Zo Raolison1, Redha Abdeddaïm2, Marc Dubois2, Lisa Leroi1, Luisa Neves2, Franck Mauconduit3, Stefan Enoch2, Nicolas Malléjac4, Pierre Sabouroux2, Anne-Lise Adenot-Engelvin4, and Alexandre Vignaud1
1CEA-Neurospin, Paris, France, 2Institut Fresnel, Marseille, France, 3Siemens Healthineers, Saint Denis, France, 4CEA-Le Ripault, Monts, France
Synopsis
A simple and efficient way
to enhance the B1+ field dark areas appearing in the
temporal lobes at 7T in MRI is to use pads with relative High-Dielectric
Constant materials which most promising ones are perovskites mixed with water. As
their performance drops over time, those materials are still not currently used
in clinical routine. A novel high lifespan material made of 4-Fluoro
1.3-dioxalan-2-one and Polyethylene glycol mixed with silicon carbide particles
is presented here. It is shown that their performances are on pair with BaTiO3
water mixture through permittivity measurements and MRI scans a 7T.
Introduction:
One way to address the B
1+ inhomogeneity in ultra-high
field MRI (B
0≥7T) is the use of relative High-Dielectric Constant (HDC)
materials in radiofrequency (RF) coils [1]. Their high displacement currents
alter the global RF distribution in the transmit coil and generate a secondary
localized RF field used to tune the B
1+ field distribution. Most
current effective HDCs are currently made into small rectangular pads filled
with BaTiO
3 water mixtures. Unfortunately, major drawbacks prevent
their use in clinical routine: drops in performance over time [1] and toxicity
during preparation [2]. A new dielectric material combined with an innovative
solvent is presented here to mimic BaTiO
3 pads performance while
addressing those issues to pave the way for new long-lasting, comfortable and
efficient pads.
Materials and Methods:
Silicon Carbide
(SiC) spherical particles (Neyco, Vanves, France) were mixed with 4-Fluoro
1.3-dioxalan-2-one (Chemos, Regenstauf, Germany), also called FEC, with powder volume
ratio contents ranging from 5% to 60%. Particles average size is around 2 µm to
ensure good particle density in the composite material. Volume contents of Polyethylene
glycol (Sigma-Aldrich, Saint Louis, USA), also called PEG, is added as a
dispersant agent for the slurry homogeneity. Its quantity is fixed to 10% for volume contents of SiC
below 50% and to 1% above 50% to ensure high permittivity levels in the
sample. Samples above 50% are machine-pressed. Its number average molar mass is
10 000. Permittivity measurements on the mixtures have been carried out through
Nicolson and Ross protocol [3] combined with a de-embedding process using an
innovative coaxial cell and sample holder [4]. Rectangular 10x10x1 cm3 pads in polylactic-acid were
filled with those mixtures in order to compare their performance to BaTiO3 water pads. B1+ maps were carried on using
XFL sequences [5] with and without pads, using a birdcage head coil 1Tx/1Rx
(Invivo Corp., Gainesville, USA) and a 3-D printed Specific Anthropomorphic
Mannequin phantom (SAM; ε’=42; ε’’=60)
on a 7T Magnetom MRI scanner (Siemens Healthineer, Erlangen, Germany). Results:
Figure 1 shows
permittivity levels reached by our composite materials at 300 MHz from 0 to 60%
volume contents of SiC powder. Permittivity levels of BaTiO3 water
mixtures are also presented (from [6]). The effects of one SiC pad (ε’=288, ε’’=80) is compared to one pad
filled with BaTiO3 (ε’=241, ε’’=29) mixture. Its permittivity levels are chosen to
have a similar effect to the BaTiO3 pad given permittivity. To that
end, B1+ field distributions are displayed in Figure 2. In both case a B1+ illumination is observed and
the dark area located in the left temporal lobe is tightened in the vicinity of
the pad.Discussion:
Compared to
BaTiO3, a pad filled with SiC particles exhibits a lower B1+ illumination owing to its
higher conductivity. This is a consistent issue when using dispersant agents [1].
But its penetrating
effect can be tuned by adjusting the pad permittivity from 100 to 300. Thus, this
new HDC material displays the required permittivity range to be effective for
MR imaging at 7T. It also has the potential for being daily used in clinical
routines. First, it overcomes the main limitation of the current water based
pads which is its decrease in performance over time [1]. Indeed, the combination of
its solvent and dispersant agent allows a long lifespan: permittivity levels were
preserved after 6 months. Since the solvent fusion temperature is close to 25°C,
the mixture can be stored at lower temperature to prevent particles
sedimentation. Pads are also less prone to dry out as the solvent boiling point
is twice the water boiling temperature. Then,
the overall pasty consistence allows the design of comfortable pads that are
not likely to break and deform when used on a daily basis. Finally, toxicity
threat is much lower than BaTiO3 powders which makes it easier, safer and faster
to prepare.Acknowledgements
This work has been
supported by the Programme Transversal du CEA and the FET-OPEN M-CUBE Project.References
[1] O’Reilly and al., Journal of
Magnetic Resonance, 2016, 270, 108-114.
[2] Regulation EC 1272/2008.
[3] L. F. Chen and al., Microwave
Electronics, John Wiley & Sons, 2004.
[4] É. Georget and al., Comptes Rendus
Phys., 2014, 15(5), 448–457.
[5] S. Chung and al., Magnetic
Resonance in Medicine, 2010, 64, 439–446.
[6] A. L. Neves and al., Magnetic
Resonance in Medicine, 2017 (ahead of print).