Gael Saib1, Alan Koretsky1, and S Lalith Talagala2
1NINDS/LFMI, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, United States, 2NINDS/NMRF, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD, United States
Synopsis
Pseudo-continuous arterial spin
labeling (PCASL) is very sensitive to off-resonance effects. This is especially
a problem at higher fields (>3T). Off-resonance effects can be compensated by
using an average or a vessel-specific correction integrated into the PCASL
tagging/control pulse. Vessel-specific corrections can be performed using a
prescan or a field map. In this study, we compared three off-resonance compensation
strategies at 7T. Data showed that a large improvement (> 2 times) of the PCASL
signal can be obtained with subject specific off-resonance correction with all 3
methods. The field
map based method showed slightly better performance over the others.
Introduction
Pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling (PCASL) is an established pulse
sequence for perfusion MRI1. It is well known that off-resonance effects can
cause significant degradation of the PCASL tagging efficiency deteriorating the image quality and the
cerebral blood flow estimation2,3. Robustness of PCASL to off-resonance
effects can be increased by using an unbalanced PCASL scheme, a short RF
separation, a low average gradient, a low selective/average gradient ratio, and
a high B14,5. However, these solutions can be hard to optimize,
especially at high-field
(>3T) where SAR restrictions and off-resonance effects are heightened6,7.
To compensate for these effects an
optimal PCASL RF phase increment can be calculated either by a pre-scan
procedure6 or an off-resonance field ($$$\triangle$$$B0) map of the tagging
location8,9. In the pre-scan approach, a series of low-resolution perfusion images
of one or more slices is acquired with different PCASL RF phase increments.
When using the field map method, the average off-resonance field and the
off-resonance gradient are determined at the tagging plane, directly around the
feeding arteries.
A more comprehensive approach consists of
compensating for in-plane off-resonance by combining the PCASL RF phase
increment with appropriate transverse gradients. In this case, instead of using
an average off-resonance correction, small in-plane rephasing gradients are
calculated based on the spatial information derived either from the prescan or the
field map6. In this work, we compare the effectiveness of using vessel-specific and an average off-resonance correction to optimize PCASL imaging at 7T. Methods
Five
healthy volunteers (3 men and 2 women, age 26$$$\pm$$$23.3 years) were scanned on a 7-T MRI system (Magnetom Terra, Siemens Healthineers)
under an IRB approved protocol. Images were acquired using a 1Tx/32Rx coil
array and a 2D-EPI sequence with an unbalanced PCASL preparation pulse train. The
vendor supplied ‘brain’ automatic shimming (up to second order) was performed
at the beginning of each experiment with a shim region covering the brain and
the tagging location (bottom of the cerebellum). The PCASL parameters were: selection
gradient (Gmax)=3.5mT/m, mean gradient (Gmean)=0.25mT/m, Hanning
RF pulse duration/separation=800/1700$$$\mu$$$s, B1 peak amplitude=5.7$$$\mu$$$T,
labeling duration (LD)=1.5s and post-labeling delay (PLD) =1.5s. These
parameters were chosen to minimize the time between the PCASL RF pulses while
not exceeding the SAR limits. The 2D-EPI parameters were: matrix=64x64,
resolution=3x3x3mm3, slices=23, TE/TR=12/4500ms, Grappa factor=2 and
TA=6min.
Four
PCASL acquisitions were performed using different off-resonance compensation
strategies: (i) no correction, (ii) prescan based correction (PScor), (iii) field-map
based correction (FMcor), and (iv) average correction (AVGcor). PCASL
prescan data were acquired using a balanced PCASL scheme with a LD/PLD
1000/300ms and tagging RF phase increments ranging from -180 to 180 deg with
22.5 deg increments.The field map at the tagging plane was acquired using a
FLASH sequence (resolution=2.5x2.5x2.5mm3, TR=25ms, TE=1.8ms). A 1x1x1mm3 time-of-flight angiogram was acquired at the tagging plane to localize the feeding arteries.
The prescan and the
field map data were processed offline using Matlab. In PScor, the PCASL inter-pulse phase
angle error ($$$\triangle\phi$$$) was deduced from a cosine fit to
the prescan data for the three main perfusion territories.
