Georg Schramm1, Johan Nuyts1, and Fernando Boada2
1KU Leuven, Leuven, Belgium, 2New York University School of Medicine, New York City, NY, United States
Synopsis
The image quality in sodium MR is hampered by very fast T2* decay during readout and high levels of noise in the acquired data. In this work we propose a joint iterative framework, including signal decay modeling during readout and decay estimation, to reconstruct dual echo sodium MR data. Regularization is incorporated by using an anatomical prior based on a high-resolution hydrogen T1 image. In simulations and a real brain tumor data set acquired on a 3T MR we demonstrate that our framework allows to suppress noise while preserving anatomical detail.
Introduction
Sodium
nuclei yield the second largest in vivo MRI signal and can be used to
image the function of excitable tissues in humans. In contrast to
hydrogen nuclei in tissue, sodium nuclei have much faster relaxation
times, which severely hampers data acquisition and image
reconstruction. Efficient k-space sampling geometries (twisted
projection imaging) are the preferred means to acquire sodium images
in adequate imaging times. In this setting, signal decay due to fast
transverse relaxation during the readout results in loss of high
frequency information and a concomitant exacerbation of partial
voluming. This k-space signal decay during the readout can be
incorporated into the forward model of an iterative reconstruction
algorithm using a time and position dependent decay function. The
resulting reconstruction problem is, however, very ill-posed -
especially if high frequencies are heavily attenuated or suffering
from much lower SNR. To regularize the algorithm, anatomical priors
can be used. In this work, we introduce and demonstrate a framework for iterative sodium MR reconstruction, which models the signal decay and jointly estimates the transverse sodium magnetization and the relaxation time in every voxel. The reconstruction is guided with anatomical (structural) information from a high resolution hydrogen MR image, using Bowsher's method [1].
Theory
In this work, we model the expected acquired signal in k-space as
$$\bar{s}[f,d](k) = \int_V f(x) c(x) d\left(x,t(k)\right) e^{-i 2 \pi \langle k,x\rangle} dx, $$
where $$$f$$$ is the transverse sodium magnetization to be reconstructed, $$$c$$$ is the coil sensitivity, $$$d$$$ is spatially dependent signal decay, and $$$t(k)$$$
is
the readout time corresponding to a given k-space sample.
We approximate the signal decay using a mono-exponential model
$$d\left(x,t(k)\right) = e^{-\frac{t(k)}{T^*_{2}(x)}} = \Gamma (x) ^ \frac{t(k)}{T_E},$$
with
$$\Gamma (x) = e^{-\frac{T_E}{T^*_{2}(x)}},$$
where $$$T_E$$$ is the echo time of the 2nd echo, leading to the joint reconstruction problem for dual echo Na MR data
$$\text{argmin}_{f,\Gamma} \underbrace{||s_1 - \bar{s}_1[f,\Gamma]||_2^2}_\text{data fidelity 1st echo} + \underbrace{||s_2 - \bar{s}_2[\Gamma f,\Gamma]||_2^2}_\text{data fidelity 2nd echo} + \underbrace{\beta _f \left( R(\Re f) + R(\Im f) \right)+ \beta_\Gamma \, R(\Gamma)}_\text{regularization} \ ,$$
where $$$s_1$$$ and $$$s_2$$$ are the acquired k-space data of the first and second echo and $$$\Re f$$$ and $$$\Im f$$$ denote the real and imaginary part of $$$f$$$.
In this work, we use the symmetric Bowsher prior [1] to incorporate anatomical (structural) regularization on f and Γ where structural information is obtained from a high resolution hydrogen T1 MR image.
Methods
The
proposed reconstruction framework was studied using 3D simulated and
real dual echo data. Simulated data were generated based on the
segmented brain-web phantom including realistic Na contrasts and T2*
decay times and a realistic dual-echo readout with echo times of 0ms
and 5ms and a readout time of ca 40ms. Stand-alone features in the
Na, Γ, and anatomical prior image were added to study the transfer
of non- shared structures. All reconstructions were done in
128x128x128 voxel grid. The image quality was analyzed in terms of
regional bias and noise and compared to standard (filtered) inverse
FFTs of the data using 25 noise realizations and different levels of
regularization βf
while
keeping βΓ
=
0.3 constant. Alternating L-BFGS-B updates [2] were used to solve the
non-convex optimization problem. Experimental, dual echo, data from a
brain tumor patient were acquired on a 3T Siemens MR using a
dedicated eight-channel, dual-tuned, head coil. These data were
reconstructed using the same framework and coil sensitivities
estimated using a sum of squares image from all channels.Results
Figure
1 shows reconstructions of one noise realization, as well as mean,
bias and standard deviation images for 25 noise realizations of the
simulated
data for our proposed joint iterative reconstruction framework for
different levels of anatomical regularization in comparison to
unfiltered
and filtered inverse Fourier transforms of the data. Moreover, bias
versus noise curves of 6 different regions are shown in Fig. 2.
Figure 3 displays the reconstruction results of the patient brain
tumor data set for one level of regularization.Discussion
The
results obtained from simulated data shown in Figs. 1 and 2
demonstrate that our proposed iterative joint reconstructions using
anatomical regularization leads to superior bias-noise
characteristics in regions where gradients (edges) are shared between
the sodium and prior image. Especially in grey matter, the bias is
strongly reduced. The anatomical regularization in combination with
signal decay modeling and estimation allows to suppress noise while
preserving anatomical detail at the same time. Transfer of non-shared
gradients from the anatomical prior image into the sodium image is a
potential source of bias that must be carefully controlled. This
source of bias does not appear to compromise the gains obtained
during experimental acquisitions. More experimental data and/or the
use of non-anatomical priors in tandem with our proposed approach can
be used to ascertain these effects.Conclusion
Our
proposed iterative joint reconstruction framework including
anatomical regularization allows to suppress noise while preserving
anatomical detail in reconstructions of dual echo sodium data.
Moreover, it also allows to directly estimate a voxel-wise
mono-exponential T2* decay time.Acknowledgements
Supported in part by PHS grants P41
EB017183-01 and R01NS113517.References
[1] Bowsher et al. “Utilizing MRI information to estimate F18-FDG distributions in rat flank tumors”Nuclear Science Symposium Conference Record, 2004 IEEE
[2] Liu and Nocedal, “On the limited memory BFGS method for large scale optimization”,Mathematical Programming 45, 1989