Said Aldemir1, Fatima tu Zahra2, Redi Poni3, and Ergin Atalar4
1Electrical and Electronics Engineering, Bilkent University, Ankara, Turkey, 2-, Ankara, Turkey, 3ETH Zurich, Zurich, Sweden, 4Electrical Electronics Engineering, Bilkent University, Ankara, Turkey
Synopsis
In this work, performance
of coupled Class-E amplifiers in a transmit array system is investigated. Conditions
for these nonlinear amplifiers to work efficiently with desired output power
are determined. Also a tuning procedure mitigating undesired effects of
coupling on the performance of these nonlinear amplifiers is explained. Simulations
are performed in ADS 2016 with 2 Class-E amplifiers and different coupling
levels are tested. MRI experiment is performed in order to observe the effects
of coupling on amplifier performance. With contour plots, how overall
performance of the system is affected by phase and amplitude of an amplifier
channel is investigated.
Introduction
The main purpose of this work is to replace the conventional
RF amplifiers used in MRI systems with highly efficient on-coil array of modified
Class-E amplifiers. Each amplifier in the transmit array may have various phase
and amplitude. When tuned and highly efficient
Class-E amplifiers are put together in a transmit array system, performance of
the amplifiers degrades significantly due to the coupling between channels.
In this work, conditions for achieving high efficiency with coupled Class-E
amplifiers are stated; tuning procedure for the amplifier components is
explained, the effects of phase and amplitude of the channel on the amplifier
performance are observed. The operation of the amplifiers in a coupled system
is simulated and MRI experiments are conducted on a 1.5T MR scanner. This work mainly focused on finding a mode of operation
which satisfies high drain efficiency for the overall system and tuning
nonlinear amplifiers in a transmit array system to optimize drain efficiency.Methods
In the transmit
array system, mutual coupling between each amplifier channel significantly affects
the operation of Class-E amplifier. In order to observe this effect,
two Class-E amplifiers which work simultaneously at 64 MHz are simulated in ADS
2016. Figure 1 shows the simulation parameters of the amplifiers with mutual
coupling determined by coupling coefficient (k). Drain efficiency is monitored
in the simulation for different coupling coefficients.
Drain efficiency of the Class-E amplifier decreased significantly with high
mutual coupling and the tuning is distorted.
In
order to improve the efficiency of amplifiers in a transmit array, N.O. Sokal’s
explanation1 over tuning a single amplifier is utilized. Figure 2 shows the effect of load components on the
switch voltage waveform. Positive coupling between the amplifiers cause an
increase in the inductance of load network therefore the waveform will be
shifted as Figure 2.
In order to eliminate this negative effect on the amplifier efficiency, series
load capacitor should be decreased. Likewise if the coupling between the
amplifiers is negative, the system can be tuned again by increasing the load
capacitor value.
Parameter sweep simulations are performed by varying the phase and
the supply voltage of the Class-E amplifier in a coupled transmit system. Conditions
enable the coupled amplifiers to deliver RF power with high efficiency are
determined. Limits of the phase difference and the amplitude for this highly
efficient operating mode are investigated with simulations.Results
In
order to demonstrate tuning procedure in the coupled system, simulations are
performed in ADS 2016 with 2 Class-E amplifiers. Previously, each channel is
tuned to deliver 275.6 W RF power at 64 MHz frequency with a drain efficiency
of 91.5%. When two channels are coupled, tuning point shifts. This effect
distorts the resonance frequency and reduces the efficiency of the amplifier.
Then, tuning procedure is applied for positive coupling case. The series load
capacitor value (Cs) is
decreased to achieve similar output power with high drain efficiency. For each
coupling level, optimum load capacitor value and corresponding drain
efficiencies are listed in Figure 3.
After tuning procedure, each amplifier can achieve almost
the same performance in the transmit array like a single tuned amplifier. In
the previous study2, the modified Class-E amplifiers for 2-channel
transmit array system is proposed. To investigate the effect of coupling, MRI
experiments with 4-channel transmit coil are conducted in 1.5 T scanner with
the previous design of Class-E amplifier2. 63.795 MHz RF signal is given and 2ms sinc pulse
signal is generated by the modified Class-E amplifiers.The MRI experiments are performed with 4-channel transmit coil and
modified Class-E amplifiers. Figure 4.a shows how the transmit loops and
Class-E amplifiers placed on the 4-channel coil.
In order to determine
optimum regions for overall efficiency and to observe the effect of
load variation, parameter sweep is performed with coupled
Class-E amplifiers. Initially, two
amplifiers are tuned and adjusted to deliver 612 W output power with 96% drain
efficiency. Then, phase and supply voltage of channel 2 are swept from 0 to 360
degree and from 1 V to 31 V respectively. By the simulation, optimum operating
regions are detected; effects of phase
and amplitude of second channel on the overall performance is
investigated.Discussion
Results
showed that by applying proposed idea, highly efficient operating points can be
found for coupled Class-E amplifiers, negative effects of coupling on load
impedance can be minimized by tuning procedure and coupled amplifiers can
deliver desired RF power with high efficiency in a transmit array. Also simulation
results of coupled system are consistent with the proposed idea. Contour plots
show which regions are favorable for achieving high efficiency in the coupled
amplifier system. Conclusion
Class-E
power amplifier can be used as on coil amplifier for parallel transmit array in
MRI. In this work, the performance and operation of coupled Class-E power
amplifiers are investigated. Conditions
satisfying high drain efficiency for coupled amplifier system are determined,
tuning procedure is implemented in order to expand highly efficient operating
region of coupled Class-E amplifiers. It
is shown that coupled Class-E amplifiers can be tuned, they can operate with
high efficiency and high output power in a transmit array system despite phase
limits.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Sokal NO. Class-E switching-mode high-efficiency tuned
RF/microwave power amplifier: improved design equations, IEEE MTT-S International Microwave Symposium Digest, 2000.
2. Zahra
F. MS Thesis: Highly Efficient 300W Modified Class-E RF Amplifiers for 64MHz
Transmit Array System, Bilkent University, 2017.