Takashi Abe1,2, Maki Otomo2, Rintaro Ito1, Rei Nakamichi1, Yumi Abe1, Toshiki Nakane1, Hisashi Kawai1, Toshiaki Taoka1, Shinji Naganawa1, and Masafumi Harada2
1Nagoya University, Nagoya, Japan, 2Tokushima University, Tokushima, Japan
Synopsis
Although it is often difficult to
differentiate brain abscess, acute ischemic stroke, and hemorrhagic stroke on diffusion
weighted image (DWI), the diagnosis can be made more accurately by focusing on
the low signal intensity, especially the low intensity rim surrounding the lesion.
In this study, image interpretation of six diagnostic radiologists (12.8 years
of experience on average) showed an accuracy of 70% before explanation of the low
intensity rim finding, but the accuracy increased to 86% after explanation (p
= 0.025), confirming the importance of focusing on low intensity rim on DWI.
INTRODUCTION
The usefulness of diffusion-weighted
imaging (DWI) for the diagnosis of acute ischemic stroke is widely known, and
early diagnosis and early initiation of therapy lead to improved prognosis. It
is important to diagnose correctly by DWI because that is the image firstly taken
in the stroke MRI. However, both infarction and hemorrhage show hyperintensity
on DWI, and their image findings are similar to those of brain abscess.
Therefore, it is necessary to check other image sequence like T2*WI and MR
angiography. However, because the low-intensity findings on DWI differ from
each other in these diseases, attention to these findings may lead to a more
accurate diagnosis using DWI alone. At this time, we tried to prove the usefulness
of the low signal intensity on DWI for differentiating these diseases in this image
interpretation study.METHOD
This retrospective study included 15
consecutive cases of untreated brain abscess diagnosed pathologically or
clinically between 2012 and 2019. One patient was excluded because of a history
of head surgery near the abscess. 20 consecutive cases of acute ischemic stroke
and 26 consecutive cases of acute hemorrhagic stroke were collected. One representative
DWI was selected from each case and 60 DW images were randomly classified into
2 groups.
Six radiologists (7 to 20 years of
experience) reviewed one group without any guidance and examined the accuracy
of classification of brain abscess, cerebral infarction, and hemorrhage.
The interpretation of another group was
carried out after the following explanation; In brain abscesses, a thin,
smooth, low-signal intensity rim surrounds the strong high-signal intensity. Cerebral
hemorrhage is an irregular, heterogeneous mixture of high and low intensity on
DWI, and the rim is nonuniform in thickness. The strong high signal can be also
often recognized around the low intensity rim. In cerebral infarction, low
signal rim is not observed, but in the basal ganglia, iron deposition may be
seen as rim.
The diagnostic accuracy before and after
explanation was statistically analyzed and p-value less than 0.05 was considered
significant.RESULT
Each diagnostic radiologist spent 14.8 minuites
for the first reading (average, range: 10.5 -19.5 min.). The accuracy was 70.3%
(average, range: 50 -80%).
The reading time after the explanation about
the low intensity rim sign was 7.3 min. (5.0 -8.5 min). The accuracy was
increased to 85.8 % (70 -96.7 %, p = 0.025, paired t-test).
The accuracy was correlated with years of
experience of each radiologist (Pearson's correlation coefficient of 0.841, p =
0.036).DISCUSSION
Brain abscess, cerebral infarction, and
cerebral hemorrhage show focal hyperintense lesion on DWI and their imaging
findings are similar, but more accurate diagnosis was possible by focusing on
low intensity rim surrounding the lesion.
The mechanism of formation of low signal
rim in brain abscess is considered to be the T2 shortening effect of free
radical secreted from aggregated macrophages. On the other hand,
the low signal intensity in the cerebral
hemorrhage is mainly caused by the T2 shortening effect and the heterogeneity
of the local magnetic field from the extracellular hemoglobin and
deoxyhemoglobin. Because the low intensity is thought to originate from the
displaced erythrocyte, the low signal rim at the periphery may also become
serpentine and nonuniform in thickness, reflecting the heterogeneous formation
of the hematoma.
Although the high-intensity of DWI has
attracted attention, the low-intensity is also considered to be useful for diagnosis.CONCLUSION
In the diagnosis of stroke MRI, not only
the high signal intensity but also the low signal area on DWI can be used for
more accurate diagnosis.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
- Hiwatashi A, Kinoshita T, Moritani T, et
al. AJR 2003; 181(6):1705-9
-
Gomori JM, Grossman RI, Yu-Ip C, et al.
JCAT. 1987;11(4):684-90.