Dikoma C. Shungu1, Xiangling Mao1, Michelle Blate2, Diana Vu2, Guoxin Kang1, Halinder S. Mangat3, Claire Henchcliffe3, Bejamin Natelson2, and Nora Weiduschat1
1Radiology, Weill Cornell Medicine, New York, NY, United States, 2Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, New York, NY, United States, 3Neurology, Weill Cornell Medicine, New York, NY, United States
Synopsis
N-acetylcysteine (NAC), a glutathione
(GSH) synthesis precursor, is thought to have anti-glutamatergic properties for
which direct in vivo evidence is
lacking. In this study, the postulated anti-glutamatergic properties of NAC were
investigated by using 1H MRS to monitor changes in brain levels of
both GSH and glutamate (Glu) in response to 4 weeks of NAC supplementation in
patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and healthy volunteers (HV). Following NAC treatment, GSH levels increased significantly in CFS
and numerically in HV, while Glu decreased significantly in both groups
compared to baseline – a finding that supports NAC as an anti-glutamatergic
agent.
INTRODUCTION
Deficits of brain
glutathione (GSH), the primary antioxidant in living tissue are postulated to
be implicated in various neurological and neuropsychiatric disorders. However,
due to the poor blood-brain barrier permeability of GSH, direct supplementation
is ineffective in elevating its brain levels. Therefore, there has been great
interest in investigating N-acetylcysteine (NAC), as a prodrug that can be
deacetylated to supply cysteine (Cys), the rate-limiting substrate in GSH
synthesis (Figure 1), which can
cross the BBB. Once inside the cell, Cys combines with glutamate (Glu) to
initiate GSH synthesis in a reaction that is catalyzed by γ-glutamyl cysteine
ligase (GCL), the rate-limiting enzyme (Figure
1). Likely due to the GCL-catalyzed reaction of NAC-supplied Cys with Glu
to spur GSH synthesis, NAC is believed to have
anti-glutamatergic properties. However, direct in vivo evidence of NAC as an anti-glutamatergic agent is currently
lacking. In this study, we used 1H MRS to monitor changes in brain
levels of both GSH and Glu in response to 4 weeks of daily supplementation with
NAC in patients with chronic fatigue syndrome (CFS) and matched healthy
volunteer (HV) subjects. Having previously shown [1] that 4 weeks of NAC
supplementation significantly increased brain levels of GSH in CFS, while
eliciting only a numerically non-significant increase in mean GSH in HV, we
postulated that the effect of NAC on Glu levels would be opposite to that
observed for GSH, i.e., a decrease in CFS patients and, possibly, also in HV.METHODS
Subjects: Participants
recruited for this study consisted of 12 medication-free patients with CFS,
diagnosed according to the CDC criteria [2], and 12 HV subjects, who served as the
normal comparison group.
NAC Supplementation: To investigate the
effects of dietary NAC supplementation on cortical GSH and Glu levels, each
subject underwent a 1H MRS scan at baseline. Then a 4-week
supplement of 900mg NAC tablets was provided, to be taken 2 per day for a daily
NAC dose of 1800mg. Finally, each subject was brought back after 4 weeks for
the post-NAC 1H MRS scans to determine the effect of the treatment on cortical
GSH and Glu levels.
Brain
1H MRS:
In vivo cortical GSH spectra were
recorded in 15 min on a 3.0 T GE MR system from a 3.0x3.0x2.0-cm3 occipital cortex voxel (Figure 2) using the standard
J-editing technique (Figure 2A),
with TE/TR 68/1500ms and 290 interleaved excitations (580 total) as recently
described [3]. Levels of Glu, uncontaminated with glutamine, were obtained from
the same voxel in 6 min using the CT-PRESS sequence [4] (Figure 2B), with TE/TR 139ms/1500ms, and 129 chemical shift
encoding steps in increments of 0.8ms in t1 dimension. Peak areas for both GSH and
Glu were derived by frequency-domain fitting of the recorded spectra.The resulting peak areas were then expressed as
ratios relative to the area of the unsuppressed tissue water (W) signal in the
same voxel [3].RESULTS
GSH
Levels (Figure 3): As previously
reported [1], we found that within
the CFS group, the effect of 4 weeks of NAC supplementation was to increase
cortical GSH levels significantly compared to baseline (p=0.004), while within
the HV group mean GSH levels increased numerically without reaching statistical
significance relative to baseline (p=0.33). Between
the CFS and HV groups, there was a significant GSH deficit at baseline in CFS
(p=0.04) relative to HV, which vanished following 4 weeks of NAC (p=0.42),
indicating normalization of GSH levels in CFS with NAC.
Glu
Levels (Figure 3): Within both the CFS and HV groups, the effect of 4 weeks of NAC
supplementation was to decrease cortical Glu significantly compared to
baseline (p=0.02 and p=0.04, respectively). Between
the CFS and HV groups, mean Glu levels did not differ at baseline (p=0.24).
However, following 4 weeks of NAC, there was a trend-level lower Glu in CFS
than in HV (p=0.07), indicating a larger Glu decrease in CFS than in HV after
NAC.DISCUSSION AND CONCLUSION
This
study has documented, for the first time, that in situ GSH synthesis following NAC supplementation is accompanied by
a significant decrease of brain Glu, supporting the postulated
anti-glutamatergic property of NAC. The decrease in total Glu levels at 4 weeks
suggests that there might be a net increase in the consumption of intracellular
Glu reserves in the GCL-catalyzed reaction that combines NAC-supplied Cys with
Glu as the first and rate-limiting step in GSH synthesis (Figure 1). Interestingly, there appears to be a degree of
consistency between the changes in GSH and Glu in the CFS and HV groups: 4
weeks of NAC numerically increased GSH in the HV group without reaching
statistical significance, in apparent consistency with a correspondingly
smaller decrease in Glu at 4 weeks. By contrast, the larger and statistically
significant increase in GSH after 4 weeks of NAC appeared to elicit a
correspondingly larger Glu decrease in the CFS group. In summary, the results
of this study support the role of NAC as an anti-glutamatergic agent, which
seems to modulate Glu levels by increasing the availability of intracellular
Cys that then combines with Glu to initiate GSH synthesis, leading to a lowering
of total Glu levels as measured with MRS.Acknowledgements
Support for this study was provided by NIH/NINR 5R21NR01365001.References
[1] Weiduschat N, et
al. Proc Intl Soc Magn Reson Med 2017; 25: Abstract #4553.
[2] Fukuda K, et al.
Ann Intern Med 1994; 121: 953-959.
[3] Shungu DC, et al.
NMR Biomed 2012; 25:1073-87
[4] Mayer D and
Spielman DM. Magn Reson Med 54, 439-442.