Marrissa McIntosh1, Rachel Eddy1, Danielle Knipping2, Tamas Lindenmaier2, David McCormack3, Christopher Licskai3, Cory Yamashita3, and Grace Parraga4
1Department of Medical Biophysics, Robarts Research Institute, Western University, London, ON, Canada, 2Robarts Research Institute, Western University, London, ON, Canada, 3Division of Respirology, Department of Medicine, Western University, London, ON, Canada, 4Department of Medical Biophysics, Division of Respirology, Department of Medicine, Robarts Research Institute, Western University, London, ON, Canada
Synopsis
129Xe MRI ventilation images consist of embedded texture
features that help explain abnormal ventilation heterogeneity. We postulated
that such texture features may help predict severe asthma patient response to
anti-IL-5 therapies. Therefore, we employed supervised shallow learning
techniques to identify specific 129Xe MRI features that help predict
anti-IL-5 responders. Texture analysis yielded features that were superior to
clinical measurements in identifying severe asthma patients that responded to
anti-IL-5 therapy after 28 days. These promising results suggest that texture
analysis may help predict asthmatics more likely to respond, before treatment is
initiated.
Introduction
Hyperpolarized 129Xe magnetic resonance
imaging (MRI) provides a way to spatially locate and quantify inhaled gas
abnormalities related to airway dysfunction, inflammation and remodeling. In
previous work, hyperpolarized 3He ventilation defect percent (VDP)
was shown to be directly related to airway wall inflammation1
in all participants with asthma and sputum eosinophilia in patients with severe
asthma.2 Currently-used segmentation
tools typically binarize ventilated versus non-ventilated lung tissue,
disregarding signal intensity differences and assuming all ventilated regions
contribute equally to global lung function. These signal intensity differences
can be quantified using gray-level run length matrices (GLRLM)3. Texture features, such as short
run emphasis (SRE), long run emphasis (LRE), low gray-level run emphasis
(LGRE), and gray level non-uniformity (GLN) can be extracted from GLRLM to describe ventilation heterogeneity.
While SRE and LRE describe short and long runs, respectively LGRE describes
low-gray levels and GLN evaluates the distribution of gray levels within an
image.
Benralizumab is
a member of a class of biologic humanized monoclonal antibody therapies that targets
interleukin 5 (IL-5). In patients with severe eosinophilic asthma who were
poorly controlled with maximal guidelines-based therapy, the subcutaneous
injection of 30 mg benralizumab was shown to improve the forced exhaled volume
in 1 second (FEV1), quality of life (QOL), and benralizumab also
significantly reduced blood eosinophil counts to normal levels.4,5
It remains difficult to predict however, who will
respond to IL-5 therapy. Moreover, current measurements of anti-IL-5 therapy
response are relatively insensitive to small airway function and cannot detect
objective improvements within weeks of therapy when blood eosinophil counts are
completely normalized.
In this regard,
hyperpolarized gas MRI VDP and MRI texture analysis have been previously used
to measure post- bronchodilator improvements6,7
in airway function and ventilation and to predict methacholine responsive
asthmatics. Here we hypothesized that VDP and texture features including SRE,
LRE, LGRE, and GLN would significantly distinguish responders from
non-responders with severe eosinophilic asthma prior to treatment with benralizumab.
Therefore, the objective of this work was to extract texture features from 129Xe
MRI prior to therapy and use a shallow learning approach to identify features
that predict response to benralizumab therapy using asthma control improvements
as the gold standard. Methods
Participants
with severe eosinophilic asthma (blood eosinophils ≥300 cells/μL)
provided written informed consent to an ethics board approved protocol and 129Xe
MRI (400 mL inhaled), pulmonary function tests at baseline and 28-days
post-benralizumab (30 mg). A small subset of patients also consented to MRI
14-days post-benralizumab.
Anatomical 1H
and hyperpolarized 129Xe were acquired using a 3.0 Tesla Discovery
MR750 (General Electric Health Care, WI, USA). Participants were instructed to
inhale 1.0 L of gas (100% N2 for anatomical scan and 400 mL
hyperpolarized 129Xe mixed with 600 mL 4He) to ensure
volume matched images for segmentation. MRI was acquired under breath-hold
conditions. Images were segmented to measure VDP8
and the GLRLM3,6
was calculated pre- and post-salbutamol before benralizumab was administered.
The GLRLM method was modified specifically for xenon texture feature analysis.
From these matrices, we calculated 11 second-order texture features, including SRE,
LRE, LGRE and GLN.6
Participants
who reported an ACQ-6 improvement ≥ minimal clinically-important-difference 28-days post-benralizumab were stratified
as benralizumab responders.5
Receiver operator characteristic (ROC) curves were generated pre-and
post-bronchodilator for FEV1, lung clearance index (LCI),
oscillometry-measured airway resistance (R5Hz, R5Hz-19Hz),
VDP, GLRLM texture features, and the St. George’s Respiratory Questionnaire
(SGRQ) using GraphPad Prism 8.0.2. Results
Table 1 provides demographic characteristics for all 17
participants (of 30 prospectively planned for enrollment) evaluated including
nine participants who reported an ACQ-6 response greater than the minimal
clinically-important difference. Responders were younger, with greater baseline
eosinophil values and lower baseline FEV1. Figure 2 provides 129Xe
MRI centre slice ventilation images for representative benralizumab responders
and non-responders.
As shown in Figure 3, post-bronchodilator baseline
MRI LGRE (AUC=.81, p=.03) was significantly predictive, whereas post-bronchodilator
baseline VDP (AUC=.76, p=.07), GLN (AUC=.75, p=.08), and SGRQ (AUC=.76, p=.07) trended
towards significance. Oscillometry, pulmonary function tests and lung clearance
index values, were not significant predictors of benralizumab response. Discussion
There
are currently 4 biologic therapy options for patients with severe asthma and
the number will increase to six in the very near future. Unfortunately, it is difficult to predict those
patients that will experience a positive response to IL-5 therapy. Moreover, current
measurements of anti-IL-5 therapy response are relatively insensitive to small
airway function and cannot detect objective improvements within weeks of
therapy when blood eosinophil counts are completely normalized. Here, in a small group of 17 asthmatics
undergoing treatment, we identified potential texture features that are
predictive of IL-5 therapy response. With the completion of the study in 30
participants, we expect to identify novel MRI predictors of response. Conclusion
Post-bronchodilator
baseline MRI features and VDP are potential predictors of improved asthma
control in response to biologic therapy in severe asthma. This is important and
clinically relevant because of the high cost of biologic therapy (~$30,000
annually) and the inability to predict or identify patients who will respond
prior to therapy initiation. Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1 Svenningsen, S. et al. Thorax 69, 63-71 (2014).
2 Svenningsen, S. et
al. Am J
Respir Crit Care Med 197,
876-884 (2018).
3 Haralick, R. M. et al. Ieee T
Syst Man Cyb Smc3, 610-621 (1973).
4 Bleecker, E. R. et
al. Lancet 388, 2115-2127 (2016).
5 FitzGerald, J. M. et
al. Lancet 388, 2128-2141 (2016).
6 Zha, N. et al.
Acad Radiol 23, 176-185 (2016).
7 Kirby, M. et al. Radiology
261, 283-292 (2011).
8 Kirby, M. et al. Acad Radiol 19, 141-152 (2012).