L Cheng1, Tjada Schult1, Mara Lauer1, Yannick Berker2, Marcella Cardoso1, Lindsey Vandergrift1, Piet Habbel3, Johannes Nowak4, Martin Aryee1, Mari Mino-Kenudson1, and David Christiani5
1Mass General Hospital, Boston, MA, United States, 2German Cancer Research Center, Heidelberg, Germany, 3Charite Medical University, Berlin, Germany, 4Julius-Maximilians University, Wuerzburg, Germany, 5Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, Boston, MA, United States
Synopsis
Lung cancer (LuCa), the
leading cause of cancer deaths, are often diagnosed late due to the lack of
screening. Low-dose spiral CT can detect small and early stage LuCa lesions, but
cannot practically be used as an annual LuCa screening tool. Metabolomics
detects global metabolite variations under physiology and pathology.
Metabolomic profiles measured from blood may reveal LuCa at early stages as a
screening tool to triage suspicious patients to CT tests. Blood sera obtained
from LuCa patients prior to their diagnosis were studied with MRS to establish
LuCa screening metabolomic profiles to discover LuCa earlier and reduce death
rates.
INTRODUCTION
Lung cancer (LuCa) is the
leading cause of oncologic-related deaths. Early stages are mostly asymptomatic
and contribute to a delayed diagnosis, with over 70% of the patients dying from
LuCa. While the overall five-year survival rate is 19%, stage I LuCa can
achieve a much higher five-year survival rate of 71%, which emphasizes the
essential need for an effective screening test. At present, the best possible LuCa
early detection test is a low-dose spiral CT, but due to its costs and
radiation hazard it can hardly be used as a widespread screening method. Thus, a simple, preferably portable,
non- or minimal-invasive screening test with no harmful side-effects is
urgently needed to triage patients with suspicious screening results to a
further CT test and thereby minimize LuCa associated mortalities.
Cancer
metabolomics detects oncological developments by interrogating the metabolic
profiles from metabolic pathways through global metabolite variations. Previously published human serum MRS-based metabolomic profiles have
shown abilities to differentiate LuCa from controls and between different
cancer type. These successes encouraged us to study LuCa patient serum samples
prior to their LuCa diagnosis to evaluate their capability as a screening agent.METHODS
Samples. Sera from non-small
cell LuCa (NSCLC)patients and their age, gender and smoking habit matched
healthy controls were grouped according to the design of training-testing-validation
cohorts in this study. The training cohort included 25 NSCLC sera from patients
at the time of diagnosis (Time-of-Dx) and controls; the testing cohort consisted
25 sera collected 0.5 to 5 yrs Prior-to-Dx from the 25 NSCLC patients in the
training cohort; and the validation cohort recruited sera collected less than 2
yrs Prior-to-Dx from additional 54 NSCLC patients and controls.
MR Spectroscopy. High resolution magic
angle spinning (HRMAS) MRS analysis of serum samples are performed at 4°C by a
600MHz Bruker spectrometer at 3,600Hz spinning rate. Spectra are analyzed with
a MatLab-based curve fitting program.
Data Analysis. 57 spectral regions
were selected based on the training and testing cohorts. Following selections
of these regions, all of the data analytical procedures, including principal
component and canonical analyses, were performed on the training cohort and
followed by the testing and validation cohorts. RESULTS
MRS
of native sera (10ul) were measured with HRMAS MRS. Spectra presented as group
averages with standard deviations for training and testing cohorts are shown in
Fig. 1. Following selections of 57
spectral regions, PCA and canonical analysis were conducted on the training
cohort with the aim to differentiate Time-of-Dx from Healthy groups, with the
testing cohort passively followed the calculations. Results thus obtained from the
training and testing cohorts are presented in Fig 2.
Using the mean plus one
standard error (M+SE) as the threshold, calculated from the canonical score
differences between Time-of-Dx and Prior-to-Dx for each case, i.e. the
difference of the two scores for each patient, a Kaplan-Meier survival analysis
indicates significantly better survival rate from their time of NSCLC diagnoses
for patients with score differences higher than the threshold (Fig 3a). Furthermore, within the group
of stage I and IIA, patient survivals can be significantly predicted from the
date of their Prior-to-Dx blood sample collections, if their score values are
higher than the M+SE threshold, calculated by the testing cohort (dashed line
in Fig 2), as shown in Fig 3b.
Fig 4a presents score results for cases in the validation cohort
as comparisons with those in the training and testing cohorts. The validation
cohort demonstrated the same significant trend of score changes in the NSCLC
group, as seen in the testing cohort, when compared with Healthy controls. The
Kaplan-Meier survival analysis for the localized stage I and IIA cases in the validation
cohort, conducted similarly to Fig 3b for the testing cohort, demonstrated a
similar survival predicting trend (Fig 4b).
Since neither testing nor validation cohorts were involved in the determination
of values of the canonical score, by collectively examining all lymph node and
metastasis negative cases in both cohorts, the resulting Kaplan-Meier survival
predicting capability by the threshold (established by the testing cohort) was enhanced
significantly as shown by the insert in Fig 4b.
By
combining testing and validation cohorts, and re-calculating the M+SE
threshold using all the Prior-to-Dx cases from both cohorts, the resulting Kaplan-Meier survival predictions for
all stage I and IIA cases, with patient survival status presented in Fig 5a, remained to be significant (Fig 5b) as that seen in Fig 4b. More clinically
relevant, Fig 5c shows that for
these cases statistically significant Kaplan-Meier
survival rates can be predicted using this threshold according to the date of
patients Time-of-Dx, with detailed statistical parameters listed in Fig 5c.DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
In this work, by measuring
values of serum MRS metabolomic profiles of samples collected from NSCLC
patients both prior-to- and at the time-of -Dx, we demonstrate that LuCa
metabolomics measured from sera has the potential to be developed into
sensitive and specific profiles that may be implemented as a LuCa screening
tool for disease early detections. Furthermore, serum MRS metabolomic profiles,
reflecting the biological activities, present thresholds based on those, NSCLC
patient survival status can be predicted that may assist to guide clinical
strategies for treatment decisions.Acknowledgements
NIH grants CA141139 and the A.A.
Martinos Center for Biomedical Imaging. References
No reference found.