Benjamin Zahneisen1, Murat Aksoy1, Julian Maclaren1, Christian Wuerslin1, and Roland Bammer1
1Stanford University, Stanford, CA, United States
Synopsis
Geometric distortions caused by off-resonant spins are a
major issue in EPI based functional and diffusion imaging. We present a
novel approach to the problem of geometric distortions. An extension of
the model-based, algebraic hybrid-SENSE reconstruction method in combination
with a known fieldmap, calculated from blip up/down scans, allows for
correction of off-resonance effects during the reconstruction. This enables a
joint blip up/down reconstruction that significantly reduces g-factor penalty if
the blip-down trajectory is chosen to fill in missing k-space samples from the
blip-up scan. The resulting high SNR images are automatically eddy-current
corrected and geometric distortions are minimized.
Introduction
Geometric distortions caused by off-resonant spins are a major issue in EPI-based functional and diffusion imaging. Typically,
correction methods use an off-resonance map and operate as a post-processing
step on the magnitude images. A robust method to measure off-resonance maps is the blip
up/down approach, where the polarity of the 2nd readout is inverted (2). Brain regions that are compressed in the
blip-up acquisitions are stretched in the blip-down case and vice versa. From
that, FSL’s topup implementation calculates the off-resonance map.
We present a novel two-stage approach to correct for geometric
distortions that makes use of the blip up/down concept. First, we propose an extension of the model-based, algebraic
hybrid-SENSE reconstruction method (1) that allows correction for off-resonance
effects. For accelerated scans
(SMS and/or in-plane) we then employ hybrid-SENSE for a joint blip up/down reconstruction
where we choose the sampling pattern of the blip-down trajectory (Figure 4) such that it partly fills in missing k-space samples.
A joint reconstruction not only benefits from signal averaging but also from reduced g-factor
penalty because the effective acceleration factor is reduced.
Theory
Ignoring off-resonance effects
along the readout, and performing an FT along the kx domain, transforms the k-space data s0(kx,ky,kz) to an hybrid space s(x,ky,kz).
For every position x=xn we can write the signal equation (forward model) in matrix notation as s=Fm[1] with the unknown magnetization m∈CNyNx×1 and the signal vector s∈CNsNc×1 that consists of all Ns acquired ky-kz k-space samples times the number of receiver coils Nc.
The effective encoding
matrix F=C∘E∘W∘R with C,E,W,R∈CNsNc×NyNz is the Hadamard product of the individual matrices that model the encoding process
where: C=coil sensitivity variation, E=gradient
encoding fromky and kz-space, W=off-resonance effects, and R=intensity
variations.
In order to invert the
rectangular matrix F, we use a truncated singular value decomposition
approach (TSVD) (3) where eigenvalues
below a certain threshold λ are completely suppressed (Figures 1,2). The solution is then given as m=FTSVDpinvs[2]
For the joint blip
up/down reconstruction we rewrite the signal model as F↑↓=(F↑F↓)[3] where F↑ and F↓ are the effective
encoding matrices for the blip up(↑) and down(↓) trajectories.
The g-factor map is
calculated as g(xn,y,z)=diag(√FTSVDpinv(FTSVDpinv)TCCT)/√Rtot[4]
where CCT corresponds to a SENSE reconstruction with R=1.
Methods
All measurements were performed at
3T using a 32-channel head coil. Reconstructions were performed
off-line using MatLab. The “blip down”-EPI acquisition is implemented by inverting the phase encoding gradients while keeping all other parameters unchanged. The fieldmap was estimated using FSL5.0’s topup (http://fsl.fmrib.ox.ac.uk/fsl) with default parameters (4). For the joint
reconstruction we employed a MUSE-like correction for phase inconsistencies between
segments (5) and the workflow is displayed in Figure 5. The following parameters were used for blip
up/down acquisitions with varying SMS and in-plane accelerations Ry:
FOV=22x22cm,
NxxNy=128x128, CAIPI blip-factor=2;
partial Fourier=0.75, esp=0.55ms, slice thickness=2mm, TR=3s.Results
Figure 3 displays
one reconstructed multi-band group (SMS-factor=4,Ry=1) for blip-up (a) and blip-down (b). From these two the fieldmap in c is derived and used in the
off-resonance-corrected hybrid-SENSE reconstructions for blip-up (d) and -down (e). Figure 4 demonstrates the g-factor penalty
reduction for the joint reconstruction of diffusion weighted (b=2000)
acquisitions (SMS-factor=4, Ry=2).
The off-resonance corrected blip-up
reconstruction (red samples in d) is shown in a and the corresponding g-factor
map for a total acceleration factor of Rtot=8 is displayed in c. Sum-of-squares
combination of separate blip-up and -down reconstructions is displayed in b.
Sum-of-squares combination does not affect the g-factor map from c. The joint blip up/down
reconstruction (red and blue samples
in d) in e has higher SNR than blip-up or sum-of-squares-combination. The
corresponding g-factor map for Rtot=4 is shown in f.Discussion
Modelling
off-resonances in an algebraic reconstruction framework results in images with
significantly reduced geometric distortions. We have shown that regularization
is important for regions where local off-resonance gradients oppose the
gradients from k-space encoding (Figure 2). Acquiring blip-up/down scans for
each diffusion direction allows for highly accurate estimation of dynamic off-resonances
and eddy-current contributions. The longer scan time is more than compensated
by the SNR increase due to averaging, the g-factor penalty reduction and the improved image quality. Acknowledgements
NIH (2R01 EB002711 , 5R01 EB008706, 5R01 EB011654), the Center of Advanced MR Technology at Stanford (P41 RR009784), Lucas Foundation.
References
1. Andersson JLR, Skare S, Ashburner J. How to correct
susceptibility distortions in spin-echo echo-planar images: application to
diffusion tensor imaging. Neuroimage [Internet] 2003;20:870–888. doi:
10.1016/S1053-8119(03)00336-7.
2. Zhu K, Dougherty R, Wu H, Middione M, Takahashi A, Zhang
T, Pauly J, Kerr A. Hybrid-Space SENSE Reconstruction for Simultaneous
Multi-Slice MRI. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging [Internet] 2016. doi:
10.1109/TMI.2016.2531635.
3. Hansen PC. Truncated Singular Value Decomposition
Solutions to Discrete Ill-Posed Problems with Ill-Determined Numerical Rank.
SIAM J. Sci. Stat. Comput. [Internet] 1990;11:503–518. doi: 10.1137/0911028.
4. Smith SM, Jenkinson M, Woolrich MW, et al. Advances in
functional and structural MR image analysis and implementation as FSL.
Neuroimage 2004;23 Suppl 1:S208-19. doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2004.07.051.
5. Chen N-K, Guidon A, Chang H-C, Song AW. A robust
multi-shot scan strategy for high-resolution diffusion weighted MRI enabled by
multiplexed sensitivity-encoding (MUSE). Neuroimage [Internet] 2013;72:41–7.
doi: 10.1016/j.neuroimage.2013.01.038.