Fasil Gadjimuradov1,2, Seung Su Yoon1,2, Thomas Benkert2, Marcel Dominik Nickel2, Karl Engelhard3, and Andreas Maier1
1Pattern Recognition Lab, Friedrich-Alexander-Universität Erlangen-Nürnberg, Erlangen, Germany, 2Magnetic Resonance, Siemens Healthcare GmbH, Erlangen, Germany, 3Department of Radiology, Martha-Maria Hospital, Nürnberg, Germany
Synopsis
Partial Fourier (PF) acquisition schemes are a common way to increase
the inherently low signal-to-noise ratio in diffusion-weighted (DW) images. The
naïve solution of zero-filling k-space results in visible blurring and Gibbs
ringing. Based on the circumstance that traditional methods such as homodyne
reconstruction or POCS often fail to remove blurring and ringing without
introducing new artifacts, this work aims to use a Convolutional Neural Network
for robust PF reconstruction in prostate DWI. We show that our data-driven
approach, which efficiently uses correlations across different b-values,
outperforms traditional methods in terms of quantitative measures and visual
impression of the images.
Introduction
Diffusion weighted imaging (DWI) has emerged as a valuable tool for the
assessment of prostate cancer, providing high sensitivity in lesion detection1.
However, prostate DWI inherently suffers from low signal-to-noise ratio (SNR).
When using EPI sequences, partial Fourier (PF) sampling along the
phase-encoding direction shortens the echo train and thereby the effective TE,
resulting in increased signal.
Zero-filling (ZF) the missing k-space lines inevitably leads to blurring
and Gibbs ringing in the reconstructed image. Commonly used techniques for PF
reconstruction, such as Projection onto Convex Sets2 (POCS) and
homodyne reconstruction3 produce unsatisfactory results in regions
with rapid phase variations and tend to introduce additional noise when
estimating high-frequency components. Alternatively, Convolutional Neural
Networks (CNNs) have been proposed for PF reconstruction, showing promising
results for Dixon imaging4 and brain DWI5. However, it
remains unclear how these approaches generalize to the task of PF
reconstruction in prostate DWI which is particularly difficult due to low SNR.
The goal of this work is to develop a CNN-based method for PF
reconstruction of DW images of the prostate. In contrast to previous work,
correlations across different b-values are exploited.Methods
Data: A prototype EPI
sequence was used to acquire fully-sampled DW images of the prostate at two
b-values (50 and 800$$$\,$$$s/mm2) in 18
male volunteers on 1.5$$$\,$$$T and 3$$$\,$$$T MR scanners (MAGNETOM, Siemens Healthcare GmbH,
Erlangen, Germany). In addition, one patient with suspected prostate cancer was
scanned to showcase the clinical value. While 15 volunteer data sets were used
for training, the data of one volunteer served as a validation set. The
remaining two volunteers as well as the patient data set were used for testing. Instead
of operating on the combined, trace-weighted magnitude images, our model was
applied to the complex-valued images of the single shots. In order to augment
the data set, images were acquired with two different phase-encoding directions
(RL and AP) and with both single-shot EPI and reduced FOV EPI (ZOOMit). In
total, the training, validation and test splits contained 10944, 768 and 1536
images, respectively.
CNN training: For preprocessing,
images were retrospectively downsampled by multiplication with a PF mask in k-space,
yielding the zero-filled images. For training, the images were interpolated to
a fixed resolution of 100x100 pixels. The complex-valued images were
presented as a two-channel input to the network. A modified version of a state-of-the-art
CNN in the related field of super-resolution was used as network architecture6
(see Figure 1 for details). Training was performed by minimizing the L1-loss
between the network output and the fully-sampled ground-truth images using the
Adam optimizer7 with a learning rate of 10-4. Based on
the observation that the deblurring ability of the network on low-signal b800
images was poor, we tried to utilize the correlations between different
b-values by concatenating b50 and b800 images along the channel dimension.
Although b50 and b800 images show different contrasts, they share similar
structural information, hence, allowing the less noisy b50 image to serve as a "guidance".
As a post-processing step which further enforced data fidelity, the k-space of
the output images was substituted by measured data where it was available.
Evaluation: The results on the
test set were evaluated quantitatively and qualitatively and compared to standard
PF reconstruction methods. In addition to retrospectively and prospectively undersampled trace-weighted images, the performance was analyzed on derived ADC maps
as well.Results & Discussion
Table 1 gives an overview of the quantitative results of our CNN and the
reference methods zero-filling (ZF), POCS and homodyne reconstruction. On the
entire test set, our CNN outperforms the next-best method (POCS) by +$$$\,$$$0.0175 (SSIM) and +$$$\,$$$1.45$$$\,$$$dB (PSNR). For b800
images, the improvements are lower than for b50 images, underlining
the difficulty of training the network for inputs with very low SNR.
The qualitative comparison on retrospectively undersampled images
presented in Figure 2 confirms the quantitative results. While the ZF
reconstruction suffers from strong blurring and ringing, POCS as well as the
homodyne reconstruction are capable of restoring resolution. However, this
comes at the cost of a structured noise pattern across the image. In contrast,
our method performs deringing and deblurring without visual noise enhancement. The
above-mentioned observations equivalently hold true for prospectively
undersampled images (see Figure 3).
Figure 4 shows the ADC map of a patient with suspected prostate cancer.
While an area of restricted diffusion is clearly delineated in the
fully-sampled ground-truth image, blurring in the ZF reconstruction makes it more
difficult to differentiate it from normal tissue. Our CNN-based method restores
image quality and sharpness nearly to the level of the ground-truth.Conclusion
We showed that a CNN-based reconstruction enables robust PF
imaging. Unlike traditional reconstruction techniques, our method recovers
image quality without introducing noticeable artifacts. Furthermore,
correlations across b-values are exploited to improve performance for high
b-values. The proposed technique provided promising results for prostate DWI in
healthy volunteers and one patient. Although it was only applied to an extreme case of a PF factor of 5/8 in this work, the concept is similarly
applicable to other commonly used PF factors. A clinical validation is the subject of future
work.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
-
Turkbey B, Rosenkrantz AB, Haider MA, et al. "Prostate Imaging Reporting and Data System
Version 2.1: 2019 Update of Prostate Imaging Reporting and Data System Version
2." European Urology (2019).
- Haacke EM,
Lindskogj ED, and Lin W. "A fast, iterative, partial-Fourier technique
capable of local phase recovery." Journal of Magnetic Resonance, 92(1):126-145
(1991).
- Noll DC,
Nishimura DG, and Macovski A. "Homodyne detection in magnetic resonance
imaging." IEEE transactions on medical imaging, 10(2):154-163
(1991).
- Toews AR,
Alley MT, Vasanawala SS, et al. "Deep Partial Fourier Reconstruction."
Proceedings of the ISMRM, #48702 (2019).
- Muckley MJ,
Ades-Aron B, Papaioannou A, et al. "Training a Neural Network for Gibbs
and Noise Removal in Diffusion MRI." http://arxiv.org/abs/1905.04176
(2019). Accessed
November 5, 2019.
-
Zhang Y, Tian Y, Kong Y, et al. "Residual Dense Network
for Image Super-Resolution." Proceedings of the IEEE Conference on
Computer Vision and Pattern Recognition, 2472-2481 (2018).
-
Kingma DP, and Ba J. "Adam: A
method for stochastic optimization." http://arxiv.org/abs/1412.6980 (2014).
Accessed November 5, 2019.