Keshav Datta1 and Daniel Spielman1
1Department of Radiology, Stanford University, Stanford, CA, United States
Synopsis
Metabolic imaging using hyperpolarized [2-13C]Pyruvate
has the potential to simultaneously probe glycolysis and Kreb’s cycle, but one
of its major limitations is the difficulty in imaging [2-13C]Lactate.
The peak-splitting induced by the J-coupling between the C2 carbon
and its attached proton causes ghosting and blurring artifacts, depending on
the k-space trajectory. We propose two novel techniques, the first a two-shot
approach combining in-phase and quadrature images acquired at echo times
differing by 1/2J and the second a single-shot method employing a highly
narrowband radiofrequency excitation pulse that images a single peak from the doublet,
to resolve the J-modulated artifacts.
1.1 Introduction
[2-13C]Pyruvate (Pyr) is an attractive
choice for hyperpolarized imaging with first human studies reported recently1. The 13C label at the C2
position is both converted to [2-13C]Lactate (Lac) and observable
from the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle intermediates citrate, glutamate and
acetylcarnitine, thus providing a simultaneous real-time window into glycolysis
(GLY) and oxidative phosphorylation (OXPHOS)2,3. However, imaging
[2-13C]Lac is challenging due to blurring and ghosting artifacts arising
from J-coupling between the 13C2 and the 1H
nuclei. We present two techniques based on the idea of
quadrature detection to resolve these artifacts. The key contribution of this work
is the use of product operator formalism to derive the evolution of coherences
in the presence of J-coupling as well as chemical shift to show that the
combination of in-phase and anti-phase doublets resolves the peak-splitting
during image acquisition. Results from simulations, phantoms and rat brain
highlight the utility of this method for simultaneous assessment of GLY and
OXPHOS in vivo. While these techniques are presented in the context of
hyperpolarized 13C metabolic imaging, they are generally applicable
to any spin-1/2 J-coupled spin system. Details can be found in this publication4.1.2 Theory
Quadrature imaging
When imaging compounds such as [2-13C]Lac,
J-coupling between the labeled carbon and attached proton causes a cosine
modulation of k-space samples given by $$$S^{'}[k_x(t),k_y(t)]=cos(πJt+φ)S[k_x(t),k_y (t)] $$$ (Fig. 1). Measuring the quadrature component
via a second acquisition delayed by 1/2J can compensate for this modulation,
resulting in an artifact-free image with complex combination of the two
acquisitions:
$$I_{rec} (x,y)=I(x,y)*IFT(cos(πJt+φ))+iI(x,y)*IFT({cos(πJ(t+\frac{1}{2J})+φ) })\qquad$$
$$ =I(x,y)*IFT(cos(πJt+φ))+iI(x,y)*IFT({({sin(πJt+φ)})}\space\space\space$$
$$=I(x,y-Y)e^{iφ }\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\qquad\space\space\space\space [1]$$
where φ represents the phase accumulation due to the
delay between excitation and data acquisition. Y is an easily corrected spatial
shift given by $$$k_y Y=\frac{J.T_{readout}}{2}$$$.
Narrowband excitation
For a spin-1/2
J-coupled system ($$$\hat{I}$$$≡13C and $$$\hat{S}$$$≡1H),
a sufficiently narrow spectrally selective excitation pulse applied at
off-resonance frequency $$$Ω_I=πJ$$$ generates the following coherences at the end
of the radiofrequency pulse:
$$ \hat{σ}_{RF}=(\frac{1}{2})\hat{I}_z-(\frac{1}{2}) 2\hat{I}_z\hat{S}_z+(\frac{1}{2})\hat{I}_y+(\frac{1}{2})2\hat{I}_y\hat{S}_z\qquad\qquad\qquad [2]$$
During readout, the sum of in-phase doublet from the $$$\hat{I}_y$$$ term and anti-phase doublet from $$$2\hat{I}_y\hat{S}_z$$$ produces a singlet, eliminating all J-coupling
associated artifacts (Fig. 2).1.3 Methods
Simulation & in
vitro experiments: A full-density matrix simulator for a coupled 2-spin I-S
system in MATLAB (Mathworks Inc.) developed in-house was used to simulate the
evolution of coherences. A syringe filled with 10ml of 0.5M [2-13C]Lac
(or 3ml of 2.5M 13C Formate), doped with a Gadolinium agent, was
placed in a 13C transmit-receive surface coil and imaged using a
clinical 3T PET-MR scanner (GE Medical systems). For quadrature imaging, two images whose echo times differed by
1/2J=3.6 ms (J=140Hz for [2-13C]Lac) were acquired using a
slice-selective fast echo-planar imaging sequence (gradient echo
EPI,FOV=128mm,slice-thickness=20mm,TR=130ms,TE=22.8ms,FA=800,matrix=32x32,receiver
BW=41.7kHz,NEX=150). A narrowband spectrally selective radiofrequency
excitation pulse (BW=100Hz,slice-thickness=20mm,70Hz off-resonance), followed by a 2D GRE-EPI image
acquisition (FOV=128mm,TR=130ms,TE=22.8ms,FA=800,matrix=32x32,receiver
BW=41.7kHz,NEX=150) , was used to test the narrowband technique.
