Xiaopeng Zhou1, Wanyong Shin1, Erik Beall1, and Mark Lowe1
1The Cleveland Clinic, Cleveland, OH, United States
Synopsis
A Multiband
version of the SimPACE sequence was developed to validate multiband SLOMOCO
motion correction method. With the increasing use of simultaneous multi-slice acquisition
techniques to acquire fMRI data more efficiently, the traditional motion
correction methods need to be modified or improved to better correct subject
motion in fMRI. This preliminary
study showed that multiband SLOMOCO can detect the outermost slice motion
better than single-slice SLOMOCO.
Multiband SimPACE is a promising sequence to further facilitate the
improvement of motion correction methods including multiband SLOMOCO.
Introduction
Although the
simultaneous multi-slice acquisition technique
1 has been applied in
fMRI to reduce the scan time, head motion is still an important factor to be
considered when fMRI data are being processed. SLOMOCO
2 was
developed and validated to correct slice-wise motion for BOLD MRI. It is novel
in that it considers the motion can be different during each slice acquired in
a volume, which overcomes the limitation of only volumetric motion being
considered with most motion correction methods.
When multiband acquisition is used in fMRI sequence, several slices are
acquired simultaneously, which means that the motion effect of these slice are
same. There is an inherent limitation of SLOMOCO in that it detects motion in the
outermost slices less accurately than inner slices
2. With a multiband
acquisition, the outermost slice is acquired together with other slices closer
to the central slice. By utilizing this fact, we expect to improve the motion detection
in the outermost slices. Therefore, a new version of SLOMOCO (multiband
SLOMOCO) was developed to correct motion in multiband acquisitions. We
hypothesized that multiband SLOMOCO method will outperform the single-slice
SLOMOCO method in detecting motion in the outermost slice.
Methods
A Multiband SimPACE sequence2
was developed to acquire BOLD data with injected motion simultaneously on multiple
slices (multiband factor=3) from two male healthy volunteers with an IRB
approved protocol on a 7T MRI scanner (MAGNETOM 7T, Siemens) using a 32-channel
phased array head coil (Nova Medical). For comparison, BOLD data were also
acquired with single-slice acquisition (multiband factor=1). 148 repetitions of
27 axial slices (slice thickness=2.5mm); TE/TR=21ms/2800ms; matrix, 96×96;
field of view, 240mm×240mm; receive bandwidth, 2604Hz/px. Motions in x,y,z translation
with the range of 0.4 mm to 1 mm were only injected to central slice (slice#14)
and outermost superior slice (slice#27) for single-slice SimPACE acquisition.
For multiband acquisition, slice#5 and 23 will have the same injected motion as
slice#14; and slice#9 and 18 will have the same injected motion as slice#27. All
the raw data were saved and reconstructed using Matlab (MATLAB R2012a, The
MathWorks Inc., Natick, MA 2012). Then the multiband and single-slice BOLD data
were corrected for motion effect with multiband and single-slice SLOMOCO
respectively.
Results
The
motion parameters obtained from one subject with single-slice (left) and
multiband (right) SLOMOCO shown in Fig.1.
There
were 6 and 7 motion events injected on central slice and outermost superior
slice separately. Multiband SLOMOCO detected all 13 motion events on both
slices, however, only the 6 motion events injected on the central slice were
detected for single-slice SLOMOCO. This
also can be see with total displacement (TD)3 (Fig.2) which is the parameter
converted from all translations and rotations.
Discussion
A Multiband version of the SimPACE sequence was
developed to validate multiband SLOMOCO motion correction method. With the
increasing use of simultaneous multi-slice acquisition techniques to acquire
fMRI data more efficiently, the traditional motion correction methods need to
be modified or improved to better correct subject motion in fMRI. Although
z-translation was not very well detected, this preliminary study showed that
multiband SLOMOCO can detect the outermost slice motion better than
single-slice SLOMOCO. Multiband SimPACE
is a promising sequence to further facilitate the improvement of motion correction
methods including multiband SLOMOCO.
Conclusion
Simple motion parameters acquired with multiband SLOMOCO were validated
with multiband SimPACE sequence. Multiband SLOMOCO performs better than
single-slice SLOMOCO in detecting outermost slice. Future work will involve
validation of a broader variety of motion.
Acknowledgements
The authors gratefully acknowledge technical support by Siemens Medical Solutions.References
1.
Feinberg D & Setsompop K. JMR 2013; 229: 90-100.
2.
Beall E & Lowe M. NeuroImage 2014;
101: 21-34.
3. Jiang
et al. Hum. Brain Mapp. 1995; 3: 224-235.