Anders Simonsen1, Juan D. Sánchez-Heredia2, Sampo Saarinen1, Jan H. Ardenkjær-Larsen2, Albert Schliesser1, and Eugene S. Polzik1
1Niels Bohr Institute, University of Copenhagen, Copenhagen, Denmark, 2Department of Health Technology, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark
Synopsis
A new approach to MRI detection is reported, where an optomechanical
transducer directly converts and amplifies the MR signal to amplitude
modulation of laser light. The transducer, which is simultaneously a capacitor
and an optical cavity, is connected directly in parallel to the receive coil.
The mechanical Q-factor of the transducer is 1500, providing a 3 dB bandwidth
of 1 kHz. We show here for the first time that this technology can be used to
directly acquire a 13C MRI at 3T (32.13 MHz), and reconstruct it
using the standard pipeline of a commercial MR scanner.
Introduction
MRI hardware has evolved greatly over the last years. The introduction
of receive-only coil arrays can arguably be considered one of the advances that
most improved image quality1. However, the MR signal detection
at its fundamental level has not changed importantly over that time: a
time-varying magnetic field induces a voltage on a coil closely coupled to the
sample, and that voltage is amplified and digitized.
The improvement and miniaturization of the electronic components have
led to coil arrays with very high number of channels. Further improvements in
this direction run into problems caused by the high number of electrical
signals and cables that need to be handled in the close vicinity of the
patient. Many of these problems can be minimized (if not completely removed) by
the use of optical technology on both the detection and signal communication
processes. Optical fibers are non-metallic, insensitive to high-magnetic fields,
immune to electrical interference and safer for the patient than standard
electrical cables.
Converting the MR signal into the optical domain after detection has previously
been reported2. In this work, we go a step
further and propose to directly detect and up-convert the MR signal into an
optical carrier. This allows displacing the preamplification electronics away
from the coils and the patient. The approach used here is based on an
optomechanical transducer, with a natural mechanical resonance at 1.4 MHz3,4.Materials and Methods
Detection Principle
The transducer consists of a freely suspended membrane
that acts simultaneously as one side of a capacitor and one mirror in an
optical cavity5. An MR signal induces a
voltage across the coil terminals that force a buildup charge on the capacitor.
This process produces a force on the membrane and makes it move, which in turn
changes the capacitance and consequently the charges that produce the motion.
This creates a parametric coupling between the mechanical and electrical
resonances. The sensitivity of the electro-mechanical transduction is optimal
when the membrane is driven at its natural resonance frequency. For the case
proposed here, this means that a biasing RF signal, whose frequency is the
difference between the Larmor precession and the membrane resonance (32.13 -
1.4 MHz = 30.73 Mhz) has to be applied.
Transducer Properties
The connection between the transducer and the electrical
circuit was made via wire-bonding the membrane to an 8-pin integrated circuit
socket (Figure 1). Because the transducer needs vacuum to operate (to enhance
the mechanical quality factor), the assembly was placed inside an MR compatible
vacuum chamber made of glass-fiber that could hold a pressure below 1 × 10−3
mbar. The transducer chip and the rest of the
circuit were then connected with a short RF cable via a vacuum feedthrough. For this kind of transducer, the
mechanical contribution to the intrinsic noise temperature has been shown to be 113 K, while the optical noise is 90 K, and both add to a total
intrinsic transducer noise of 210 K. This is equivalent to a noise-figure of
2.33 dB5.
MR Experiments
MR experiments were performed
on a 3T scanner (GE Healthcare, USA), using a spherical (38 mm diameter) 13C-enriched
bicarbonate phantom. A CSI sequence (16x16 acquired points, TR=75ms, FOV= 80 mm
x 80 mm x 100 mm) was used. The coil used for detection was a custom made,
spiral surface coil (50 mm outer diameter), tuned using two segmenting
capacitors. One of the segmenting capacitors was used to implement active
decoupling, in a regular fashion. The transducer was also connected to a
bandpass filter, which allowed to bias it with the RF constant wave at 30.73
MHz. The circuit schematic is shown in Figure 2.
The detection architecture is
shown in Figure 3. The output of the optical detector is down-converted to the
frequency of the mechanical resonance (1.4 MHz) and could be used to
reconstruct the MR image. However, and just for convenience, we mixed that
signal back to the Larmor frequency and fed it to the scanner receiver,
allowing the image to be reconstructed by the dedicated scanner postprocessing
software.Results and Discussion
Figure 4 shows the MRI measured using the described
optical detection. Figure 5 shows the averaged spectrum over the whole FOV
using the optical setup (left), and compared to a similar measurement using
standard detection. The single frequency peak of the bicarbonate signal can be
seen clearly in both acquisitions, but their noise floor is very different. The
noise floor of the optically detected signal is compatible with the mechanical
membrane spectral response, following a Lorentzian distribution.Conclusion
We propose a setup for direct optical detection in
MRI, and successfully implement it in a commercial MR scanner. The optically
detected spectrum shows an SNR comparable to the standard detection, but still
lower. However, the overall performance of the optical detection can be further
enhanced with straightforward improvements (e.g. lowering the capacitance in
parallel to the transducer, optimization of the optical cavity, higher bias…).
The RF bias signal can be potentially applied wirelessly, therefore providing a
setup with no electrical connections. Such a design would allow for a new
generation of highly dense arrays, where no electrical cables are needed in the
near environment of the patient.Acknowledgements
This work was supported by funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant agreement 732894 (HOT) and 722923 (OMT); European Research Council (Q-CEOM 638765, QUANTUM-N 787520,EMOT 768491); Innovation Fund Denmark (Qubiz 5150-00004B); Danish Council for Independent Research (4002-00060,4005-00531); and Danish National Research Foundation (DNRF124 HYPERMAG, DNRF139 Hy-Q).References
1. Roemer PB, Edelstein WA, Hayes CE. The
NMR Phased Array. MRM. 1990;225:192-225.
2. Memis OG, Eryaman Y, Aytur O, Atalar
E. Miniaturized fiber-optic transmission system for MRI signals. MRM. 2008;59(1):165-173. doi:10.1002/mrm.21462.
3. Bagci T, Simonsen A, Schmid S, et al.
Optical detection of radio waves through a nanomechanical transducer. Nature.
2014;507(7490):81-85. doi:10.1038/nature13029.
4. Takeda K, Nagasaka K, Noguchi A, et
al. Electro-mechano-optical detection of nuclear magnetic resonance. Optica.
2018;5(2):152. doi:10.1364/OPTICA.5.000152.
5. Simonsen A, Saarinen SA, Sanchez JD,
Ardenkjær-Larsen JH, Schliesser A, Polzik ES. Sensitive optomechanical
transduction of electric and magnetic signals to the optical domain. Opt
Express. 2019;27(13):18561. doi:10.1364/OE.27.018561.