Juan Diego Sánchez-Heredia1, Daniel Højrup Johansen1, Rafael A. Baron1, Matthias Schneider2, Gabriele Spörl2, Jarek Wosik3, Vitaliy Zhurbenko1, and Jan H. Ardenkjær-Larsen1
1Department of Electrical Engineering, Technical University of Denmark, Kgs. Lyngby, Denmark, 2Institut für Luft- und Kältetechnik gemeinnützige GmbH, Dresden, Germany, 3Electrical and Computer Engineering Department, University of Houston, Houston, TX, United States
Synopsis
SNR in hyperpolarized 13C MRI is often
limited by the low sensitivity of the receive RF chain at the low Larmor
frequency of 13C. In this study we present an RF transparent
(non-metallic) cryostat designed for small animal imaging, which allows a coil
temperature of 88 K, with a coil-to-sample distance below 3 mm. Performance of
the cryostat equipped with a 30 x 40 mm2 13C surface coil
(3 T, 32 MHz) was tested and 3-fold SNR gain over room temperature coil was
achieved.
Purpose
Cryogenically cooled coils have been a long-standing
promise for SNR enhancement since the early days of MRI1. This is
even more relevant nowadays, with the increased interest on imaging of low
abundance nuclei with lower Larmor frequencies than protons2.
However, the increased coil-to-sample distance needed in cryogenic coils can
easily neutralize the SNR enhancement obtained by cooling. In this study we
describe an MRI transparent cryostat for small animal imaging (Ø 73 mm) which
allows a coil-to-sample distance below 3 mm, with the coil temperature reaching
88K while the outer surface being kept at room temperature.Methods
A schematic of the cryostat is shown in Fig. 1. A separate ceramic (Al2O3)
cylinder (AdValue, AZ, USA) whose outer diameter matches the inner diameter of
the vessel acts as a cold-finger for to-be-cooled RF coil(s). Besides the vacuum
thermal insulation, additional Multi-Layer Insulation (MLI) was installed, to
reduce radiation heat losses. A combination of traditional (aluminized Mylar)
and non-metallic (Kapton) MLI was used, in order to avoid eddy currents close
to the RF coil (Fig. 2). The cryostat (ILK, Dresden, Germany) is shown in Fig. 3a,
while the cold-finger (with the RF coil attached) is shown in Fig. 3b.
Temperature sensors were attached to the cold-finger, and to the outside
the cryostat (at the animal position). The temperatures were monitored under
two different situations: without heat externally applied to the inner bore,
and with warm air (50 ℃) applied. The approximate
amount of LN2 supplied during the experiment was 6 L.
An octagonal 40x30 mm2 RF coil made of flat
copper (thickness 1.2 mm) was glued to the cold finger using thermally
conductive epoxy, and its Q-factor measured at room temperature and when cooled
down inside the cryostat. A reference measurement with the coil immersed in LN2
was also performed. The coil includes tuning, matching and active decoupling as
described in3.
The SNR performance was measured with a combination of
a spectrum analyzer (Keysight, CA, USA) and a signal generator
(Rohde&Schwarz, Munich, Germany). A small pickup loop was placed inside the
cryostat bore, at a distance of 38 mm to the coil, and excited with -100 dBm.
The received signal was measured for two different cases: room temperature (290
K) and cooled (88K), and the SNR calculated.Results
The measured temperature inside and outside the
cryostat is shown in Fig. 4, where the warm air was applied for 5 min from minute
70 to 75, and later for a longer period of 50 min (from minute 100 to 150). It
can be appreciated that the application of warm air, increases only minimally
the temperature of the cold finger (0.6 K).
The coil Q-factor is shown in Fig. 5.a). The Q-factor
is increased from 325 to 599 when the coil is cooled, which agrees well with
other results reported for coils of similar size4,5. The measured
SNR is shown in Fig. 5.b.Discussion
The measured temperature at the coil position was 88 K (-184 °C), and this
temperature could be kept stable for several hours (not shown in Figure 4). The
temperature at the sample position was slightly decreased after some minutes to
a stable value of about 10℃. This could be corrected by
applying warm air at 50 ℃, with a minimal effect on the
temperature of the cold-finger (and therefore on the coil).
The relatively small difference between the measured Q-factor of the
coil inside the cryostat, compared to the coil immersed in LN2 shows
that the coil is indeed very close to the LN2 temperature (77 K). A
3-fold SNR enhancement was measured, which agrees well with the theoretically
predicted value when sample losses are negligible $$$(ΔSNR = \frac{\sqrt{Q_{88K}·290}}{\sqrt{Q_{290K}·88}} = 2.6)$$$. The extra factor from 2.6 to 3 can be attributed to
the noise reduction in the matching network, which was observed to effectively
decrease the noise levels when cooled down.Conclusion
Cryogenically cooled RF receive coils can be the means to significantly
improve SNR in 13C MRI, where sample noise is not very important.
This is so, as long as the coil-to-sample distance is not increased excessively
due to the thermal insulation needed to provide a warm environment at the
sample position. In this study we describe a small animal cryogenic coil setup,
where the coil can be kept at a distance below 3 mm from the sample, while
keeping the sample position at room temperature. A 3-fold SNR enhancement is reported
for a small 30x40 mm2 octagonal coil for 13C at 3T (32 MHz), which
agrees well with the theoretically predicted value.Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. Black
R, Early T, Roemer P, Mueller O, Mogro-Campero A, Turner L, et al. A
high-temperature superconducting receiver for nuclear magnetic resonance
microscopy. Science (80- ). 1993 Feb 5;259(5096):793–5.
2. Ardenkjær-Larsen
JH. Increase in Signal-to-Noise Ratio of > 10,000 Times in Liquid-State
NMR. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2003;100(18).
3. Sanchez-Heredia
JD, Szocska Hansen ES, Laustsen C, Zhurbenko V, Ardenkjær-Larsen JH. Low-Noise
Active Decoupling Circuit and its Application to 13C Cryogenic RF Coils at 3T.
TOMOGRAPHY. 2017;3(1):60:66.
4. Wright
AC, Song HK, Wehrli FW. In Vivo MR Micro Imaging With Conventional
Radiofrequency Coils Cooled to 77°K. MRM. 2000;169:163–9.
5. Ratering D, Baltes C, Nordmeyer-massner J, Marek D, Rudin
M. Performance of a 200-MHz Cryogenic RF Probe Designed for MRI and MRS of the
Murine Brain. MRM. 2008;1447:1440–7.