Hyo-Im Heo1, Paul Kyu Han2, Seung Hong Choi3, and Sung-Hong Park1
1Department of Bio and Brain Engineering, Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology, Daejeon, Republic of Korea, 2Gordon Imaging Center, Massachusetts General Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States, 3Department of Radiology, Seoul National University College of Medicine, Seoul, Republic of Korea
Synopsis
The conventional pCASL is vulnerable to data corruption
and has high specific absorption rate. In this study, we propose a new pCASL approach
using modulation of labeling RF pulse power and Fourier analysis. The proposed
approach enabled us to acquire perfusion images comparable to those of the
conventional pCASL. Under data corruption, the proposed approach maintained the
perfusion signals well with no observable effect, while the conventional method
showed almost no perfusion signal. The proposed approach has relatively low average
SAR and instantaneous SAR, potentially advantageous at high fields. These
advantages of the proposed method warrant further investigation.
Introduction
Pseudo-continuous arterial spin labeling (pCASL) is
the perfusion imaging technique recommended by the ASL community [1]. Perfusion
signals are mostly acquired by subtraction of images from label and control
scans. In conventional pCASL, labeling and control scans are performed by pseudo-continuous
short RF pulses with phase cycling of 0° and
180°,
respectively. Recently, a new pCASL strategy, which does not use any RF pulse for
control scan, has been suggested [2]. The approach provides higher sensitivity,
robustness to scan conditions, and reduced specific absorption rate (SAR) than
those of the conventional pCASL. Also, pair-wise subtraction typically used in ASL
is vulnerable to unintended image corruption, which may be overcome by period
modulation of labeled signals and corresponding Fourier analysis. In the new
pCASL (no-RF‑control pCASL), the difference between labeling and control scans
is the RF power (flip angle), and thus it is possible to modulate the labeling
effects by changing the RF power. In this study, we propose a new approach for
pCASL by periodic modulation of labeling RF pulse flip angle and Fourier
analysis of the modulated data (with no separate labeling or control scan). The
proposed method is expect to have low instantaneous SAR and be robust to
unintended image corruption during data acquisition because of the Fourier
analysis.Data Acquisition
All experiments were performed on a Siemens 3T Trio
system (Siemens Medical Solution, Erlangen, Germany) on 3 healthy volunteers. The
selection gradient of the pCASL labeling scan increased to 15 mT/m to minimize
the MT effects and thus enable no-RF‑control
pCASL [2]. Three-dimensional balanced steady state precession (bSSFP)
was used for readout. Flip angle of labeling RF pulses of no-RF-control pCASL was
changed periodically between 0⁰ and
30⁰ for
every dynamic scan with two modulation schemes of trapezoidal and sinusoidal shapes
(Fig. 1) and with the step size of 6⁰ and
10⁰ (power-modulated
pCASL). Conventional pCASL and no‑RF-control pCASL (with alternating
labeling/control scans) were also performed for comparison. Common parameters
used in all experiments were as follows; Labeling duration = 1.5 s; labeling RF
pulse duration/spacing = 0.5/1.2 ms; TR/TE=4.08/2.04 ms; 70 dynamic scans;
readout flip angle = 30⁰. The
conventional pCASL was performed with selection gradient of 6 mT/m. Pixel-by-pixel
Fourier transform along temporal dimension was performed for power-modulated
pCASL data. The location of modulation frequency for each condition was
calculated. Also data corruption was simulated by changing intensity of a
randomly-selected data by 20% in order to evaluate the robustness of the conventional
pCASL subtraction scheme and the proposed method.Results
Fig. 2 shows the perfusion
image acquired from conventional pCASL, no-RF-control pCASL, and the proposed power-modulated
pCASL. The power-modulated pCASL showed perfusion images comparable to those
from the conventional pCASL. The 6⁰ step showed better signals than
10⁰ in both trapezoidal and sinusoidal modulations. Images with the sinusoidal modulation
showed clearer and higher perfusion signals than those with trapezoidal modulation.
Under the condition of the image corruption (Fig. 3a), perfusion images with the
subtraction scheme (conventional pCASL) showed significant contamination with
no identifiable perfusion signal, whereas those from Fourier analysis
(power-modulated pCASL) showed almost no difference before and after the
corruption (Fig. 3b).Discussion and Conclusion
The proposed approach utilized modulation of
labeling RF pulse power periodically and acquired perfusion images through Fourier
analysis. Perfusion images comparable to those of the conventional pCASL were
obtained for the proposed method. We could modulate perfusion signals at the
desired frequency and Fourier analysis successfully separated the perfusion
signal component. Sinusoidal modulation showed better perfusion signals than those
of trapezoidal modulation, in agreement with the expectation that Fourier
transform of a sinusoidal signal becomes an impulse signal at the frequency of
oscillation and thus concentrates energy in the desired frequency component. Labeling
RF power modulation, one of the main idea of proposed method, has advantages in
the view point of SAR. Average SAR during the whole scan is significantly
reduced in the proposed method because of using no-RF control scan.
Furthermore, instantaneous SAR in proposed method is expected to be low because
the number of scans with maximum labeling RF flip angle (i.e., labeling scan) is
reduced. Thus, the proposed method is potentially advantageous at high field
MRI systems. Also, Fourier analysis in temporal direction is robust to accidental
image corruption. Based on the many advantages demonstrated in this study, it
is worthwhile investigating the proposed approach as an alternative pCASL
scheme.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1.
Alsop D, Detre J, Golay X et al. Recommended implementation of arterial
spin-labeled perfusion MRI for clinical applications: A consensus of the ISMRM
perfusion study group and the European consortium for ASL in dementia. Magnetic
Resonance in Medicine. 2015;73(1):102-116.
2. Han P, Choi S, Park S. Investigation of control scans in pseudo-continuous
arterial spin labeling (pCASL): Strategies for improving sensitivity and
reliability of pCASL. Magnetic Resonance in Medicine.
2016;78(3):917-929.