Athanasia Kaika1,2, Mathias Schillmaier1,2, Geoffrey J. Topping1,2, and Franz Schilling1,2
1Technical University of Munich, Munich, Germany, 2Nuclear Medicine, Klinikum rechts der Isar, Munich, Germany
Synopsis
Filter-Exchange
Imaging (FEXI) is a noninvasive double-diffusion imaging method, sensitive to
transmembrane water exchange, which is strongly connected to cell viability. A
FEXI sequence was implemented and tested in vitro with baker’s yeast. Upon permeabilization with ethanol, AXR increased whereas ADC
decreased, more so with increasing ethanol concentration. AXR reduced over time, but only minor
changes in ADC, intracellular volume and Trypan staining were detected.
Purpose
The alteration
of cell membrane water permeability is a common cell feature that reflects fundamental
biological processes involved in the development of cancer and during cell
death1,2. Recently, a novel MRI method named ‘filter-exchange
imaging’ (FEXI) has been presented that non-invasively detects transmembrane
water exchange, quantified by the so-called apparent exchange rate (AXR)3-5.
The aim of this work was to establish an imaging protocol to map relative cell
membrane permeability changes under different permeabilization conditions in
vitro by using FEXI. Methods
PhantomsIn vitro experiments were
carried out in three phantoms containing suspensions of baker’s yeast.
- On top of the yeast suspension, a thick layer of detergent was added
for cell permeabilization and to generate AXR contrast as described previously
by Lasič et al.4
- Yeast was mixed with DPBS (2:1 w/w). After
15h, the suspension was centrifuged (10 min; 2000rpm). A temperature sensor with 0.1°C accuracy was
placed in the phantom.
- Yeast cells were permeabilized with ethanol solutions
(3%, 13%, 23%) containing DPBS8.
MR measurementAll
experiments were performed on a 7T small animal MRI scanner (Agilent/GE/Bruker)
using a
1H/
13C dual channel resonator (RAPID Biomedical).
Imaging parameters of the FEXI sequence (Figure 1) included: diffusion filter
at b-value of 1300 s/mm
2, diffusion encoding (parallel to diffusion
filter) at
b-values of [123, 277, 477, 677, 977]s/mm
2 and [47.5, 222, 422, 622, 922]s/mm
2 (for experiment
with ethanol), mixing
times (
tm) of [33.4 93.4 163.4 213.4 303.4]ms, gradient
separation (
∆f,∆)=16ms, gradient duration (
δf,δ)=4ms, TE=31.3ms
and 24.5 ms (for experiment with ethanol), TR= 3500ms, matrix size=32x32, FOV=64x64mm and 48x48mm
(for detergent layer experiment), slice thickness 5mm, averages=10, data acquisition time per AXR map =
17min 30sec. Phantoms 1 and 3 were at scanner room temperature (approx. 16°C) and phantom
2 was at 22°C and 31°C.
Image analysisThe signal acquired at different b-values in each FEXI acquisition
was fitted voxel by voxel to equation 1 to generate parametric ADC maps for
each mixing time. Then, parametric maps of AXR and filter efficiency (
σ) were calculated
according to equations 2 and 3.
$$ S (b,t_m) = S_f (t_m ) exp(-b\cdot ADC’(t_m)) \quad \quad [Eq. 1]$$
$$ ADC’(t_m)=ADC[1-σ \exp(-AXR \cdot t_m)] \quad \quad [Eq. 2] $$
$$ σ =1-\frac{ADC’(0)}{ADC} \quad \quad [Eq. 3] $$
where $$$ S_f (t_m ) $$$ is the signal intensity before the application
of the detection module and $$$ ADC’(t_m) $$$ the filtered ADC for each
mixing time.
MicroscopyViability assessment of the baker’s yeast cells were
performed with an optical microscope (Olympus BH2) and Trypan blue staining. The
intracellular volume was calculated from the cell cross-section area which was estimated
from fluorescence microscope (BZ-9000 (BIOREVO)) bright-field images. The cell
cross-section images were analyzed with the software ImageJ.
Results and Discussion
An increase of permeability
of a baker’s yeast cell
suspension in contact with a detergent was observed by a hyperintense region
within an AXR map (Figure 2), seen as peak in the AXR profiles across the
sample (Figure 2e). Despite
the lack of exchange between the water and the detergent, the AXR value is non-zero
in the top layer of the AXR map. This non-zero AXR value stems from the
longitudinal relaxation rate difference between the detergent and the water as
observed previously4.
Cell membrane permeability
increases with temperature (Figure 3). The measured AXR value of the baker’s yeast pellet was ̴ 20% lower
compared to the results from Åslund, I. et al.5, possibly related to
differences in cell preparation.
Phantoms with higher
ethanol concentration had higher AXR but lower ADC (Figure 4 and 5). The ethanol penetrates and softens
the phosphatidylcholine membrane9.
The AXR
values of the yeast pellets treated with 23%, 13% and 3% ethanol (Figure 4) were reduced by 77%, 66% and 63%, respectively, between 210 min and 294
min from start of treatment (Figure 5). However, the intracellular volume, estimated from fluorescence microscope
bright-field images (Figure 5c), and the
ADC were almost
constant over this time. After pelleting the cell sample, the contribution of
the intracellular water fractional population to the ADC becomes higher. The mean intracellular volume decreases with an
increase in ethanol concentration (Figure 5) and thus leads to a reduction of the measured ADC.
No difference in the viability
of treated cells with ethanol concentration was observed after staining
the samples with Trypan blue.Conclusion
FEXI is
able to detect cell membrane permeability alterations
of living cells without requiring contrast agents. Measurements of baker’s yeast cells permeabilized
by different ethanol concentrations show changes of AXR over time, whereas no
changes in ADC and in the Trypan staining were detected. As FEXI is compatible
with the hardware constraints of clinical MRI scanners, it may be a valuable
tool to monitor treatment response of pathologies which are subject to changes
in membrane permeability.Acknowledgements
The present work was supported by the
Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation – 391523415,
SFB 824). References
- Ruggiero
MR, Baroni S, Pezzana S, et al. Evidence
for the Role of Intracellular Water Lifetime as a Tumour Biomarker Obtained by
In Vivo Field-Cycling Relaxometry. Angew Chem Int Ed Engl.
2018;57(25):7468–7472.
- Galluzzi
L, Vitale I, Aaronson SA, et al. Molecular
mechanisms of cell death: recommendations of the Nomenclature Committee on Cell
Death 2018. Cell Death
Differ. 2018;25(3):486–541.
- Nilsson
M, Lätt J, Westen D, et al. Noninvasive
mapping of water diffusional exchange in the human brain using filter-exchange
imaging. Magn
Reson Med. 2013; 69(6):
1573–1581.
- Lasič S, Nilsson M, Lätt J, et al. Apparent exchange rate mapping with diffusion MRI. Magn
Reson Med. 2011; 66(2):356-65.
- Aslund I, Nowacka A, Nilsson M, et al. Filter-exchange PGSE
NMR determination of cell membrane permeability. Magn Reson Med. 2011; 66(2):356-65.
- Trawczyńska I, Miłek J, Sylwia JK. Effect
of temperature, concentration of alcohols and time on baker’s yeast
permeabilization process. Technical Sciences. 2018; 21(3), 195–206.
- Shinoda W. Permeability across lipid membranes.
Biochimica et Biophysica Acta. 2016; 1858 (10),
2254-2265.