Wouter Schellekens1, Alex Bhogal1, Jeroen Siero1, and Natalia Petridou1
1Radiology, UMC Utrecht, Utrecht, Netherlands
Synopsis
In the
current study, we investigate the contribution of non-neuronal and
neuronal-related hemodynamic changes to the BOLD signal for micro- and
macro-vascular compartments. Vascular reactivity was assessed using CO2
and O2 gas administration, as well as brief visual stimuli, while we
used gradient-echo and spin-echo across different cortical depths to
specifically target different vascular compartments. We found that gradient-echo
responded clearly to the gas challenges, also affecting the neurovascular
hemodynamic response function. These effects were not seen for spin-echo,
suggesting that the spatiotemporal characteristics of micro-vessels may not
solely be affected by vascular properties.
Introduction
The
Blood-Oxygen Level Dependent (BOLD) signal is widely used to investigate human
brain functioning in healthy and diseased humans. However, the BOLD signal consists
of a mix of hemodynamic changes, some of which relate to neuronal activity via
micro-vessels, and some of which relate to blood draining effects in
macro-vessels (intra-cortical
and pial draining veins). Thus, the neurophysiological nature of the
signals is unclear due to unknown variability in vascular organization and the
spatiotemporal characteristics of the hemodynamic response within the volume
imaged. In
the current study, we investigate the contribution of non-neuronal and
neuronal-related hemodynamic changes to the BOLD signal for micro- and macro-vascular
compartments. Non-neuronal hemodynamic changes were induced with CO2
and O2 gas administration, while we recorded BOLD signals using gradient-echo
(GE) and spin-echo (SE) EPI at 7T. SE-EPI samples BOLD signal effects
originating mainly from micro-vessels (e.g. capillary bed), while GE-EPI is
sensitive to both micro- and macro-vessels (intra-cortical and pial draining
veins). Additionally, neural activity was induced using a visual stimulus to
directly assess how differences in vessel reactivity modulate the hemodynamic
response function.Methods
Seven
healthy volunteers (female=6, mean age=20.4 years) participated in a 7 Tesla fMRI
session, while performing CO2 and O2 breathing challenges
(Respiracttm), and brief visual stimuli were presented on a screen
in the scanner bore. BOLD signals were recorded using a gradient-echo (GE,
resolution=1x1x1mm, TR/TE=850/27ms, FA=50°,
FOV=128x128x7mm), and spin-echo (SE, resolution=1.5x1.5x1.5 mm, TR/TE=850/50ms,
FA=90°, FOV=190x190x7.5mm) EPI
sequences, for the same gas and visual conditions. The gas conditions
consisted of a 3-minute increase in end-tidal pressure CO2 (+3, +5,
+8, and +10 mm/hg) and O2 (+500 mm/hg), plus a baseline of normal
air. The visual stimuli were brief (0.5s) flashes of black/white random
orientation patterns on a grey background, which were presented during all gas
conditions. On the basis of a T1-weighted anatomy scan, cortical layers (deep,
middle and top) were estimated using LayerfMRI (github.com/layerfMRI). The
percentage of BOLD signal change following the gas conditions was estimated per
voxel and averaged over layers. Hemodynamic Response Functions (HRF) following
the visual stimuli were estimated per gas condition using a Finite Impulse
Response (FIR) function and also averaged across cortical layers.Results
We
found robust BOLD signal change for the increases in end-tidal pCO2
and end-tidal pO2 gas conditions during the GE-EPI run (F(4,24)=14.546,
p<.001), but not for the SE-EPI run (F(4,24)=0.286, p=.884)
(figure 1). Additionally the GE-EPI scans showed the largest signal change in
the upper cortical layers (F(4,24)=18.615, p<.001), whereas the
SE-EPI scans did not reveal any differences in BOLD signal change across layers
(F(4,24)=0.253, p=.781). For the estimated GE-EPI HRFs, we observed small
differences in the response shape during different gas conditions (figure 2). The
HRF amplitude exhibited a small decrease with increasing end-tidal pCO2
conditions as anticipated (figure 2), however, this effect did not reach
significance. A significant amplitude increase was found from deep to upper
cortical layers (F(2,8)=10.224, p=.006). The estimated SE-EPI HRFs
did not show a change in BOLD signal amplitude across gas conditions (F(4,16)=0.678,
p=.617), or cortical layers (F(2,8)=2.449, p=.148). However, the
estimated amplitude of SE-EPI HRF during the end-tidal pO2 gas
condition was significantly different from baseline (F(1,6)=9.73,
p=.023), which was not seen for the GE-EPI pO2 gas increase
condition (F(1,6)=0.722, p=.428).Discussion
We
investigated effects of different gas challenges on the estimated BOLD signal
change for different vascular compartments during the acquisition of GE-EPI and
SE-EPI scans. We found that different levels of end-tidal pCO2 during
the SE-EPI scan did not have a significant effect on the percentage of BOLD
signal change and also did not differ across cortical layers. However, an
increase in end-tidal pCO2 administration was observed to cause
significant signal increases during the GE-EPI scan, resulting in largest
signal changes toward the upper cortical layers. These results suggest that the
smaller veins of the capillary bed may be less likely to dilate as a result of
increases in end-tidal pCO2 (measured with SE-EPI), as opposed to the
larger intra-cortical and pial vasculature (measured with GE-EPI). Finally, the
estimated HRFs following visual stimuli changed per different gas condition,
but only the HRFs caused by SE-EPI pO2 administration were
significantly different from baseline. These results indicate that BOLD signal
changes around the capillary bed are not solely dominated by vessel dilation
and that increases in oxyhemoglobin are sufficient to cause the observed signal
changes.Conclusion
Using
GE-EPI and SE-EPI sequences, different CO2 and O2 gas
administration levels, and a visually induced neuronal stimulus, we report
differences in the contribution of large vessels versus the capillary bed to
the fMRI BOLD signal. The spatiotemporal characteristics of micro-vessels may
not likely be affected by solely vascular properties.Acknowledgements
This work was supported by a grant from the National Institute of Health under Award Number RO1MH111417References
No reference found.