Samantha J Ma1, Chenyang Zhao1, Kai Wang1, Xingfeng Shao1, Soroush Heidari Pahlavian1, Farshid Sepehrband1, Kay Jann1, Lirong Yan1, and Danny JJ Wang1
1University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA, United States
Synopsis
B1+ field
inhomogeneity is an ongoing issue that plagues whole-brain anatomical imaging
at ultra-high field, hindering its translation to the clinic. This work evaluates
and compares the latest commercially available options for RF shimming using
NOVA 1Tx/32Rx and parallel 8Tx/32Rx coil systems. Various configurations
including the use of dielectric pads for 1Tx, or volume-selective and
patient-specific RF shimming with pTx, were systematically compared with the
purpose of evaluating benefits for clinically relevant anatomical imaging.
Experimental results showed a consistent significant drop in the B1+ field map
in the temporal lobe, which was ameliorated using pTx.
Purpose
Ultra-high
field (UHF) MR imaging, where the main magnetic field (B0) strength is greater
than or equal to 7T, has been shown to provide benefits such as higher spatial
resolution, improvements in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) and contrast-to-noise ratio
(CNR), and improved temporal resolution for dynamic processes. However, whole-brain
neuroimaging at 7T also presents significant challenges with B1+ inhomogeneity
that may hinder clinical adoption of UHF imaging due to insufficient diagnostic
image quality. The introduction of parallel transmission (pTx) was previously
proposed to alleviate RF inhomogeneities1, 2. In this work, five commercially available solutions provided
by Siemens and NOVA Medical systems are systematically compared for benefits in
anatomical imaging including: (1) combined mode single transmission 1Tx+32Rx
NOVA coil system [Nova Medical, Inc., Wilmington, MA] with and (2) without the
use of dielectric pads3, and pTx mode 8Tx+32Rx NOVA coil system (Nova
Medical, Inc.) operating in (3) quadrature (circular polarization-like/TrueForm),
(4) patient-specific, and (5) volume-selective RF shimming configurations,
where the selected volume is focused on the commonly problematic temporal lobe
region. Methods
All
experimental data were acquired using a 7T Terra whole-body MR system equipped
with 8-channel pTx array capability [Siemens Healthcare, Erlangen, Germany].
Five healthy volunteers (1 female, 27±2.3 years) were either fitted with 3D-printed
helmets or securely padded into the head coil for motion prevention (Caseforge,
Berkeley, CA) and scanned using both pTx and 1Tx combined modes in a single 2-hour
session. Switching between the FDA-approved 1Tx combined mode and research-only
pTx mode typically required an average time of about 10 minutes. First-level
controlled SAR mode was employed for 3D structural imaging sequences to ensure FDA
guidelines (3.2W/kg on head) were met. RF field mapping was performed using a
Turbo Flash sequence with the following parameters: FOV=256x256mm, TR/TE=4000/1.73ms,
FA=5°, BW=440Hz/Px, resolution=4.0mm3. Sagittal T1-weighted MPRAGE
images were acquired with the following parameters: resolution=0.7mm3
isotropic, GRAPPA=2, TR/TE/TI=2200/2.95/1050ms, scan time ~6.5min. Sagittal
T2-weighted SPACE images were acquired with the following parameters:
resolution= 0.6mm3 isotropic, GRAPPA=3, TR/TE=2140/221ms, scan time
~11min. All configurations were matched to the highest SAR-limit allowed input
voltage and had the same sequence parameters. Current commercially available
coil array configurations were evaluated based on B1+ homogeneity, signal
intensity and coverage, repeatability across different subjects, as well as
ease of operation for clinical applicability and performance in future neurology
patient studies focusing on diagnostic image quality (SNR, CNR).Results and Discussion
Figure 1
shows qualitative comparisons of measured in vivo B1+ field distributions for
three views between the pTx system using TrueForm, Patient-specific, and medial-temporal
lobe focused Volume-selective (dashed red box) B1 shim modes, as well as 1Tx
combined mode with and without the use of dielectric pads. A significant drop
of the B1+ field intensity was observed in the temporal lobe and cerebellum for
the combined mode 1Tx NOVA coil system. While the addition of dielectric pads slightly
improves B1+ field inhomogeneity, the temporal lobes still suffer from signal
dropout. In contrast, this medial temporal region exhibits improved homogeneity
in all configurations with the pTx NOVA coil system, an observation which was
expected due to the expanded coil coverage. Figure 2 shows a quantitative experimental
analysis for Head 3. The mean coefficient of variation (CV=std/mean) of
measured B1+ field was 0.21 when using either patient-specific or
volume-selective B1 shim mode with the pTx coil system, indicating improved RF
homogeneity when compared to the other configurations (0.25 for pTx TrueForm, 0.38
for 1Tx with dielectric pads, and 0.42 for 1Tx without pads). When using the
same input voltage, the mean B1+ intensity over the whole head decreases by
~20% for all subjects with patient-specific RF-shimming, compared to the clinically
used 1Tx with dielectric pads (Figure 2).
Concerning
application of in vivo anatomical imaging, the pTx coil system
demonstrates significant benefits for clinical use. Figure 3 displays the
T1-weighted MPRAGE images of Head 1 for both 1Tx and pTx coil system
configurations. Patient-specific pTx B1 shimming enabled higher SNR and
improved CNR between gray (GM) and white matter (WM) in the medial-temporal
region. Figures 4 and 5 display the T2-weighted SPACE images for Heads 2 and 3,
respectively. As shown in the magnified insets focusing on the hippocampus and
parahippocampal gyrus/temporal lobe in Figure 4, the signal dropout due to B1
field inhomogeneity is alleviated in pTx mode, with especially improved
qualitative delineation of hippocampal structures when utilizing
patient-specific or volume-selective shimming configurations. Furthermore, in one
subject, pTx shimming enabled the detection of extracerebral structures like
the cochlea (Figure 5). Interestingly, T2-weighted SPACE images exhibited
unexpected contrast near the brainstem due to an accentuated CSF pulsation
artifact in the basal cisterns. This artifact was mitigated with the
application of flow compensation in addition to pTx RF shimming, revealing fine
structures such as the abducens nerve with the restored high contrast between
tissue and cerebrospinal fluid (CSF). Conclusion
The
comparison of commercially available coil configurations showed that the patient-specific
shimming, achieved through parallel transmission, can substantially improve RF
homogeneity in anatomical neuroimaging. While further developments are needed to
limit SAR deposition for 3D T1 or T2 imaging, using pTx can address homogeneity
issues and directly benefit diagnostic imaging of important structures related
to dementia and other neurodegenerative diseases. Acknowledgements
This
work was supported by National Institutes of
Health grants UH2-NS100614, S10-OD025312, K25-AG056594 and P41-EB015922. This work was
also supported by American Heart Association grant 16SDG29630013.References
1. Ibrahim TS, Lee R, Baertlein BA, Kangarlu A, Robitaille
P-ML. Application of finite difference time domain method for the design of
birdcage rf head coils using multi-port excitations. Magnetic Resonance Imaging. 2000;18:733-742
2. Hoult DI. Sensitivity and power
deposition in a high-field imaging experiment. Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging. 2000;12:46-67
3. Yang QX, Mao W, Wang J, Smith MB,
Lei H, Zhang X, et al. Manipulation of image intensity distribution at 7.0 t:
Passive rf shimming and focusing with dielectric materials. Journal of Magnetic Resonance Imaging.
2006;24:197-202