Hyperpolarization and
in vivo imaging of [2-13C]Lac: 54ml of 15.5M [2-13C]Pyruvic
acid mixed with 15mM trityl radical was polarized between 3-4 hours in GE SPINLab
system and dissolved using 16g solution of 40mM tris buffer,100mg/L EDTA, and
50mM NaCl. After neutralizing with 640ul of 125mM NaOH buffer, 2.5ml of the resulting
100mM pyruvate solution was injected at a rate of 0.25mL/s into a male Wistar
rat through a tail-vein catheter and imaged in a clinical GE 3T scanner 20s
post injection to maximize the signal from lactate. A narrowband radiofrequency(RF)
pulse centered on one of the lactate peaks followed by an EPI readout, with the
same parameters as for the phantom, was used to acquire the [2-13C]Lac
image from an axial slice through the rat-brain and overlaid on a T1-weighted
proton image for anatomical reference.
Reconstruction
and post-processing: An empirical scale factor, Acorr,
to compensate for the T1 and flip
angle related losses, and a relative phase factor ϕcorr to counter the phase accumulation arising from
off-resonance effects (offres) were introduced in Eq. [1],
i.e.,
Irec (x,y)=I1 (x,y)+iAcorrI2 (x,y) eiϕcorr. The resulting image was
shifted by $$$(\frac{J}{2}+offres )*T_{readout}$$$ pixels in the slower k-space acquisition
direction to offset the shift arising from the quadrature reconstruction. In
the case of narrowband acquisition, the native scanner EPI reconstruction was
used without any further processing.1.4 Results
Quadrature Imaging
(Fig. 3): EPI acquisitions from thermally polarized and hyperpolarized
phantoms show the severity of J-modulation artifacts, which are resolved via
the complex combination of two acquisitions, one delayed by 1/2J.
Narrowband
Imaging: Analytically derived and simulated coherences
during broadband and narrowband RF excitations are shown in Fig. 4. Data from
simulations, [2-13C]Lac and 13C-formate phantoms (Fig. 4),
and an in vivo [2-13C]Pyr rat brain study (Fig. 5), demonstrate the
effectiveness of the narrowband excitation approach.1.5 Discussion and Conclusions
The two-shot and single-shot imaging strategies
described here utilize the same underlying principle of combining in-phase and
quadrature components to recover the signal free of J-coupling artifacts. The two-shot method sequentially acquires the
sine and cosine components, whereas the single-shot technique based on use of highly
selective RF pulse simultaneously generates in-phase (cosine) and anti-phase
(sine) coherences that combine to produce a singlet during imaging. Simulations, in vitro, and in vivo results demonstrate the potential
utility of these methods for imaging of [2-13C]Lac in a hyperpolarized
[2-13C]Pyr experiment.Acknowledgements
The Lucas Foundation, NIH
grants R01EB019018, R01CA176836, P41 EB015891.References
- Chung BT, Chen HY, Gordon J, et al. First
hyperpolarized [2-13C]pyruvate MR studies of human brain metabolism.
Journal of Magnetic Resonance. vol. 309, p. 106617, 2019. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jmr.2019.106617
- Schroeder MA, Atherton HJ, Ball DR, et al. Real-time assessment of
Krebs cycle metabolism using hyperpolarized 13C magnetic resonance
spectroscopy. The FASEB Journal. vol. 23, no. 8, pp. 2529-2538, 2009. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1096/fj.09-129171
- Park JM, Josan S, Grafendorfer T, et al. Measuring mitochondrial
metabolism in rat brain in vivo using MR Spectroscopy of hyperpolarized [2‐13C]pyruvate.
NMR in Biomedicine. vol. 26, no. 10, pp. 1197-1203, 2013. DOI: https://doi.org/10.1002/nbm.2935
- Datta K, Spielman D. MRI of [2-13C]Lactate
without J-coupling artifacts. Magn. Reson Med. 85: 1522-1539, 2020. DOI:
https://doi.org/10.1002/mrm.28532