Synopsis
Magnetic
resonance spectroscopy (MRS)1-4 is a method for non-invasively probing
metabolism. In the heart, phosphorus 31P MRS has proved particularly
valuable because it probes the creatine-kinase system which buffers and
actively transports ATP from its site of generation in the mitochondria to its
site of utilisation in the myofibrils, where it drives contractile work, pumps
blood around the body, and sustains life. In most heart diseases, the
concentrations and/or the rates of interconversion of 31P
metabolites are altered. Spectroscopy benefits from ultra-high fields in two
main ways: (i) the signal-to-noise ratio for a fixed scan time increases
approximately proportional to B0; and (ii) the frequency separation
between the peaks from different metabolites increases proportional to B0
which makes robust spectral fitting easier. This session reviews the first
human cardiac spectroscopy studies at 7T.Overview
Magnetic
resonance spectroscopy (MRS)1-4 is a method for non-invasively probing
metabolism. In the heart, phosphorus 31P MRS has proved particularly
valuable because it probes the creatine-kinase system which buffers and
actively transports ATP from its site of generation in the mitochondria to its
site of utilisation in the myofibrils, where it drives contractile work, pumps
blood around the body, and sustains life. In most heart diseases, the
concentrations and/or the rates of interconversion of 31P
metabolites are altered. Spectroscopy benefits from ultra-high fields in two
main ways: (i) the signal-to-noise ratio for a fixed scan time increases
approximately proportional to B0; and (ii) the frequency separation
between the peaks from different metabolites increases proportional to B0
which makes robust spectral fitting easier. This session reviews the first
human cardiac spectroscopy studies at 7T.
The creatine-kinase shuttle
The human
heart consumes 6kg of adenosine triphosphate (ATP) per day as the primary fuel
driving contraction of the cardiac myocytes (muscle cells). As the heart beats,
it turns chemical energy (ATP) into mechanical (pV) work pumping blood around
the body, which is essential to life.
Cardiac myocytes take up glucose, free fatty acids and ketone bodies,
using them to synthesise ATP in the mitochondria. The CK energy shuttle buffers
and transports ATP to the myofibrils, in the form of phosphocreatine (PCr), to
power contraction of the sarcomeres. The CK reaction at the myofibrils is:5
MgADP¯+ PCr2¯ + H+ ⇌
MgATP2¯ + Cr,
and the reverse reaction dominates in the
mitochondria. In animal models, magnetic resonance spectroscopy (MRS) methods
have measured: [PCr2¯] and [MgATP2¯] (or their ratio);
intracellular [Mg2+]; the effective first order rate constant kf
= k1 [MgADP¯][H+]; and the flux of MgATP2¯.
[MgADP¯] can be computed by also measuring pH and [Cr], and knowing K=1.66 nM-1.
∆G~ATP for ATP hydrolysis in the myofibrils (ATP + H2O →
ADP + Pi) can be computed from [Pi]. ∆G~ATP
measures the power available to a myocyte. Together these processes are termed
“high-energy phosphate” (HEP) metabolism.7 HEP metabolism is deranged in: heart failure,
ischaemia, cardiomyopathies, myocardial infarction (MI), and in systemic
diseases such as diabetes and obesity.6
31P-MRS at 7T
Since
the first-in-man 31P-MRS experiments in 1985,8 many labs have translated the successes of
animal 31P-MRS to human studies. However, 31P-MRS
applications in humans have always been limited by the low intrinsic
signal-to-noise of 31P-MRS scans compared to 1H MRI. Spectroscopy
benefits from using stronger field MRI scanners in two main ways: (i) the
signal-to-noise ratio for a fixed scan time increases approximately
proportional to B0; and (ii) the frequency separation between the
peaks from different metabolites increases proportional to B0 which
makes robust spectral fitting easier. This session reviews the first human cardiac
spectroscopy studies at 7T.
Normal volunteers
In
2013, we performed the first cardiac 7T 31P-MRS scans in a study on
9 volunteers. We observed a 2.8x increase in signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) at 7T compared
to 3T.9 We also obtained the T1 relaxation
times of the key 31P metabolites.
Cardiac patient study at 7T
Recently,
we completed a study comparing the performance of 31P-MRS at 3T and
7T in 25 patients with dilated cardiomyopathy.10 This was the first cardiac patient study at 7T
in Oxford. We observed a 2.6x increase in phosphocreatine signal-to-noise ratio
at 7T compared to 3T. Intriguingly, while we saw the expected reduction in
standard deviation of PCR/ATP in control subjects from 3T to 7T, in the DCM
cohort we saw very little reduction in the PCr/ATP standard deviation. Our
study was not large enough for this difference to be statistically significant,
but it suggests that cardiac 31P-MRS at 7T may be approaching the
level of SNR where inter-subject biological variation becomes visible.
Meander coil
Cardiac
31P spectra are often contaminated by signals from overlying skeletal
muscle, which has ~2x greater PCr:ATP ratio than myocardium and different
creatine-kinase kinetics. Traditionally, skeletal muscle signal is suppressed
with additional radiofrequency pulses. However, at 7T, this is undesirable
because we have limited radiofrequency power. Instead, we constructed a local B0-spoiling
gradient insert coil. We demonstrated the ability to de-phase 31P
signals arising from overlying skeletal muscle with minimal effects on cardiac 31P
spectra in normal volunteers in vivo.11
Bloch-Siegert field mapping
It
is often necessary to know the B1+ in the heart in vivo to set appropriate pulse
voltages or during post-processing. Existing methods (e.g. the dual-angle, or
dual-TR method) are not well suited to 31P-MRS in the heart at 7T.
