Graeme A. Keith1, Amir Seginer2, David A. Porter1, and Rita Schmidt3
1Institute of Neuroscience and Psychology, University of Glasgow, Glasgow, Scotland, 2Siemens Healthcare Ltd, Rosh Ha’ayin, Israel, 3Neurobiology Department, Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel
Synopsis
Echo-planar spectroscopic imaging (EPSI) is a fast method of
acquiring metabolic information in the human brain. When applied at high-fields, such
as 7T however, it suffers from limited spectral-width, as well as the inconsistencies
between readout lines, seen at all field strengths, which lead to ghosts in the
spectra. In this work, we present the readout-segmented COKE method, which removes the
spectral-width limitation at 7T and provides a coherent phase evolution that
avoids Nyquist artefacts in the spectra. Simulations and phantom scans are also
presented, which seek to increase understanding of residual lipid contamination
due to the readout-segmented spatial-encoding scheme.
Introduction
Magnetic resonance spectroscopic imaging provides
metabolic information with high diagnostic value, but scan times are often too
long for routine clinical application. One technique to reduce acquisition time
is echoplanar spectroscopic imaging (EPSI)1-3. There is great
interest in using this technique at 7T, where there is higher SNR and improved
spectral resolution. However, the spectral width (SW) in EPSI is determined by
gradient performance and can be insufficient to match the higher value required
at 7T. In addition, the EPSI trajectory suffers from inconsistencies between
readout lines acquired with alternating positive and negative gradients4.
In this 1H study at 7T, we combine two methods: (1) readout
segmentation5 to increase the spectral width, and (2) COKE
(COnsistent K-t space Epsi)6,7 to produce a consistent temporal
phase evolution.Methods
Fig. 1
shows the Readout-Segmented COKE (RS-COKE) pulse sequence8, which
was implemented on a 7T MAGNETOM Terra (Siemens Healthcare, Erlangen, Germany).
The sequence has a VAPOR water-suppression module9 and a pair of
adiabatic pulses for spin-echo preparation10. The COKE
gradient-encoding scheme interleaves blipped phase-encoding (PE) gradients
between odd and even readout lobes. This displaces phase discontinuities caused
by readout-gradient polarity from the temporal to the PE direction, thereby
shifting the Nyquist artefacts from the spectral to the image domain, where
their effect is more benign. The resulting image-domain ghost is minimized by
phase correction using standard techniques11.
Three phantoms were used to examine and optimize the sequence – 1) a spherical
oil phantom, 2) a 3D-printed phantom with a “brain”
compartment mimicking brain metabolite content and 3) a 3D-shaped phantom with brain-like
compounds and a superficial compartment with a lipid-like compound. The 3D
head-shaped phantom was designed to resemble the brain with respect to B0 and
B1 distributions, metabolite content, and the subcutaneous lipid layer (see
Ref. 12). The metabolite content included 10mM
L-Glutamic acid, 10mM Creatine, 8mM myo-Inositol, 2mM GABA, 2mM Choline
chloride, 5mM Choline chloride, 5mM Sodium lactate, and 12.5mM NAA. Sequence parameters for the 3D printed phantom scans were: TR/TE 1200/35 ms, FOV
200x250 mm2, slice thickness 15 mm, in-plane resolution 3.7x4 mm2
(54x64 acquisition matrix), 3 readout segments, SW 2778 Hz, echo spacing 0.36
ms, 296 echoes, and scan duration 3:50 min.
Data
were acquired from the brain of a healthy subject using the following
parameters: TR/TE 2000/35 ms, FOV 200x250 mm2, slice thickness 15 mm, in-plane
resolution 4.3x4.5 mm2 (46x56 acquisition matrix), 3 readout segments, SW 2778
Hz, echo spacing 0.36 ms, 296 echoes, and scan duration 5:36 min. Simulations were also performed to investigate
image-domain artifacts caused by the effect of residual lipid signals on
readout-segmented spatial encoding.Results and Discussion
Fig. 2 compares single-segment COKE and EPSI, demonstrating
that the COKE version can provide a full spectrum without ghosting artifacts following
a navigator-based even/odd phase correction11. Fig. 3 shows summed
spectra from three human brain regions (5x5 voxels, 0.3mL per voxel). The
spectra demonstrate well-resolved metabolite peaks, but are contaminated by
signal from subcutaneous lipids. This contamination is partly caused by
imperfect kx trajectories causing a ringing artefact in the readout
direction of the image due to mismatch at the interfaces between readout segments.
Fig. 4a shows that for a “brain” only compartment the 3-segment RS-EPSI and
RS-COKE provide similar results without significant artifacts. Fig. 4b compares
single-segment and three-segment acquisitions with a
lipid layer. A ringing artefact can be observed in the three-segment
water image. One method to reduce the ringing artifact is to apply saturation
bands to reduce the lipid signal contribution, as shown in Fig.4b. It shows
clear improvement of the metabolite spectra, however, the saturation bands also
reduce the water suppression efficiency by a factor of
four. Fig. 5 shows simulated results
for an annulus-shaped object, considering only the first echo of each
echo-train. In the current implementation,
each readout segment is acquired at the same time point, relative to the
excitation, resulting in phase discontinuities at segment interfaces for
off-resonant signals. Such an acquisition can result in a ringing artifact
when the annulus signal is off-resonance (Fig.5a). The simulation results in
fig. 5b show how time-shifting the outer segments by ±echo-spacing removes the
phase discontinuities and the off-resonance artifacts are suppressed. The much
smaller residual ringing artifact probably corresponds to Gibbs ringing due to the
low spatial resolution. Fig. 5d shows simulated data
that demonstrate the effect of kx trajectory imperfections, which
cause similar ringing artifacts, but which are not specific to off-resonant
signals. In practice, these artifacts are minimised by empirically
scaling the readout gradients to improve the continuity of the kx
trajectory at segment interfaces.Conclusion
The readout-segmented COKE method allows fast
spectroscopic imaging and high spatial resolution for human application at 7T.
The method is capable of removing the spectral-width limitation at 7T and
provides a coherent phase evolution that avoids Nyquist artefacts in the
spectra. However, before the method can be used for routine studies in vivo, further
work is required to minimize the effect of lipid contamination on the
readout-segmented spatial encoding scheme. The phantom experiments and
simulations in this study have led to an increased understanding of these
artifacts and provided potential mitigations that can be explored in future
work.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1] Mansfield, MRM 1984; [2] Posse et.al,
MRM 1997; [3] Lin et.al, MRM 2007; [4] Posse et.al JMRI 2013; [5]
Keith et al, ISMRM 2019; [6] Schmidt et al MRM 2019; [7] Webb et.al, MRM
1989; [8] Keith et al, ESMRMB 2020 [9] Tkac, MRM 1999; [10]Connolly MRM 1991; [11] Chen. et. Al, MRM 2004; [12] Jona et. al, NMR
BioMed 2020.