Mélissa Vincent1,2, Mylène Gaudin1,2, Covadonga Lucas-Torres3, Océane Guillemaud1,2, Carole Escartin1,2, Alan Wong3, and Julien Valette1,2
1Molecular Imaging Research Centre (MIRCen), Commissariat à l'Energie Atomique et aux Energies Alternatives (CEA), Fontenay-aux-Roses, France, 2UMR 9199, Neurodegenerative Diseases Laboratory, Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique (CNRS), Université Paris-Sud, Université Paris-Saclay, Fontenay-aux-Roses, France, 3NIMBE/ Laboratoire de Structure et Dynamique par Résonance Magnétique (LSDRM), Commissariat à l'Energie Atomique et aux Energies Alternatives (CEA), Gif-sur-Yvette, France
Synopsis
Diffusion in the
extracellular space is assessed by state-of-the-art diffusion-weighted MRS
techniques following intracerebral injection of sucrose, which predominantly remains
in the extracellular space. Sucrose diffusion appears to be not strictly
Gaussian and different from intracellular metabolites diffusion. Signal
attenuation is stronger and deviates from mono-exponential attenuation at very
high b-values, suggesting the presence of some highly restricted pool. The ADC
is higher and decreases when augmenting td, indicating that the
tortuosity regime is not reached yet. Lastly, unlike intracellular metabolites,
sucrose diffusion does not exhibit microstructural anisotropy in
double-diffusion-encoding experiments.
Introduction
Unveiling tissue microstructure by
diffusion-weighted MRI is fundamentally limited by the ubiquitous nature of
water. How do diffusion properties in the extracellular space (ECS) differ from
those in the intracellular space? Is extracellular diffusion faster or slower?
Can it be considered Gaussian or not?
Unlike water, most endogenous brain metabolites
are intracellular, yielding specific information about intracellular diffusion when
using diffusion-weighted magnetic resonance spectroscopy (DW-MRS)1.
Unfortunately, no endogenous metabolite is specific of ECS. However, pioneer
works proposed to inject molecules in the ECS and to measure their apparent
diffusion coefficient (ADC) by DW-MRS2,3. These works concluded that
extracellular and intracellular ADC were similar (for molecules of similar
size).
Here we revisit extracellular diffusion using modern
in vivo DW-MRS techniques. Sucrose
(for which no known transporter exists in the mammal brain) is injected in the
mouse brain and its diffusion properties are characterized across different diffusion
modalities: high b-value attenuation,
ADC up to ultra-long td, and
double-diffusion encoding (DDE). DW-MRS reveals that sucrose diffusion drastically
differs from intracellular metabolites diffusion.Methods
C57BL/6J mice were
anesthetized and immobilized in a stereotaxic frame. Two cannulas loaded with
1M sucrose solution were inserted in the ventricles (Figure 1-A). One hour after injection, mice
were scanned on an 11.7 T Bruker Scanner (Gmax=752 mT/m) using a cryoprobe. DW-MRS
was performed in a 63-µL voxel carefully positioned in the hippocampus to
exclude injection sites and minimize ventricle contribution. A STE-LASER sequence4
was used to measure signal up to b=20
ms/µm² at fixed td=53 ms
(N=4 mice) and to measure ADC up to td=1 s (at b=3 ms/µm²) (N=4
mice). DDE was acquired using a DDE-LASER sequence5 (Δ/δ/TM=30/4.5/5.5 ms, b=2.5 ms/µm² per diffusion
block) (N=4 mice). Sucrose and metabolite signals were quantified using
LCModel, with experimental macromolecule signal included in the basis-set.Results
Efficient sucrose
injection, fast sucrose diffusion, and limited contamination by ventricles. Figure 1-B shows
the hippocampal voxel and corresponding spectra at b=0.02 and 20 ms/µm². Intense
sucrose resonances are observed at 3.60-3.75-5.35 ppm. Strikingly, sucrose signal almost
vanishes at b=20 ms/µm² while endogenous metabolites are still measurable,
demonstrating faster diffusion of sucrose. To rule out contamination from
ventricles, we acquired signal in a small 8-µL voxel far from injection sites
and ventricles (Figure 1-C). Despite
lower SNR, similar sucrose signal and signal drop relative to intracellular metabolites
were observed, suggesting that sucrose has spread far from injection sites, and
that contamination from ventricles does not bias results in the large voxel.
