Over the past few
decades, the use of ex vivo MRI has become widespread. This phenomenon was
largely driven by the early development of various mammalian ‘brain atlases’ for
neuroscientific applications as well as the need to characterize metabolism and
other pathways in cells, isolated organs and cancer models. These developments included
pioneering work that resulted in the creation of the first public, 3D, ex vivo
atlases of the mouse (Benveniste et al. 2000, Dhenain et al. 2001, MacKenzie-Graham et al. 2003, Zhang et al. 2006)
and rat brain (Veraart et al. 2011)
for neuroscientific and translational applications (Benveniste et al. 2002). Moreover, these studies were
the antecedents of recent big-data projects such as the Allen Brain Atlas (Lein et al. 2007)
and the Mouse Connectome project (Oh et al. 2014).
In other landmark studies, ex vivo MRI was employed to interrogate the
biophysics of various cell types (Aguayo et al. 1986, Ackerstaff et al.
2001),
isolated organs and solid tumors (Aguayo et al. 1987, Chatham et al. 1991)
under a range of physiological conditions using an array of preclinical disease models. Collectively,
these early studies set the stage for more unconventional applications of ex
vivo MRI. Recent advances in MRI hardware, RF coil design, pulse sequence
design (Badea et al. 2012), image processing and
visualization software (Walter et al. 2010), the availability of complementary
modalities such as optical and micro-CT imaging (Kim et
al. 2012), and more affordable
computational power have driven a slew of new applications of ex vivo MRI. Therefore,
recent applications of ex vivo MRI that are ‘off the beaten path’, or ‘beyond
rodents’ are the focus of this lecture.
For
example, Deng et al elegantly demonstrated how the integration of imaging data and
computational modeling could facilitate the development of more accurate models
of infarct-related arrhythmic circuits (Deng et al. 2015). In this study, the authors developed
computer models based on ex vivo MRI images of pig hearts with ischemic
cardiomyopathy and showed that they could predict and analyze ventricular
tachycardia resulting from a specific infarct architecture. In the future, such
image-based models could assist in clinical decision making and ablating reentrant
cardiac pathways. Another example of this integrated modeling and imaging
paradigm comes from the work of Huang et al in which ex vivo MRI data of
coronary plaques from patients were used to construct 3D fluid-structure
interaction computational models (Huang et al. 2014).
These models were used to investigate the association between plaque wall
stress and coronary artery disease (CAD). They found that plaques from patients
who died from CAD were associated with higher critical plaque wall stress
compared to patients who died from non-CAD causes.
Another
application of ‘mesoscopic’ or intermediate resolution ex vivo MRI is its utility
as an ‘integrator’ or ‘bridge’ modality between imaging data acquired at the
macroscopic and microscopic spatial scales. Recently, Cebulla et al demonstrated
the feasibility of 'multiscale' angiogenesis imaging in a human breast cancer
model, wherein they bridged the resolution gap between ex vivo micro-CT and in
vivo MRI using intermediate resolution ex vivo MRI (Cebulla et al. 2014). They showed the feasibility
of creating co-registered maps of vascular volume from three independent
imaging modalities, and were also able to visualize differences in tumor
vasculature between viable and necrotic tumor regions by integrating micro-CT
vascular data with tumor cellularity data obtained using diffusion-weighted
MRI.
Ex
vivo MRI is particularly useful for correlating post-mortem human tissue
samples with histopathology. This is an especially powerful paradigm for characterizing
rare disorders or disorders for which high-quality in vivo imaging data are
scarce. One recent example employed ex vivo MRI to characterize ischemic
cavities in the cerebella of ageing subjects (De Cocker et al. 2014). Histopathological
correlation allowed them to classify these cavities more accurately and gain
insight into the imaging characteristics of these cavities so that in the
future they can use this information to reliably identify patients with subtle
manifestations of cerebrovascular disease in the cerebellum. Another area where
ex vivo MRI can play a crucial role is in the imaging of small structures that
change rapidly over time. An elegant example of this comes from Wang et al, in
which they used ex vivo MRI to obtain high-quality images of the detailed local
neuroanatomy in early fetal stages because the fetal brain is very small with a
complex architecture that rapidly changes during brain development (Wang et al. 2015). They were able to identify
the four-layer-structure within the fetal cerebral wall as early as 10
gestational weeks, and five to six layers during the early second trimester.
More recently, several studies have harnessed the strengths of high-resolution
ex vivo diffusion tensor imaging to map the 3D complexity of the white matter
fiber architecture in the human brain. These studies include the human
cerebellum (Dell'Acqua et al. 2013), brainstem (Aggarwal et al. 2013) and cortex (Aggarwal et al. 2015).
