Samuel W. Holder1,2, Michael Graham Harrington3, and Samuel Colles Grant1,2
1National High Magnetic Field Laboratory, Florida State University, Tallahassee, FL, United States, 2Chemical & Biomedical Engineering, FAMU-FSU College of Engineering, Tallahassee, FL, United States, 3Molecular Neurology Program, Huntington Medical Research Institutes, Pasadena, CA, United States
Synopsis
Spontaneous Trigeminal
Allodynia (STA) occurs within ~50% of male Sprague-Dawley rats, presents
symptoms analogous to migraine and may be alleviated by migraine treatments. Relaxation-enhanced
MRS implemented in the female rat thalamus at 21.1 T examined metabolic effects
of STA using a nitroglycerin-injected model of migraine. It
was found that STA generates glutamate/glutamine and limited lactate responses with even saline injection. However, the STA response is rendered negligible when given a conventional dose of 10-mg/kg nitroglycerin. Future spectroscopic examinations of neurological disorders,
particularly those focused on excitotoxicity/neuroprotection, should account for
this potential effect.
Introduction
Due
to small genetic variances, ~50% of male Sprague-Dawley rats have been reported
to develop spontaneous trigeminal allodynia (STA)1. Examined behaviorally, STA
presents similarly to the mechanical allodynia and phono-sensitivity that
accompany migraine; STA can be alleviated through triptans, a class of migraine
treatment1. These similarities raise
questions about the physiological impacts of STA and potential implications of an
unevaluated factor within the commonly used Sprague-Dawley rat model, particularly for migraine research but extendable to other neurological models. To evaluate
STA impacts, an established model for migraine based on nitroglycerin
(NTG)-induced central sensitization was chosen for direct comparison. in vivo relaxation-enhanced MR
spectroscopy (RE-MRS) was performed at 21.1 T within the female Sprague-Dawley
rat thalamus. The thalamus was chosen due to its involvement in migraine
attacks and previous metabolic response to NTG in the male rat, including significant
changes in lactate (Lac), glutamate/glutamine (Glx) and taurine (Tau)2. Methods
The presence of
STA was determined behaviorally through application of Von Frey filaments to
the periorbital region. Filaments ranged from 0.008-26 g and were increased sequentially
until an aversive withdrawal occurred in 2 of 3 or 3 of 5 applications. The trial
was repeated four times, 1 h apart, on alternating sides of the head. Animals
were separated into two behavioral groups, naturally resilient (NR) and
experiencing STA, based on their mechanical sensitivity threshold. Prior to
scanning, animals were anesthetized with 5% isoflurane in oxygen for surgery implantation
of an intraperitoneal line to deliver nitroglycerin (NTG) in situ while
in the magnet and after baseline scans were acquired. Post-surgery, rodents
were maintained at 2-3% isoflurane in oxygen for the remainder of the scanning,
then promptly sacrificed.
Groups examined were NR animals dosed with
saline (N=8), 2-mg/kg NTG (N=6) or 10-mg/kg NTG (N=6), with STA animals scanned
at identical dosages (N=7, N=3, and N=4, respectively). Spectra (Figure 1)
were acquired using a relaxation-enhanced, spectrally selective spin echo
sequence localized to a 4x3x3-mm3 voxel via Localization by
Adiabatic SElective Refocusing (LASER). The voxel was centered between thalamic
lobes. With an effective TE=54 ms and TR=2.5 s, spectra were averaged eight
times per repetition, with 32 repetitions performed. Peak selection was
performed in Bruker Topspin 4. Scans repeated every 20 min out to 2 h post-injection.
Spectral data was normalized to the NAA signal;
ratios are presented as a percentage change from baseline values. Statistical
analysis was performed in JMP Pro 15 (SAS, Inc). One-way ANOVA were used to
establish significance along time and between NTG doses, with a post-hoc Student's t tests used to determine group differences, both with p<0.05.Results & Discussion
The Von Frey examination
denoted a clear difference between NR and STA animals. The spontaneous nature
of STA is demonstrated in Figure 2. While STA animals may appear
resilient during individual trials, their variance between trials is large,
reaching mechanical sensitivity thresholds as low as 1.4 g. However, NR animals
never drop below a threshold of 10 g and experience much less variance.
Thalamic spectra show the clearest distinction
between STA and NR groups with saline injection (Figure 3). At later
times, saline STA Glx is significantly and progressively elevated from baseline
levels, unlike saline NR. Notably, despite being a spontaneous condition, STA
saline appears to display a Glx buildup over time, with larger variations at these
later times. However, with NTG injection to induce central sensitization, NR
and STA Glx signal changes are consistent (Figure 3), with only one time
point showing a significant difference (t=55 min). NTG induction appears to
overwhelm the spontaneous buildup of Glx, with possible increases in variance
for the STA group at some time points.
With respect to Lac, NR and STA cohorts
are remarkably similar over time with NTG injection (Figure 4). As lactate
would be increase with increased glycolysis to meet rising cellular energy
demands, the Lac trends are consistent with previous examinations of the
nitroglycerin model in male rats2, albeit occurring much at earlier times
post-injection in females. The earlier Lac significance might be a sex-specific
dose response, which is under evaluation. However, at the 2-mg/kg NTG dose,
similar Lac trends are evident for NR and STA, though these fail to reach
significance. At the highest NTG dose employed, the only potential
difference between NR and STA cohorts may be the differences in variances at
certain time points.Conclusion
RE-MRS at 21.1 T was
implemented to examine the metabolic impacts of STA and its impacts on a
migraine analog. In the female Sprague-Dawley thalamus, STA induced buildup of
Glx and late increases in Lac. Meanwhile, the impacts of STA with NTG
triggering were negligible compared to NR animals aside from possible and occasional
increases in variances with STA. Notably, the STA increase in Glx with saline is
largely mitigated at both NTG doses. Regardless, the impact of STA should be
considered in current and future investigations involving this animal model,
particularly with respect to Glx-related substrates. Acknowledgements
This work was
supported by the US NIH (R01-NS072497) and the US National High Magnetic Field
Laboratory, which is supported by the National Science Foundation (DMR-1644779)
and the State of Florida.References
1. Oshinsky,
M. L. et al. Spontaneous trigeminal allodynia in rats: A model of
primary headache. Headache 52, 1336–1349 (2012).
2. Abad, N. et al. Metabolic
assessment of a migraine model using relaxation-enhanced 1H
spectroscopy at ultrahigh field. Magn. Reson. Med. 79, 1266–1275
(2018).