Julian Emmerich1 and Sina Straub1
1Medical Physics in Radiology, German Cancer Research Center (DKFZ), Heidelberg, Germany
Synopsis
In
this work, we present a fast and accurate T2 mapping method based on standard
multi-echo turbo spin echo sequences (ME-TSE) that are widely available on
clinical scanners. Estimation of T2 values is done by a Bloch simulation-based
algorithm. As this method can account for stimulated echoes that occur during
the echo train within a TSE sequence, its use for sequences with reduced
refocusing flip angle is feasible to avoid SAR problems at higher field
strength.
Introduction
Quantitative
magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) is still rarely used in today’s clinical
practice except for diffusion MRI and relaxometry in myocardial imaging, but it
can provide additional information on tissue properties1.
In this work, we present a fast and accurate T2
mapping method based on a standard multi-echo turbo spin echo sequence (ME-TSE)
that is widely available on clinical scanners. For higher field strength ME-TSE
sequences can only be used with reduced refocusing angle due to SAR (specific
absorption rate) limitations. The proposed dictionary-based method can also
account for the effects of stimulated echoes that occur when using refocusing
angles smaller than 180°.Methods
The relaxation of transverse
magnetization $$$M_{xy}$$$
can be described using Bloch equations. In the
ideal case of perfect 180° refocusing pulses, signal decay due to T2 relaxation
can be modeled as $$$ M_{xy} (t) = M_0 \cdot \exp{(-\frac{t}{T_2})} $$$
. In
general, the signal decay will follow a generalized echo modulation curve
depending on pulse shape and refocusing angle that can be obtained by
performing Bloch simulations of the actual imaging sequence2,3.
The radio frequency
shapes, timings and gradient schemes were read from the SIEMENS poet sequence
simulation tool. Bloch simulations were performed along slice direction to
account for dephasing due to non-ideal slice profile using Matlab (MathWorks, MA,
USA) with an internal spatial resolution of 0.05 mm and a temporal resolution
of 5$$$~$$$μs. Data was acquired with
a SIEMENS Symphony fit 1.5$$$~$$$T (Siemens Healthcare, Erlangen, Germany). Imaging and simulation parameters of
the multi-slice triple-echo TSE sequence were: TR = 6800$$$~$$$ms, TE = 11/142/273$$$~$$$ms, echo train length ETL = 11.
In each run of the simulation, one echo modulation curve (EMC) for a specific
T2 value within a range of T2 = [50,…,200]$$$~$$$ms and for different refocusing flip
angles α = 120°/150°/180° was generated. Assuming that image contrast is mainly determined by the
central k-space lines, only the first echo of each of the three echo trains was
taken into account during the simulation4. Measured signal
evolution was compared and matched
to simulated EMC to find correct T2 values. Ground truth T2 data was obtained
by single echo spin echo (SE) imaging with three different echo times and mono-exponential fitting of the data.
The method was
validated ex vivo with an agarose gel phantom with different T2 values similar
to those in the human brain. In vivo measurements of the human brain were
conducted in accordance with the declaration of Helsinki.Results
Figure 1 depicts the T2
maps from different evaluation methods. In the first row, the outcome of the
spin echo experiment is shown, which was used as ground truth. In the second
row of Figure 1, mono-exponential fits of the data from the TSE-experiment are
shown and in the last row dictionary-based T2 maps for the different refocusing
angles are presented. Evaluation results for each single mask are shown in
Figure 2. The bar graphs represent mean value and standard deviation for each
of the 13 masks and the different calculation methods. T2 values obtained by mono-exponential
fit of TSE-data are markedly larger than the ground truth. Dictionary-based T2 mapping
can provide relaxation values that coincide with the SE-experiment.
Figure 3 shows that T2
values obtained by Bloch-based reconstruction can describe transverse
relaxation times also in in vivo experiments. Bloch-based T2 values in the
white matter region are within the range of 70-85 ms. As marked with white
arrow heads T2 maps from Bloch-based reconstruction suffer less from artifacts
than the SE-approach.Discussion
Bloch-based
T2 mapping can provide reliable results in phantom experiments. Also in vivo T2
values coincide with literature values3.
There is still a slight difference when using different refocusing angles. This
might be caused by system imperfections that cause additional echo paths that
cannot be accounted for by the simulations.
A
simple exponential fit can not model the signal evolution correctly since it
does not account for stimulated echoes. Reduction of artifacts can be obtained by
the shorter measurement
time in TSE experiment (1:44 min) compared with the SE experiment (37:09 min).
Taking
more than three echoes into account could improve stability of T2 estimation
but would also increase SAR and therefore limit resolution or field of view.Conclusion
The proposed method of
Bloch-based reconstruction of T2 values from a multi-echo turbo spin echo
sequence is a suitable tool for fast and accurate determination of T2
relaxation times. Due to short acquisition times in ME-TSE sequences compared
with standard SE sequences also motion artifacts can be minimized.
Especially at higher
field strength T2 reconstruction from sequences with small refocusing flip angle
is of high importance, since TSE sequences are otherwise limited by high SAR.Acknowledgements
The authors thank Sebastian Flassbeck and Simon Schmidt for providing the phantom and their valuable support.
References
1. Horsfield MA, Jones DK. Applications
of diffusion-weighted and diffusion tensor MRI to white matter diseases – a
review. NMR in biomedicine. 2002;15(7-8):570-577.
2. Ben-Eliezer
N, Sodickson DK, Block KT. Rapid and accurate T2 mapping from multi-spin-echo
data using Bloch-simulation-based reconstruction. Magnetic resonance in medicine. 2015;73(2):809-817.
3. Whittall KP,
Mackay AL, Graeb DA, Nugent RA, Li DKB, Paty DW. In vivo measurement of T2
distributions and water contents in normal human brain. Magnetic resonance in medicine. 1997;37(1):34-43.
4. Mezrich R. A
perspective on K-space. Radiology. 1995;195(2):297-315.