A
recent study demonstrated the utility of ex vivo MRI as a potential new
clinical tool for breast cancer detection (Agresti et al. 2013).
In this study, ex vivo MRI of resected breast lesions was conducted and helped
detect malignant tumors within several of the surgical specimens. This helped
physicians verify that the initial tumor excision was successful and that the
disease was contained in the surgical specimen. It also demonstrated that conventional
imaging underestimated the extent of certain breast tumor subtypes. Collectively, these data demonstrate that ex
vivo MRI helps with tumor staging and ensures free margins of resection, while
simultaneously helping to avoid surgical re-excisions and additional unplanned
surgery. Luciani et al conducted ex vivo MRI on excised axillary lymph nodes
from breast cancer patients (Luciani et al. 2009).
They were able to precisely correlate findings from conventional imaging and
pathology, as well as identify nodal features that were suggestive of
metastatic involvement. Orczyk et al used ex vivo MRI to quantify alterations
in the prostate resulting from surgical excision (Orczyk et al. 2014).
They systematically compared in vivo and ex vivo MRI data from unfixed freshly
excised specimens and found that the observed prostate volume was significantly
smaller on ex vivo MRI than in vivo MRI. This was likely due to loss of
vascularity and connective tissue following excision. Moreover, these findings have
profound implications for clinical co-registration systems that are currently
in development for pathological validation and patient follow up (Goubran et al. 2015).
Along similar lines, ex vivo MRI was recently used to generate 3D models of
brains and then rapid prototype 3D brain holders (Guy et al. 2016).
These customized 3D-printed brain holders maintained brain positioning between
ultra-high resolution MRI and tissue cutting for histology. The preservation of
brain position enabled accurate comparisons between ex vivo MRI and histology
as well as to in vivo MRI. Finally, in another ‘beyond rodent’ application Xiao
et al used ex vivo MRI to monitor the stability and healing of lumbar
intervertebral disc transplants in goats (Xiao et al. 2015).
Post-mortem images demonstrated that the disc allograft had united well with
the host vertebral bones and was still hydrous at 3-month follow-up.
To
summarize, while ‘traditional’ applications of ex vivo MRI for the development
of mammalian brain atlases (e.g. marmosets, squirrels etc.) continue , unconventional applications
ranging from image-based modeling, to multiscale imaging, clinical
applications, rapid protoyping and transplantation also continue to be
developed. Collectively, these advances herald an exciting new era for ex vivo
imaging unlimited by the traditional constraints of hardware and software. More
importantly, ex vivo imaging is slowly beginning to inform the clinical
workflow for patients with different types of cancer, and other debilitating
disorders.
References
Ackerstaff, E., B. R. Pflug, J. B. Nelson and Z. M.
Bhujwalla (2001). "Detection of increased choline compounds with proton
nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy subsequent to malignant transformation
of human prostatic epithelial cells." Cancer Res 61(9): 3599-3603.
Aggarwal, M., D. W. Nauen, J. C. Troncoso and S. Mori
(2015). "Probing region-specific microstructure of human cortical areas
using high angular and spatial resolution diffusion MRI." Neuroimage
105: 198-207.
Aggarwal, M., J. Zhang, O. Pletnikova, B. Crain, J.
Troncoso and S. Mori (2013). "Feasibility of creating a high-resolution 3D
diffusion tensor imaging based atlas of the human brainstem: a case study at
11.7 T." Neuroimage 74:
117-127.
Agresti, R., G. Trecate, C. Ferraris, B. Valeri, I.
Maugeri, C. Pellitteri, G. Martelli, S. Migliavacca, M. L. Carcangiu, S. Bohm,
L. Maffioli, D. Vergnaghi and P. Panizza (2013). "Ex vivo MRI evaluation
of breast tumors: a novel tool for verifying resection of nonpalpable only MRI
detected lesions." Breast J 19(6):
659-663.
Aguayo, J. B., S. J. Blackband, J. Schoeniger, M. A.
Mattingly and M. Hintermann (1986). "Nuclear magnetic resonance imaging of
a single cell." Nature 322(6075):
190-191.
Aguayo, J. B., S. J. Blackband, J. P. Wehrle, J. D.
Glickson and M. A. Mattingly (1987). "NMR microscopic studies of eyes and
tumors with histological correlation." Ann N Y Acad Sci 508: 399-413.
