David Longbotham1, Daniel Wilson2, Ian Rowe3, Dhakshinamoorthy Vijayanand4, Magdy Attia4, Ashley Guthrie5, Mark Gilthorpe3, Rajendra Prasad4, and Steven Sourbron6
1University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom, 2Department of Medical Physics, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, Leeds, United Kingdom, 3Leeds Institute of Data Analytics, University of Leeds, Leeds, United Kingdom, 4Hepatobiliary and Transplantation Surgery, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, Leeds, United Kingdom, 5Department of Radiology, Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, Leeds, United Kingdom, 6Department of Infection, Immunity and Cardiovascular Disease, University of Sheffield, Sheffield, United Kingdom
Synopsis
The aim of this study was to identify Dynamic
Gadoxetate-Enhanced MRI (DGE-MRI) biomarkers that can improve predictions of
post-hepatectomy liver function. 29 patients requiring resection for colorectal
liver metastases were recruited, with post-operative bilirubin as outcome
measure. The results suggest that: (a) functional imaging substantially improves
outcome predictions over demographical and biochemical tests; (b) it is
critical to separately characterise the future liver remnant; (c) volumetry
does not offer any added predictive value. We conclude that DGE-MRI may improve patient
selection for hepatectomy, potentially reducing the risk of post-hepatectomy
liver failure while allowing more patients to be operated.
INTRODUCTION
Major liver resection is the only curative option for many
patients with primary or secondary liver cancer but is associated with a risk
of post-hepatectomy liver failure (PHLF)1. A reliable preoperative
estimate of post-operative liver function would help to reduce the risk of PHLF,
optimise surgery planning and potentially open up this treatment option in
cases where this is currently considered too risky. Hepatobiliary Scintigraphy
has demonstrated that there is a role for imaging-based measurement of partial
liver function2, but the technique is underused in clinical practice.
Dynamic Gadoxetate-enhanced MRI (DGE-MRI) is a more widely
available imaging method with potential to measure partial liver function3.
Gadoxetate is filtered by hepatocytes through OATP1, MRP2 and MRP3
transporters, a mechanism shared with bilirubin excretion. Liver function of individual
segments can be quantified by DGE-MRI and thus potentially provide a direct
prediction of post-operative liver function.
The aim of this study was to determine which, if any, pre-operative
DGE-MRI biomarkers of liver function have the potential to improve prediction
of post-operative outcomes over and above currently available measures.METHODS
Study assessments
This was a single-centre, prospective and non-randomised
observational study approved by the local research ethics committee. Patients
with colorectal liver metastases selected for curative major liver resection were
recruited consecutively. Pre-operative MRI was performed at 1.5T (Siemens Aera),
including DGE-MRI with an 8min free-breathing 3D spoiled gradient-echo (2.4s temporal
resolution, TR/TE=2.45ms/0.76ms, FA=25°, acquisition matrix=128x77, FOV=400x400mm,
reconstructed voxel size 3.125x10mm). 10mL Gadoxetate (Primovist, Bayer) was
delivered at 1 mL/sec. Hepatectomies were performed using an open surgical
technique, and biochemical and clinical progress was observed until discharge.
Data collection
Day 5 post-operative bilirubin was recorded as the primary
outcome due to its common use as a surrogate for liver function. Pre-operative data
included weight, age, diabetes status, BMI, chemotherapy use, renal
insufficiency and biochemistry: bilirubin, ALT, Alkaline Phosphatase, Albumin,
INR, Prothrombin time, Lactate. Evidence of liver steatosis was determined by
histology.
DGE-MRI processing produced 13 biomarkers for the whole liver and
the FLR (Figure 1) and was performed blinded using open-source software PMI 0.4 as
described previously3. Arterial- and venous input functions and a whole
liver volume-of-interest (VOI) were defined semi-automatically. Liver segments
were delineated using anatomical landmarks and an FLR VOI was created by joining
up all segments in the FLR. Concentrations were calculated by assuming linearity
with the signal and interpreted with a dual-inlet two-compartment uptake model.
Data analysis
The analysis aimed to identify which variables consistently
offer useful predictions in combination with others. Prediction modelling evaluated
all linear permutations of variables in a given subtype (clinical, whole liver DGE-MRI
and FLR-based DGE-MRI) with the Bayesian Information Criterion. Variables consistently retained in the better fitting models were considered good candidate predictors. RESULTS
29 patients were recruited and 1 was excluded due to incomplete
dynamic data collection. 15 patients had major liver resection; 8 patients
underwent a more limited resection. 6 patients were deemed inoperable after MRI
and excluded from analysis.
Outcome predictions with best models (Figure 2) show that whole
liver DGE-MRI variables alone offer poor prediction (Fig.2b), and that FLR-based
DGE-MRI variables (Fig.2c) offer substantially better predictions than clinical
variables (Fig.2a). Predictions do not improve when clinical variables are combined with FLR-based variables (Fig.2d),
but the combination achieves good prediction with only 7 variables whereas
FLR-variables alone require 11.
The 7 variables retained in the best model include one demographic
variable (age), one biochemical variable (International Normalised Ratio), and
5 FLR variables: extracellular volume fraction, extracellular mean transit time,
venous perfusion, filtered flow and normalised clearance. The relative weight
of the FLR variables in the best model (5/7) indicates that FLR variables are
most predictive. FLR volume is not retained in the best model indicating that
functional measures offer better prediction.DISCUSSION
The results offer strong indications that: (a) functional
imaging substantially improves predictions of post-operative liver function
over demographical and biochemical tests; (b) it is critical to measure
functional variables for the FLR separately; (c) volumetry does not offer any added predictive value.
The FLR variables retained in the best model reflect
different aspects of liver pathophysiology. Changes in the extracellular space may
reflect levels of fibrosis or liver injury, which are known risk factors for
hepatectomy1. Perfusion and hepatocellular function are two components
of liver function and therefore are expected to help predict post-operative
function. They are both represented in the normalised clearance, an absolute
measure of liver function that may offer a benchmark for what constitutes adequate
post-operative liver function.
Due to the small number of observations in this pilot study
the results must be treated as hypothesis generating. Stronger evidence is
needed in a dataset large enough to separately provide training and testing of the idealised prediction model.
The fact that 23 data points can be well fitted with a combination of only 7
variables offers confidence to justify investment in such larger
studies. CONCLUSION
DGE-MRI may substantially improve predictions of post-operative
liver function over demographical and biochemical data. When confirmed in
larger studies, DGE-MRI may help to reduce the risk of PHLF and potentially
open up this treatment option for larger numbers of patients.Acknowledgements
This work is funded by the Medical Research Council grant reference MR/P023398/1.References
1.
Kauffmann R, Fong Y. Post-hepatectomy liver failure.
Hepatobiliary Surg Nutr. 2014;3(5):238–46.
2.
Cieslak KP, Bennink RJ, de Graaf W, van Lienden
KP, Besselink MG, Busch ORC, et al. Measurement of liver function using
hepatobiliary scintigraphy improves risk assessment in patients undergoing
major liver resection. HPB. 2016;18(9):773–80.
3.
Sourbron S, Sommer WH, Reiser MF, Zech CJ.
Combined Quantification of Liver Perfusion and Function with Dynamic Gadoxetic
Acid-enhanced MR Imaging. Radiology. 2012;263(3):874–83.