Yongxian Qian1, Bei Zhang1, Shannon Haas1, and Aaron R. Chidakel2
1Radiology, New York University, New York, NY, United States, 2Endocrinology, New York University, New York, NY, United States
Synopsis
This study presents preliminary results supporting a new concept to
build a wearable magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) system for noninvasive blood
glucose measurement in humans. Computer simulations, hardware buildings and
subject studies demonstrated the promising of such a system.
INTRODUCTION
High blood glucose level is a characteristic of
diabetes: 100-126 mg/dL for pre-diabetes and >126 mg/dL for diabetes1.
Diabetes is a metabolic disease that causes acute and serious chronic
complications1. It becomes a huge healthcare burden worldwide. In
the United States there were 23.1 million people with diabetes in 2015 and $105
billion in annual direct cost 2. Globally, there were 422 million
diabetics and $827 billion annual direct cost 3-6. There is no
known cure for the disease1. Current management is to keep blood
glucose level within acceptable range as close to normal (~100 mg/dL).
This is usually achieved with healthy diet, exercise, weight loss, and
medication. Monitoring glucose level therefore becomes a critical part of the
management. Currently, daily
monitoring is performed at home using a meter that requires finger-pricking for
a drop of blood sample7. The procedure is invasive and can be
painful, making patients less likely adhere to it. Minimally-invasive and less
painful solutions have been developed in recent years, such as continuous
glucose monitoring (CGM) meters8,9 which insert a small biosensor
under the skin and measure glucose level in cellular fluid, not in blood, and thus need extra
calibration by finger-pricking meter10. Noninvasive and painless
solutions are under extensive development, including optical sensor11,12,
smart contact lens13, radio-wave sensor14, and ultrasonic
sensor15. These hopefuls however share a major technical drawback of
non-specific to blood glucose and
unlikely being accurate as finger-pricking meters16. Here we present
a new sensor based on magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) which is specific
to blood glucose (via chemical shift) and has the potential to be as accurate
as finger-pricking meter17.METHODS
We designed and built a wearable MRS system at
0.1 T (Fig. 1). The B0 field was calculated using the Bio-Savart law
in MATLAB (R2018a). The B1+/- field was full-wave
simulated using a software (CST microwave studio, Darmstadt, Germany). A signal
generator (BK Precision 4065, Yorba
Linda, CA) provided RF pulse for the transceive (Tx/Rx) flexible solenoid coil. An oscilloscope (Tektronix TDS3054C, Beaverton, OR) displayed
and recorded FID signals which were then demodulated into complex ones and Fourier
transformed into MR spectra. Signals from static tissues surrounding blood vessels
were saturated by a 1min-long preparation of RF excitation. The asymmetry of
water peak caused by small glucose signal was used as glucose index (Eq. 1),
which was then transformed into glucose concentration via a linear calibration (Eq. 2). Finger-pricking meter reading was employed as standard reference.
Eq. 1: Rgluc = ΔARL / Awater .
Eq. 2: Ygluc = a + b Rgluc .EXPERIMENTS
The MRS measurement was performed on the tip of
a finger (left index) of 30 human subjects (15 Type-2 diabetics and 15 healthy
controls; age 45.4±17.0 years in 23-71 years;
10/20 female/male), with an approved IRB and written consents. A custom-developed
rectangular RF pulse sequence was used for data acquisition with RF duration=2.5ms
and central frequency=3.95MHz, FID readout time =2.5ms, TE/TR=1.25/5ms, averages=17-20.
Figure-pricking measurement was performed on subject's finger tips before and
after MRS measurement, using a popular meter (OneTouch UltraMini, LifeScan, Switzerland). The two meter readings
were averaged. MRS data processing was performed offline in MATLAB (R2019a).RESULTS
Fig. 2 presents the B0 field of the disk
magnet (Fig. 2a) with a 3D simulation in Fig. 2b and a 1D measurement in Fig.