Badea, A. and G. A. Johnson (2012). "Magnetic
resonance microscopy." Anal Cell Pathol (Amst) 35(4): 205-227.
Benveniste, H. and S. Blackband (2002). "MR
microscopy and high resolution small animal MRI: applications in neuroscience
research." Prog Neurobiol 67(5):
393-420.
Benveniste, H., K. Kim, L. Zhang and G. A. Johnson
(2000). "Magnetic resonance microscopy of the C57BL mouse brain." Neuroimage
11(6 Pt 1): 601-611.
Cebulla, J., E. Kim, K. Rhie, J. Zhang and A. P.
Pathak (2014). "Multiscale and multi-modality visualization of
angiogenesis in a human breast cancer model." Angiogenesis 17(3): 695-709.
Chatham, J. C., S. Ackerman and S. J. Blackband
(1991). "High-resolution 1H NMR imaging of regional ischemia in the
isolated perfused rabbit heart at 4.7 T." Magn Reson Med 21(1): 144-150.
De Cocker, L. J., S. J. van Veluw, G. J. Biessels, W.
G. Spliet, I. E. Thunnissen, P. R. Luijten, J. Hendrikse and J. J. Zwanenburg
(2014). "Ischaemic cavities in the cerebellum: an ex vivo 7-tesla MRI
study with pathological correlation." Cerebrovasc Dis 38(1): 17-23.
Dell'Acqua, F., I. Bodi, D. Slater, M. Catani and M.
Modo (2013). "MR diffusion histology and micro-tractography reveal
mesoscale features of the human cerebellum." Cerebellum 12(6): 923-931.
Deng, D., H. Arevalo, F. Pashakhanloo, A. Prakosa, H.
Ashikaga, E. McVeigh, H. Halperin and N. Trayanova (2015). "Accuracy of
prediction of infarct-related arrhythmic circuits from image-based models
reconstructed from low and high resolution MRI." Front Physiol 6: 282.
Dhenain, M., S. W. Ruffins and R. E. Jacobs (2001).
"Three-dimensional digital mouse atlas using high-resolution MRI." Dev
Biol 232(2): 458-470.
Goubran, M., S. de Ribaupierre, R. R. Hammond, C.
Currie, J. G. Burneo, A. G. Parrent, T. M. Peters and A. R. Khan (2015).
"Registration of in-vivo to ex-vivo MRI of surgically resected specimens:
a pipeline for histology to in-vivo registration." J Neurosci Methods
241: 53-65.
Guy, J. R., P. Sati, E. Leibovitch, S. Jacobson, A.
C. Silva and D. S. Reich (2016). "Custom fit 3D-printed brain holders for
comparison of histology with MRI in marmosets." J Neurosci Methods 257: 55-63.
Huang, X., C. Yang, J. Zheng, R. Bach, D.
Muccigrosso, P. K. Woodard and D. Tang (2014). "Higher critical plaque
wall stress in patients who died of coronary artery disease compared with those
who died of other causes: a 3D FSI study based on ex vivo MRI of coronary
plaques." J Biomech 47(2):
432-437.
Kim, E., S. Stamatelos, J. Cebulla, Z. M. Bhujwalla,
A. S. Popel and A. P. Pathak (2012). "Multiscale imaging and computational
modeling of blood flow in the tumor vasculature." Ann Biomed Eng 40(11): 2425-2441.
Lein, E. S., M. J. Hawrylycz, N. Ao, M. Ayres, A.
Bensinger, A. Bernard, A. F. Boe, M. S. Boguski, K. S. Brockway, E. J. Byrnes,
L. Chen, L. Chen, T. M. Chen, M. C. Chin, J. Chong, B. E. Crook, A. Czaplinska,
C. N. Dang, S. Datta, N. R. Dee, A. L. Desaki, T. Desta, E. Diep, T. A.
Dolbeare, M. J. Donelan, H. W. Dong, J. G. Dougherty, B. J. Duncan, A. J.
Ebbert, G. Eichele, L. K. Estin, C. Faber, B. A. Facer, R. Fields, S. R.
Fischer, T. P. Fliss, C. Frensley, S. N. Gates, K. J. Glattfelder, K. R.
Halverson, M. R. Hart, J. G. Hohmann, M. P. Howell, D. P. Jeung, R. A. Johnson,
P. T. Karr, R. Kawal, J. M. Kidney, R. H. Knapik, C. L. Kuan, J. H. Lake, A. R.
Laramee, K. D. Larsen, C. Lau, T. A. Lemon, A. J. Liang, Y. Liu, L. T. Luong,
J. Michaels, J. J. Morgan, R. J. Morgan, M. T. Mortrud, N. F. Mosqueda, L. L.
Ng, R. Ng, G. J. Orta, C. C. Overly, T. H. Pak, S. E. Parry, S. D. Pathak, O.