In FMcor, the phase angle error was determined by $$$\triangle\phi$$$ = $$$2\pi\triangle$$$B0 $$$\triangle t \left(1-\frac{Gmean}{Gmax}\right)$$$ where $$$\triangle$$$B0 is the vessel specific field offset around the right internal carotid, the left internal carotid and between the two vertebral arteries. $$$\triangle t$$$ is the PCASL RF pulse separation. The $$$\triangle\phi$$$ values of each method were used to calculate the
optimum PCASL correction parameters as described previously6.
For AVGcor, the average of the field offsets around the feeding arteries was used
to calculate a PCASL RF phase increment directly.
In
each data set, the normalized perfusion signal ((control-tag)/M0) was quantified
in the three perfusion territories using manually drawn regions of interest in the
four central slices. Results
Table 1 presents the phase angle error $$$\triangle\phi$$$ determined from prescan and field map data. This
shows a large inter-subject variability with an average $$$\triangle\phi$$$ of -82$$$\pm$$$33deg. Figure 1
shows perfusion data obtained from 2 subjects without and with off-resonance correction
using FMcor. In data acquired without correction, the perfusion signal is
observed in either the posterior or the anterior territory only (Fig. 1a).
However, with FMcor, the perfusion signal is observed uniformly thoughout the
brain (Fig. 1b). The normalized perfusion signal measured for all data sets is
shown in Figure 2. On average, the perfusion
signal increased by a factor of 2.6, 2.9 and 2.7 after PScor, FMcor and AVGcor,
respectively. Discussion
This
work shows that subject specific PCASL off-resonance compensation is necessary
to acquire good quality cerebral perfusion images at 7T. The large
inter-subject variability of the off-resonance field leads to highly variable
image quality and reduced perfusion without off-resonance correction. In this
study, all three correction methods vastly improved the perfusion signal in all
the territories leading to uniform perfusion throughout the brain. FMcor and
AVGcor performance was similar and slightly better than PScor, but these trends
need to be confirmed with a larger subject population. Further improvement of
PCASL at 7T may be possible by incorporation of off-resonance gradient
corrections8. Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Alsop DC, Detre JA, Golay X et. al., Recommended
implementation of arterial spin-labeled perfusion MRI for clinical
applications: A consensus of the ISMRM perfusion study group and the European
consortium for ASL in dementia. Magn. Reson. Med. 2015;73(1):102-16.
2. Jung Y, Wong E, Liu T, Multiphase Pseudocontinuous arterial spin labeling
(MP-PCASL) for robust quantification of cerebral blood flow. Magn. Reson. Med.
2010;64:799-810.
3. Shin D, Liu T, Wong E, Shankaranarayanan A et. al., Pseudocontinuous arterial spin labeling with
optimized tagging efficiency. Magn. Reson. Med.
2012;68:1135-1144.
4. Zhao L, Vidorreta
M, Soman S et. al., Improving the
robustness of pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling to off-resonance and
pulsatile flow velocity. Magn. Reson. Med.
2017;78:1342-1351.
5. Boland
M, Stirnberg R, Pracht E et al., Robust and SAR-efficient whole-brain
pseudo-continuous ASL at 7T. Proceedings ISMRM 2019; 4963.
6. Luh WM, Talagala SL, Li TQ et. al., Pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling at 7T for
human brain: estimation and correction for off-resonance effects using a
prescan. Magn. Reson. Med. 2013;69:402-410.
7. Hirschler L, Debacker CS, Voiron J et al., Interpulse phase corrections for unbalanced
pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling at high magnetic field. Magn. Reson.
Med. 2018;79:1314-1324.
8. Jahanian H, Noll DC, Hernandez-Garcia L, B0 field inhomogeneity considerations in
pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling (pCASL): effects on tagging efficiency
and correction strategy. NMR BioMed. 2011;24,1202-1209.
9. Berry E, Jezzard P, Okell T, Off-resonance correction for pseudo-continuous
arterial spin labeling using the optimized encoding scheme. NeuroImage 2019;
199:304-312.