Ping Liu1, Gui-hua Jiang1, and Jing Zhang2
1Radiology, Guangdong Second Provincial General Hospital, Guangzhou, China, 2Radiology, The Affiliated Tongji Hospital, Tongji Medical College, Huazhong University of Science & Technology, Wuhan, China
Synopsis
Dysthyroid optic
neuropathy (DON) is the most serious complication of Thyroid-Associated
Ophthalmopathy(TAO). Untimely and ineffective treatment of could lead to
permanent blindness. Early detection is the principle factor for timely
intervention. Diffusion tensor imaging(DTI) is a noninvasive tool to reveal
microstructural or non-overt damage and quantify pathological processes of nerve
fiber bundle. We applied the multi-parametric of optic nerve to identify the
DON from TAO. The result reveals that DTI can be considered a useful and noninvasive tool
to differentiate DON from TAO with higher accuracy.
Introduction:
Dysthyroid optic
neuropathy (DON), the most severe and vexing complication of TAO, can lead to
irreversible blindness if treated untimely and ineffectively. In clinical
practice, overwhelming majority of TAO patients may be unaware of the danger
until the onset of pronounced visual loss. Thus, early diagnosis is critical
for timely intervention of DON.
Many examinations
have been used auxiliary to diagnose DON. The ophthalmologic psychophysical tests are subjective and require the
full cooperation of an alert and motivated patient. The electro-physiological
tests, such as visual evoked potentials (VEP), are readily influenced by poor
patient compliance and factors unrelated to the disease such as the opaque
media, incorrect refraction[1] and often render
false positive results. Peripapillary optical coherence tomography(OCT) can
reflect the structural changes of optic nerve, but it is limited to the retinal. In
short, existing methods cannot effectively detect the DON. In short, the ophthalmic
signs or symptoms-based evaluations are neither invariably present nor specific
for diagnosis. Therefore, identification of typical presenting features is vital
for prevention the risk of permanent visual compromise.
Muscle indices measured
on conventional MRI or CT are frequently used to detect DON[2], however, this method was
established on the undetermined pathology mechanism-the compression from
enlarged EOMs. Furthermore, it is an indirect sign and limited to the intra-orbital
part of optic nerve, fail to directly demonstrate the impairment of optic nerve
and cannot accurately assess the underlying pathophysiology preceding the
irreversible structural damage. Diffusion-tensor
imaging (DTI) can sensitively detect the microstructural alterations in
nerves[3] by quantifying microscopic motion
of the water molecules within nerve fibers. It has been widely employed on
human’s visual pathway related disease, including glaucoma, multiple sclerosis,optic neuritis to evaluate the nerve
fibers. So far, DTI was just applied to assess the optic nerve in TAO patients
without DON[4].
Therefore, we aimed
to assess the axonal architecture of the optic nerve on DTI and use it to identify
TAO patients with and without neuropathy.
Thereby,
providing data-based evidence for early detect DON.Methods:
This single-center
retrospective study was approved by local institutional review board, and the
requirement for informed consent was obtained. 56 TAO patients and 23 DON
patients were included in the study. Clinical features of 79 patients and DTI
parameters of the optic nerve of 158 orbits were analyzed. The area under receiver(AUC) operating characteristic
curve was employed to evaluate the diagnostic performance of DTI parameters.
The
correlations between these DTI parameters and the clinical features were
determined.Results:
Compared to patients
without TAO, DON patients showed higher levels of serologic TGAb, higher CAS,
decreased visual accuracy and delayed latency time. As shown in Fig.1, the DON
group displayed significantly higher λ⸗, λ﬩, MD and lower FA values than that of TAO(p<0.05, respectively). For identify
DON from TAO, the MD and FA have the higher AUC(AUC=0.727,0.709,respectively), combination
of the DTI parameters have added diagnostic performance, especially the
combination of the four parameters generated the highest AUC (0.821) and
corresponding sensitivity and specificity were 80.43% and 66.96%, respectively (Table
1 and Fig 2). There was significant correlation of the CAS,
VA with all DTI parameters. The VEP amplitude also correlated with the FA of
optic nerve (Fig 3). Discussion
DON begins in an insidious way and
requires prompt diagnosis and treatment to prevent blindness. Existing diagnostic
means are complex and cannot effectively and sensitively detect its occurrence
until the onset of obvious and irreversible visual function.
The optic nerve damage in DON have
been confirmed by a cadaveric
study[5]. We applied the DTI to observe the microstructural
changes of optic nerve and attempted to use multiple parameters for the
detection of DON. This study found that all diffusion
parameters of the optic nerve changed markedly in DON patients. MD reflects the magnitude of the diffusion tensor and
associates with demyelination or glia cell impairment.FA measures the orientation coherence of diffusion and
fiber integrity and mirrors fiber attenuation, axonal diameter, and
myelination in white matter. We conjecture
that complex and diverse pathogenic mechanism including optic nerve ischemia or axonal flow inhibition from the
compression of swelling extraocular muscles(EOMs), optic nerve stretching from increased soft-tissue volume,
and inflammation (optic neuritis) may jointly induced the alterations of optic nerve.
With regard to the relationships
between the clinical measures and DTI metrics,.The CAS represents the activity of
TAO, higher scores means the disease is in inflammatory stage, increased λ⸗, λ﬩, and
MD reflected the enhanced water diffusion, this suggested the inflammation-mediated
optic neuritis may play a role in the neuropathy, that maybe the reason why large
dose methylprednisolone is recommended as the first-line therapy for DON.
Conclusion
The correlation
between DTI parameters of optic nerve and ophthalmic test suggests that these
parameters may play a role as disease indicators. The diagnostic performance of
DTI for identification DON from TAO mean the DTI may act as an imaging marker
for the prediction of the DON during TAO. This study facilitates the management of DON.Acknowledgements
Thanks for the subjects inclued in this research.References
1.M.D. Tsaloumas, P.A. Good, M.A. Burdon, G.P.
Misson, Flash and pattern visual evoked potentials in the diagnosis and
monitoring of dysthyroid optic neuropathy, Eye (London, England) 8 ( Pt 6)
(1994) 638-45.
2.L. Barrett, H.J. Glatt, R.M. Burde,
M.H. Gado, Optic nerve dysfunction in thyroid eye disease: CT, Radiology 167(2)
(1988) 503-7.
3.P.J. Basser, C. Pierpaoli, Microstructural
and physiological features of tissues elucidated by
quantitative-diffusion-tensor MRI, Journal of magnetic resonance. Series B
111(3) (1996) 209-19.
4.H. Lee, Y.H. Lee,
S.I. Suh, E.K. Jeong, S. Baek, H.S. Seo, Characterizing Intraorbital Optic
Nerve Changes on Diffusion Tensor Imaging in Thyroid Eye Disease Before
Dysthyroid Optic Neuropathy
5.T.J. Hufnagel,
W.F. Hickey, W.H. Cobbs, F.A. Jakobiec, T. Iwamoto, R.C. Eagle,
Immunohistochemical and Ultrastructural Studies on the Exenterated Orbital
Tissues of a Patient with Graves' Disease, Ophthalmology 91(11)