Adriano Troia1, Umberto Zanovello1, Luca Zilberti1, Matteo Cencini2, Michela Tosetti2,3, David Kilian4, Martina Capozza5, Wolfgang Kilian6, and Tuğba Dışpınar Gezer7
1INRIM, Turin, Italy, 2IRCCS Stella Maris, Pisa, Italy, 3IMAGO7 Foundation, Pisa, Italy, 4Centre for Translational Bone, Joint and Soft Tissue Research, Faculty of Medicine and University Hospital TUD, Dresden, Germany, 5Department of Molecular Biotechnology and Health Sciences UNITO, Turin, Italy, 6Physikalisch-Technische Bundesanstalt, Braunschweig, Germany, 7National Metrology Institute, TUBITAK, Istanbul, Turkey
Synopsis
Anthropomorphic
phantoms for MRI imaging are rapidly evolving also thanks to the
increase of 3D printing technologies. Their realization may represent
an important support for the implementation of advanced quantitative
imaging technique such as Magnetic Resonance Fingerprinting (MRF)or
Electrical Properties Tomography (EPT). Even if formulations of gel
based tissue-mimicking materials have been widely explored, generally
they lacked in achieving the simultaneous tuning of electrical and
relaxation properties of the mimicked tissues. In this study,
customized moulds of white and grey matter are combined to realize
brain-like gel phantoms in which relaxation times, conductivity and
permittivity have been measured.
Purpose
Phantoms
for quantitative MRI have been largely studied. However, most of them
take the form of simple vials or bottles filled with salt solutions
or gels with tuneable relaxation properties. As a consequence, they
don’t address other aspects, such as heterogeneity or complex
geometries, typical of real tissues. Here we aim at realizing
heterogeneous phantoms, with tuneable relaxation and electrical
properties, exploiting the fabrication of 3D printed mouldsin order
to obtain anthropomorphicbrain-like structures.This approach will
allow to realize volumetric phantoms of realistic size with the
possibility to test quantitative MR-based imaging technique like MRF
and EPT.Methods
Different
types of naturally-derived polysaccharides and polymers have been
used to realize heterogeneous phantom in order to simulate white and
grey matter. Starting from the results reported in reference [1],
combined blend of Agar and Gellan Gum have been used as a matrix in
which T1 and T2 relaxation times can be modulated independently by
varying the amount of Agar and GdCl3.
Gellan gum has been used to increase the strength and mechanical
stability of the gel, as well as to limit the diffusion phenomena of
the paramagnetic salt due to its electrostatistically crosslinked
gelation mechanism in the presence of divalent ions (i.eGd). To
modulate the electrical properties, different amount of NaCl and
Polyvinylpyrrolidone (PVP) have been used in the above composition,
while, NaN3 has been added as preservative. Negative moulds of white (WM) and
grey matter (GM) have been realised using soft and elastic polymer
like RTV silicone or cryogel based on Polyvinyl alcohol. The
polysaccharide-based solution has been poured in the moulds, using a
step by step pouring technique, to produce a heterogeneous gel-based
structure on the scale of human brain.MRI
measurements have been performed with two different MRI scanners.
Small homogenous phantoms (15ml vials) have been characterized
in a 3T Bruker BioSpecscanner, equipped with a 72
mm 1H coil, to investigate the role of Agar and GdCl3. Raw data have
been analysed with the Bruker Image sequence analysis tool. A "T1
saturation recovery" sequence has been applied to extractT1
values, whilst the "T2 vtr" sequence allowed T2
determination. The anthropomorphic phantoms have been characterized in
a GE HDxt 1.5T in which data have been acquired using a 3D
SSFP-MRF technique [2]. Acquisition schedule consisted of a variable
flip angle train (length: 880 pulses) preceded by an adiabatic
inversion pulse (TE/TR=0.5/8.5ms). Each frame has been sampled with
55 interleaves of a 3D spiral projection trajectory. At the end of
each frame, a spoiler gradient has been applied to obtain a 4π
dephasing along the z-direction. The electrical
properties have been measured using a dielectric measurement
system(SPEAG DAK) based on an open-ended coaxial probe technique. The
probe has been positioned on the flat surface of cylindrical
samples(diameter:10 cm, height: 5 cm) and connected to a network
analyzer (VNA). By means of a commercial software, the conversion
between the complex S-parameters, measured by the VNA, and the
dielectric values of the samples (i.e. electrical conductivity and
dielectric permittivity) has been performed.Results
In
Fig. 1an example of T1 and T2 parametric map is reported,
together with the role of Agar and GdCl3 concentration.
Further measurements confirmed that the variation of these components
allows to independently tune T1 and T2 values within the reported
range. In Fig. 2 the T1 and T2 parametric map for the brain-like
phantom is reported. No presence of diffusion phenomena has been
observed after several months and, as it is possible to note from the
figure, the structure of the heterogeneous phantom clearly traces the
complex geometry of WM and GM compartments. In Fig. 3, an
example of dielectric measurements is shown. In this case, electrical
conductivity and relative permittivity have been modulated by means
of NaCl and PVP. Discussion & Outlook
Preparation
of phantoms using gel-based tissue mimicking materials have been
realized by means of different polysaccharide and additives for
tuning their relaxation and electrical properties. With the aid of 3D
printed moulds, it was possible to realize heterogeneous gel-based
anthropomorphic structures. MRI measurements, performed on this
phantom, showed distinct relaxation parameters comparable to those
reported in literature for WM and GM demonstrating the
feasibility of this approach. .Further
preparations will be investigated in order to tune all the parameters
in a single anthropomorphic phantom, taking into account the
characterization data provided by small samples.Acknowledgements
The results here presented have been developed in the
framework of the 18HLT05 QUIERO Project. This project has received funding from
the EMPIR programme co-financed by the Participating States and from the
European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme.References
1]K.
Yoshimura, Development of a Tissue-Equivalent MRI Phantom Using Carrageenan
Gel, Magnetic Resonance in Medicine 50:1011–1017,(2003)
[2] Pedro A. Gómez [Rapid
three-dimensional multiparametric MRI with quantitative transient-state
imaging, Scientific Reports volume 10, Article number: 13769 (2020).
[3] Debra F. McGivney, SVD
Compression for Magnetic Resonance Fingerprinting in the Time Domain, IEEE
Trans Med Imaging. Dec; 33(12): 2311–2322 (2014)
[4]M. Weigel, Extended Phase
Graphs: Dephasing, RF Pulses,and Echoes - Pure and Simple, Journal Of Magnetic
Resonance Imaging 41:266–295 (2015)