C. Pearson, R. B. Puchalski, Z. L. Riley, H. R. Rockett, S. A. Rowland, J. J.
Royall, M. J. Ruiz, N. R. Sarno, K. Schaffnit, N. V. Shapovalova, T. Sivisay,
C. R. Slaughterbeck, S. C. Smith, K. A. Smith, B. I. Smith, A. J. Sodt, N. N.
Stewart, K. R. Stumpf, S. M. Sunkin, M. Sutram, A. Tam, C. D. Teemer, C.
Thaller, C. L. Thompson, L. R. Varnam, A. Visel, R. M. Whitlock, P. E.
Wohnoutka, C. K. Wolkey, V. Y. Wong, M. Wood, M. B. Yaylaoglu, R. C. Young, B.
L. Youngstrom, X. F. Yuan, B. Zhang, T. A. Zwingman and A. R. Jones (2007).
"Genome-wide atlas of gene expression in the adult mouse brain." Nature
445(7124): 168-176.
Luciani, A., F. Pigneur, F. Ghozali, T. H. Dao, P.
Cunin, E. Meyblum, C. De Baecque-Fontaine, A. Alamdari, P. Maison, J. F. Deux,
J. L. Lagrange, L. Lantieri and A. Rahmouni (2009). "Ex vivo MRI of
axillary lymph nodes in breast cancer." Eur J Radiol 69(1): 59-66.
MacKenzie-Graham, A., E. S. Jones, D. W. Shattuck, I.
D. Dinov, M. Bota and A. W. Toga (2003). "The informatics of a C57BL/6J mouse
brain atlas." Neuroinformatics 1(4):
397-410.
Oh, S. W., J. A. Harris, L. Ng, B. Winslow, N. Cain,
S. Mihalas, Q. Wang, C. Lau, L. Kuan, A. M. Henry, M. T. Mortrud, B. Ouellette,
T. N. Nguyen, S. A. Sorensen, C. R. Slaughterbeck, W. Wakeman, Y. Li, D. Feng,
A. Ho, E. Nicholas, K. E. Hirokawa, P. Bohn, K. M. Joines, H. Peng, M. J.
Hawrylycz, J. W. Phillips, J. G. Hohmann, P. Wohnoutka, C. R. Gerfen, C. Koch,
A. Bernard, C. Dang, A. R. Jones and H. Zeng (2014). "A mesoscale
connectome of the mouse brain." Nature 508(7495): 207-214.
Orczyk, C., S. S. Taneja, H. Rusinek and A. B.
Rosenkrantz (2014). "Assessment of change in prostate volume and shape
following surgical resection through co-registration of in-vivo MRI and fresh
specimen ex-vivo MRI." Clin Radiol 69(10): e398-403.
Veraart, J., T. B. Leergaard, B. T. Antonsen, W. Van
Hecke, I. Blockx, B. Jeurissen, Y. Jiang, A. Van der Linden, G. A. Johnson, M.
Verhoye and J. Sijbers (2011). "Population-averaged diffusion tensor
imaging atlas of the Sprague Dawley rat brain." Neuroimage 58(4): 975-983.
Walter, T., D. W. Shattuck, R. Baldock, M. E. Bastin,
A. E. Carpenter, S. Duce, J. Ellenberg, A. Fraser, N. Hamilton, S. Pieper, M.
A. Ragan, J. E. Schneider, P. Tomancak and J. K. Heriche (2010).
"Visualization of image data from cells to organisms." Nat Methods
7(3 Suppl): S26-41.
Wang, R., G. Dai and E. Takahashi (2015). "High
Resolution MRI Reveals Detailed Layer Structures in Early Human Fetal Stages:
In Vitro Study with Histologic Correlation." Front Neuroanat 9: 150.
Xiao, J., Y. C. Huang, S. K. Lam and K. D. Luk
(2015). "Surgical technique for lumbar intervertebral disc transplantation
in a goat model." Eur Spine J 24(9):
1951-1958.
Zhang, J., L. J. Richards, M. I. Miller, P. Yarowsky,
P. van Zijl and S. Mori (2006). "Characterization of mouse brain and its
development using diffusion tensor imaging and computational techniques." Conf
Proc IEEE Eng Med Biol Soc 1:
2252-2255.