Diffusion
properties of sucrose. Figure 2 displays results
for all DW-MRS experiments. At high b-values, signal attenuation is much
stronger for sucrose than for intracellular metabolites. Interestingly, while
sucrose signal attenuates close to mono-exponentiality at low-b, it seems to
strongly deviate from mono-exponentiality at high-b, suggesting some restricted
sucrose (in ECS deadspace microdomains?). Lactate, which is both intracellular
and extracellular, displays some intermediate behavior. ADC values up to
long td are remarkably higher for sucrose (>0.2 µm²/ms) than
for intracellular metabolites (~0.1 µm²/ms). Sucrose ADC seems to decrease as td
is increased, suggesting it has not reached tortuosity regime yet. Again,
lactate exhibits an intermediate behavior. Finally, unlike metabolites, sucrose
DDE signal does not exhibit any angular modulation, i.e. it does not exhibit microscopic anisotropy.Discussion
Is sucrose specific
to ECS? To confirm ECS-specificity of sucrose, one mouse was sacrificed one hour
following sucrose injection, and its brain dissected around the hippocampus. ECS
fluid from this extract was separated from the cytosol and cell membranes
thanks to a cell dissociation protocol (Figure
3). HR-MAS revealed much larger sucrose signal in the ECS, confirming that
sucrose essentially remains there.
Alternative injection
site. To further rule out any potential contribution of ventricles, in some
additional experiments (still on-going) we directly injected sucrose in a
pre-frontal cortical area with no ventricle. Preliminary results indicate
similar outcomes for high b-values and DDE measurements (Figure 4).
Extracellular
versus intracellular ADC. While sucrose is a slightly larger molecule than intracellular metabolites, its ADC is higher. This contrasts with early works reporting similar intracellular and extracellular ADC. However we are quite confident in our results, considering the high quality of our data and the experiments we have performed to confirm that sucrose signal essentially arises from ECS fluid. Furthermore, the fact that intracellular metabolites exhibit “normal” diffusion properties (as compared to published results4-6) suggests that no major cellular alteration (e.g. due to osmotic perturbation) is induced by sucrose injection. Also, DTI maps (not shown) look normal, providing additional arguments in favor of preserved tissue microstructure. Conclusion
Besides
ADC measurement at fixed td, our study explores new territories, revealing
intriguing properties for diffusion in ECS: while signal attenuation up to high
b and ADC up to long td does not strictly correspond to Gaussian
diffusion (in a manner that remains to be fully characterized), it appears that
DDE signal modulation is flat, suggesting total loss of correlation between
diffusion directions even at short TM=5.5
ms. Despite intrinsic sensitivity limitations, measuring the diffusion
properties of extracellular probes using DW-MRS appears to be very fruitful and invites further research. Acknowledgements
This project has received funding from the
European Research Council (ERC) under the European Union’s FP7 and Horizon 2020
research and innovation programmes (grant agreements No 336331 and 818266). The 11.7 T MRI scanner was funded by a grant
from “Investissements d'Avenir - ANR-11-INBS-0011 - NeurATRIS: A Translational
Research Infrastructure for Biotherapies in Neurosciences".References
1 Palombo, M., Shemesh,
N., Ronen, I. & Valette, J. Insights into brain microstructure from in vivo
DW-MRS. NeuroImage 182, 97-116,
doi:10.1016/j.neuroimage.2017.11.028 (2018).
2 Duong, T. Q. et al. Extracellular apparent diffusion
in rat brain. Magnetic resonance in
medicine 45, 801-810,
doi:10.1002/mrm.1108 (2001).
3 Duong, T. Q.,
Ackerman, J. J., Ying, H. S. & Neil, J. J. Evaluation of extra- and
intracellular apparent diffusion in normal and globally ischemic rat brain via
19F NMR. Magnetic resonance in medicine
40, 1-13, doi:10.1002/mrm.1910400102
(1998).
4 Ligneul, C., Palombo,
M. & Valette, J. Metabolite diffusion up to very high b in the mouse brain
in vivo: Revisiting the potential correlation between relaxation and diffusion
properties. Magnetic resonance in
medicine 77, 1390-1398,
doi:10.1002/mrm.26217 (2017).
5 Vincent, M., Palombo,
M. & Valette, J. Revisiting double diffusion encoding MRS in the mouse
brain at 11.7 T: which microstructural features are we sensitive to? . arXiv: 1908.00317 (2019).
6 Palombo,
M. et al. New paradigm to assess
brain cell morphology by diffusion-weighted MR spectroscopy in vivo. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A 113, 6671-6676,
doi:10.1073/pnas.1504327113 (2016).