2c. Demonstrated in Fig. 3 are the full wave simulation results of the B1+/-
field of a wrist model (εr=80 and σ=0.5 S/m). The signals acquired on a
healthy subject were shown in Fig. 4. Fig. 5 shows the measurements of blood
glucose on the study subjects. An expected linear relationship between MRS
measurement and meter reading was obtained. Statistically, there was no significant
difference observed between the male and female subjects, between the healthy
and Type-2 diabetics, and between the age groups. However, we also found outliers
(1/15 in the healthy subjects and 5/15 in the Type-2 diabetics).DISCUSSION
The B0 field map in Fig. 2 suggests
the penetration into the skin at ~6 mm (or 0.8-0.9 T) which is deep enough to
reach blood vessels inside tissues. The arrangement of the magnet and coil
makes RF field perpendicular to B0 (Fig.3), ensuring production of
MR signal. The study results in Fig. 5 show the capability of the wearable MRS
system for noninvasive measurement of blood glucose at an accuracy comparable
to finger-pricking meter (<15%) and meeting FDA recommendations18,19. We found that the outliers in Fig. 5 were caused by imperfect setup of the measurement
such as loose contact between subject’s finger and the coil. This MRS system employed
external RF generator and recording subsystems. Other subsystems related to the
power supply, signal processing and glucose reading, and safety of users, were
not explored in this study.CONCLUSION
This study has
shown preliminary data supporting the technical feasibility of proposed wearable
MRS system for noninvasive measurement of blood glucose. However, more efforts
are needed to minimize the system and build a prototype. Studies on more
subjects, especially those with higher (>300 mg/dL) or lower (<100 mg/dL)
blood glucose level, are also needed to determine the system’s accuracy and
limitations.Acknowledgements
This work was financially
supported in part by the Applied Research Support Fund (ARSF) of NYU School of
Medicine and the General Research Fund of the Department of Radiology. The authors
(Y.Q. and B. Z.) are the inventors of a patent application related to this
research.References
1. American
Diabetes Association. Standards of medical care in diabetes – 2017. Diabetes
Care 2017; 40 (sup 1): s1-s135.
2. CDC. National Diabetes Statistics Report, 2017.
Atlanta, GA: Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, US Department of
Health and Human Services; 2017.
3. WHO. Global
Report on Diabetes. Geneva, 2016.
4. NCD-Ris
C. Worldwide trends in diabetes. Lancet 2016; 387:1513-30.
5. IDF
Diabetes Atlas, 7th ed Brussels, Belgium: International Diabetes
Federation, 2015 http://www.diabetesatlas.org.
6. Zheng,
Y. et al. Global etiology and epidemiology of
type 2 diabetes mellitus and its complications Nat. Rev. Endocrinol. 2017.151. doi:10.1038/nrendo.
7. Bestreviews.com. July 2017.
8. https://www.dexcom.com/products. 2018.
9. https://www.freestylelibre.us. 2018.
10. FDA News Release. FDA expands indication for
continuous glucose monitoring system, first to replace fingerstick testing for
diabetes treatment decisions. Dec 20, 2016.
11. Taylor NP. Apply is testing a noninvasive blood
glucose monitor. CNBC; 2017-4-14.
12. Shao J, Lin M, Li Y, Li X, Liu J, et al. In Vivo
blood glucose quantification using Raman spectroscopy. PLOS ONE 2012; 7(10):
e48127.
13. Otis B, Liao YT, Amirparviz, Yao H. Wireless powered
contact lens with glucose sensor system. US Patent Publication No. US20120245444A1.
Feb 21, 2012.
14. http://www.gluco-wise.com. 2019.
15. http://www.integrity-app.com/the-glucotrack/. 2019.
16. Smith, John. The pursuit of noninvasive glucose
(5th ed): Hunting the deceitful turkey. 2017 https://www.researchgate.net/publication/317267760_The_Pursuit_of_Noninvasive_Glucose_5th_Edition.
17. Qian Y, Zhang B. System and method for blood glucose
monitoring using magnetic resonance spectroscopy. U.S. Patent Application No.:
62/618,974. January 2019 Submitted by NYU.
18. FDA.
Self-monitoring blood glucose test systems for over-the-counter use: Guidance
for industry and Food and Drug Administration staff. Issued on October 11,
2016.
19. ISO 15197:2013. In vitro diagnostic test systems –
Requirements for blood-glucose monitoring systems for self-testing in managing
diabetes mellitus. 2013-05-15.