Pei-Hsin Wu1, Frank Preiswerk1, Cheng-Chieh Cheng1, and Bruno Madore1
1Radiology, Brigham and Women's Hospital, Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA, United States
Synopsis
MR
thermometry, based on proton resonance frequency (PRF) shift, can be achieved
by the phase subtraction between pretreatment baseline images and treatment
images. However, breathing motion leads to phase errors that may corrupt
temperature measurements. We propose the use of a hybrid MR-ultrasound imaging
setup and reconstruction algorithm to provide the phase reference required for
PRF thermometry in moving organs. The generated synthetic MR-ultrasound images
match the acquired images in all respect except for the fact that they do not
contain any heating information, and thus provide a valuable non-heated phase
reference from which temperature changes can be
quantified.
Introduction
The proton resonance
frequency (PRF) shift method has become the prevalent technique for MR
thermometry1. Breathing motion creates phase shifts
that may corrupt temperature measurements, and two main approaches have been
proposed to handle such motion: the referenceless2 and the multi-baseline3 approach. A hybridized version of the two
has also been proposed4.
The
present work introduces a method for thermometry in moving organs that fits in
the same general category as the multi-baseline approach. As in all such
multi-baseline methods, images acquired before heating are employed to
synthesize a phase reference, from which temperature-induced phase shifts can
be measured. However, instead of using navigator echoes and/or a respiratory
belt to characterize motion, a hybrid MR-ultrasound imaging system equivalent
to that described in Ref5 was implemented here. Thermometry is
typically performed for guidance purposes, during image-guided therapies, and a
respiratory belt would involve much fabric and Velcro that would get in the way
of an interventionalist; in contrast, the ultrasound probe employed here
contacts only a small location on the torso and directly senses organ position.
Furthermore, navigator echoes typically take time away from the acquisition
process and are quite limited in terms of information content; in contrast, the
signal from our organ configuration motion (OCM) ultrasound sensor was acquired
in parallel with the MRI signal and proved very rich in terms of information
content. Minimally-invasive thermal therapies in abdominal organs of wakeful
free-breathing patients may become a desirable alternative to surgical
resection, but robust free-breathing implementations of the PRF approach
continue to be difficult to achieve. We hope that the proposed hybrid OCM-MR
imaging method may prove part of the solution.Methods
Human scans were
performed after informed consent, on a 3.0T Siemens Verio system (45 mT/m,
200/T/m/s), using a flexible body coil array, with parameters: FOV = 38×38 cm2,
matrix size = 192×192, slice thickness = 5 mm, flip angle = 30°,
bandwidth = 390 Hz/px, TR/TE = 10/4.8 ms, 500 dynamic acquisitions, temporal
resolution = 0.6 s, partial Fourier ratio = 5/8. An MR-compatible, single-element
OCM sensor (Imasonics, 15-mm diameter, 1 MHz) was applied to the abdomen using
surgical tape. Figure 1 shows an OCM sensor, a transducer able to provide rich
motion-related information as its non-focused beam may probe a wide section of
the abdomen. Fiberoptic temperature probes (Neoptix ReFlex) were in contact
with the OCM sensor, to detect any possible heating and prevent skin burns, but
no such heating was detected. In one of two volunteers, a Hot & Cold
compress was applied to the abdomen, in-between the flexible coil and the OCM
sensor, to create some small but detectable temperature changes. The Bayesian
learning algorithm from Ref5 was employed here to combine the streams
of OCM and MRI data. Training was limited to baseline scans, about one minute
worth of scans without temperature changes, such that all hybrid OCM-MR images
subsequently generated by the algorithm did not feature any heating-related
information, and for this reason they provided a valuable motion-matched phase
references from which the PRF effect and temperature changes could be
quantified, in moving organs.Results
Figure 2 showed
the thermometry results from a free-breathing but non-heated dataset. Both the
acquired MR image and a corresponding hybrid MR-US were shown side-by-side at
expiration (Fig. 2a) and at inspiration (Fig. 2b). The mean and standard
deviation for temperature measurements within the ROI (Fig. 2c) were plotted
from timestep theat onward (Fig. 2d). Both OCM-based and
image-based information were employed toward generating the non-heated phase
reference. Because there was no heating source in this acquisition, a
temperature elevation of 0˚C was expected, as seen in Fig. 2d. Figure 3 demonstrated
results from the second volunteer, with Hot & Cold compress. The shallow
ROI1 was closer to the compress and saw temperature changes, while ROI2 was
deeper and saw none (Fig. 3d, about 3˚C change for ROI1).Discussion and Conclusion
A new
multi-baseline free-breathing thermometry approach was introduced, based on
hybrid OCM-MR imaging. After about a minute worth of training data, the
learning Bayesian algorithm could generate matching images to any new acquired
MR image. These synthetic matching images were similar to acquired ones in all
respect, except for the fact that they did not include any heating-related
information, as only non-heated images were employed for training purposes. As
a result, these hybrid OCM-MR images provided valuable phase reference maps
from which temperature changes could be quantified. Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
[1] Ishihara, Y., et al., A precise and fast
temperature mapping using water proton chemical shift. Magn Reson Med, 1995.
34(6): p. 814-23.
[2] Rieke, V., et al., Referenceless PRF shift
thermometry. Magnetic resonance in medicine, 2004. 51(6): p. 1223-1231.
[3] Vigen, K.K., et al., Triggered, navigated,
multi-baseline method for proton resonance frequency temperature mapping with
respiratory motion. Magn Reson Med, 2003. 50(5): p. 1003-10.
[4] Grissom, W.A., et al., Hybrid referenceless and
multibaseline subtraction MR thermometry for monitoring thermal therapies in moving
organs. Medical physics, 2010. 37(9): p. 5014-5026.
[5] Preiswerk, F., et al., Hybrid MRI-Ultrasound
acquisitions, and scannerless real-time imaging. Magn Reson Med, 2016.