) marginal association between inter-hemispheric asymmetry of
the occipital lobe and brain occipital petalia [gm+wm: r=0.36, p=0.09; wm: r=0.40,
p=0.06], indicating that the smaller the relative damping ratio of the left
occipital lobe, the greater the brain length and the posterior protrusion of
the left cerebral hemisphere (see Figure 4).
4.
Discussion
In
this study, we report (i) a significant increase of shear stiffness asymmetry in
the occipital lobe in AD compared to OA and reduction of shear stiffness of the
occipital lobe in both cerebral hemispheres, more prominent in the right
compared to the left, (ii) significant occipital petalia, bending and length
asymmetry in both AD and OA groups, with no significant difference between diagnostic
groups and (iii) a significant relationship between damping ratio asymmetry of
the occipital lobe and brain length asymmetry.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
Barrick
TR, Lawes N, Mackay CE, Clark CA. 2007. White matter pathway asymmetry
underlies functional lateralization Cerebral Cortex. 17: 591-598.
Fischl
B, van der Kouwe A, Destrieux C, Halgren E, Segonne F, Salat DH, Busa E,
Seidman LJ, Goldstein J, Kennedy D et al. 2004. Automatically parcellating the
human cerebral cortex. Cereb Cortex. 14: 11-22.
Josse
G, Kherif G, Flandin G, Seghier ML, Price CJ. 2009. Predicting language
lateralization from gray matter J
Neurosci. 29: 13516-13523.
Xiang
L, Crow T, Roberts N. 2019. Cerebral torque is human specific and unrelated to
brain size. Brain Struct Funct. 224: 1141-1150.