Linqing Li1, Christine Law2, Karla Miller3, and Peter Jezzard3
1National Institute of Mental Health, National Institute of Health, Rockville, MD, United States, 2Systems Neuroscience and Pain Lab, Stanford University, CA, United States, 3Nuffield Department of Clinical Neurosciences, FMRIB Centre, University of Oxford, Oxford, United Kingdom
Synopsis
To assess
whether DANTE-EPI (Delay Alternating with Nutation for Tailored
Excitation) sequence
for moving blood suppressed fMRI images can effectively reduce inflow effects
and, physiological noise originating from intravascular blood signal, and spurious
(false positive) functional activation resulting from draining vein effects.
Results were compared with images from conventional
gradient echo planar imaging (GE-EPI).
Introduction:
Localization and identification of neural
activity detected via the blood-oxygen-level dependent (BOLD) effect with conventional
GE-EPI can be severely compromised due to intravascular blood flow effects (in
both arteries and veins), especially at 1.5 T and 3T. Previous
studies blood flow in capillary beds of
rat brain suggest that the transit flow rate of blood between vascular
(arterioles and venules) and the cortical capillary bed is about 2-3 mm/sec[1].
DANTE is a novel magnetization preparation method[2]
that allows selective suppression of signals from moving blood (or cerebral
spinal fluid CSF) travelling with speeds greater than 2-3 mm/sec,
illustrated in Fig. 1a. Previous
studies suggested that DANTE preparation pulse trains in conjunction with an EPI
imaging readout module should reduce contamination from large-vessel intravascular blood without
significantly influencing the resulting signals derived from the parenchyma and
capillary bed. In this work, we demonstrate that three major contaminants from macro-vascular
blood, namely inflow effects, physiological noise, and draining vein effects,
can be effectively diminished using DANTE-EPI compared with results from
conventional GE-EPI, allowing improved localization of neural
activity.Methods:
Ten healthy
volunteers (6 males, 4 females, age 24-35 years), with written informed
consent, underwent fMRI scans. DANTE-EPI sequence was illustrated in Fig. 1b
and Fig.1c. All
scans were acquired using a 3T
Siemens Verio scanner
and a 32-channel head coil. EPI parameters
for all scans were: TR=2s, TE=31ms, GRAPPA=2, BW=1086 Hz/Px, FOV= 220 mm, resolution:
2.3´2.3 mm
(96´96),
thk=4mm, with 20% gap. Two 5 mins 19-slice series of resting state fMRI images were
acquired using GE-EPI and DANTE-EPI techniques, respectively. Temporal standard
deviation (tSTD) maps were calculated from the resting state data, and overlaid
on high-resolution T1 images for comparisons. An additional 5.5 mins 11-slice task-related
protocol was carried out, using a right-hand finger-tapping task (1 Hz) with 30s
ON-OFF blocks. DANTE parameters for the resting-state acquisition were: number
of pulses (Np) 44 for each DANTE preparion duration 22 ms; inter-pulse delay
(td) 0.5-0.7 ms; flip angle (FA) 6°; for
the task-based sequence FA=3°
and Np=212 was used for
each DANTE preparion duration 106 ms. Results:
Bloch
simulations of the 19-slice protocol are shown in Fig. 2, demonstrating the transient
longitudinal magnetization evolution of moving blood, CSF and static gray
matter tissue at the start of the DANTE preparation.
1. Elimination of in-flow effect: To demonstrate mitigation of in-flow effects when DANTE pulses are
applied, high resolution (0.3´0.3mm) time-of-flight (TOF) data were acquired,
as shown in Fig. 3a, showing hyper-intense arterial signals due to a strong
in-flow effect, which is greatly reduced with DANTE preparation, as shown in
Fig. 3b. In addition, sagittal images reconstructed from multi-slice GE-EPI and
DANTE-EPI are shown in Figs. 3c and 3d. It can be visually observed that blood
signal in the sagittal sinus is largely suppressed in DANTE-EPI image.
2. Temporal
standard deviation maps calculated from the GE-EPI and DANTE-EPI resting state
data, and arising mainly from cardio-respiratory physiological motion of CSF
and blood, are shown in Fig. 4. The relative color scale represents the
detected physiological noise. Significant signal suppression of moving blood
and CSF physiological fluctuations is observed in the images from the DANTE-prepared
EPI sequence.
3. Removal
of draining vein effects: The extent of spurious activations in the sagittal
sinus vein, shown in Fig. 5a from GE-EPI, is substantially diminished in images
from the DANTE-EPI scans, in Fig. 5c, suggesting considerable improvement in
identifying the true activation region. In terms of BOLD sensitivity, it shows that
activation regions from DANTE-EPI data, in Fig. 5c appear to have comparable
sensitivity when compared with Fig.5b, which was the same data with Fig. 5a but
with increased minimal z-stat for filtering out the fake positive activation at
sinus vein.Conclusion:
Detection
of relevant cortical activation with DANTE-EPI techniques appears to be more
closely localized to the microvasculature and the associated tissue bed,
compared with the GE-EPI technique. Therefore, adoption of DANTE-EPI may be helpful in improving
the localization of neural activity in fMRI studies.Acknowledgements
This
work was supported by the British Heart Foundation, UK, the Dunhill Medical
Trust.References
1. Ivanov, K. P., M. K. Kalinina, and
Yu I. Levkovich. "Blood flow velocity in capillaries of brain and muscles
and its physiological significance." Microvascular research 22, no. 2
(1981): 143-155.
2. Li, Linqing, Karla L. Miller, and
Peter Jezzard. "DANTE prepared pulse trains: A novel approach to motion sensitized
and motion suppressed quantitative magnetic resonance imaging." Magnetic
resonance in medicine 68, no. 5 (2012): 1423-1438.