We adapted the Bloch-Siegert method for flip angle measurement for use in 31P
spectroscopy and found that it is an attractive approach for 31P-MRS
B1-mapping.12
Saturation transfer
We implemented cardiac 31P saturation transfer at
7T, and validated our method by measuring the creatine-kinase (CK) rate
constant kf in calf muscle and in the mid-interventricular septum of
10 normal volunteers. The 2.8x higher signal-to-noise of 31P-MRS at
7T allows us to make 3D-resolved kf measurements in the human heart in vivo.13
Improved RF transmission using a quadrature coil at 7T
Our current standard RF coil for 7T 31P-MRS
studies is an array with 16 receive elements and a single 28x28cm2
transmit element (Rapid Biomedical, Germany). This coil has the best receive performance
of our coils in Oxford, but it gives a comparatively low peak transmit field
strength in the heart.14
To overcome the limitation of low transmit field strength,
we optimised a cardiac quadrature surface coil design by EM simulations. We
have now built this coil, performed RF safety tests, and used it to obtain
spectra from the anterior and inferior interventricular septum in the human
heart. In vivo, the coil gives much higher transmit field strength in the
anterior and mid regions of the heart compared to the 16-element array, but it
has a lower receive sensitivity because it uses the two 15cm diameter loops for
both transmit and receive.15
We have now also implemented an adiabatic
half-passage excitation pulse (made possible by the increased transmit field
strength from the quadrature coil) and used this to scan the hearts of 12
subjects. This proof-of-concept study shows the feasibility of adiabatic
excitation in the anterior and mid-septal regions of the heart at 7T, which is
a key step towards making absolute concentration measurements of metabolites,
i.e. in mmol per kg wet weight tissue.16
Other groups
Whole-body RF transmit
Prof Klomp’s group at UMC Utrecht have recently demonstrated
a 31P whole-body RF birdcage coil. The 5 minute CSI spectroscopy
dataset presented in their paper shows that this coil has much more uniform B1+
and receive sensitivity than the surface coils we have used for our studies to
date. The wider availability of whole-body transmit coils for 31P-MRS
will significantly enhance the opportunities for studying cardiac disease by 31P-MRS
at 7T.
B0-shimming using 1H GRE field maps
In a collaborative study with Prof Vaughan at CMRR,
University of Minnesota, we tested the impact on cardiac 31P-MRS of per-subject
B0 shimming using a 16-element 1H coil for shimming and then
swapping to our 16-element 31P coil. B0 shimming reduced
the linewidth of the 31P spectra and in some subjects allowed us to
resolve spectra from the inferior segments of the heart.17
Four channel cardiac 31P-MRS coil
Lu et al. from Auburn University presented bench
and phantom results from a four-channel 7T cardiac 31P-MRS coil at
ISMRM2013.18
Other nuclei
Cardiac
1H MRS19 has been used successfully e.g. to quantify the
fat fraction in the myocardium at 3T20, or to measure the total creatine concentration
at 1.5T21. However, it is not straightforward to adapt
these single voxel spectroscopy PRESS and STEAM methods for use in the heart at
7T because of the challenge of achieving sufficiently uniform and strong RF
transmit (B1+) fields in the heart, and because PRESS and
STEAM cause significant RF heating (SAR) at 7T. Nevertheless, there is clear
potential for cardiac 1H-MRS at 7T e.g. it may become possible to
distinguish the 1H creatine (Cr) and phosphocreatine (PCr)
resonances at 7T, instead of only measuring “total creatine” (tCr = Cr + PCr).
Acknowledgements
CTR
is funded by a Sir Henry Dale Fellowship from the Wellcome Trust and the Royal
Society [098436/Z/12/Z]. I thank my colleagues at OCMR and FMRIB for helpful
discussions and their enthusiasm for developing new methods at 7T.References
1 De Graaf, RA. In vivo NMR spectroscopy: principles and techniques. 2nd edn, (John Wiley & Sons, 2007).
2 Bottomley, PA.
in Encyclopedia of Magnetic Resonance (eds R. K. Harris & R. E.
Wasylishen) (John Wiley, 2009).
3 Levitt, MH. Spin dynamics : basics of nuclear magnetic
resonance. 2nd edn, (John Wiley
& Sons, 2008).
4 Ernst, RR,
Bodenhausen, G & Wokaun, A. Principles
of nuclear magnetic resonance in one and two dimensions. (Clarendon Press, 1987).
5 Wallimann, T,
Wyss, M, Brdiczka, D, Nicolay, K & Eppenberger, HM. Biochem. J. 281 ( Pt 1),
(1992).
6 Neubauer, S. N. Engl. J. Med. 356, (2007).
7 Ingwall, JS. Cardiovasc. Res. 81, (2009).
8 Bottomley, PA. Science 229, (1985).
9 Rodgers, CT et al. Magn. Reson. Med. 72,
(2014).
10 Stoll, VM et al. Radiology, (In Press (2016).).
11 Schaller, B,
Clarke, WT, Neubauer, S, Robson, MD & Rodgers, CT. Magn. Reson. Med. 75,
(2016).
12 Clarke, WT,
Robson, MD & Rodgers, CT. Magn.
Reson. Med., (2015).
13 Clarke, WT,
Robson, MD & Rodgers, CT. in ISMRM2016 (2016).
14 Rodgers, CT,
Clarke, W, Berthel, D, Neubauer, S & Robson, M. in ISMRM (Milan, 2014).
15 Schaller, B,
Paritmongkol, W, Magill, A, Robson, MD & Rodgers, CT. in ISMRM2016.
16 Valkovic, L et al. in ISMRM2016 (2016).
17 DelaBarre, L,
Neubauer, S, Robson, MD, Vaughan, JT & Rodgers, CT. in ISMRM2015 (2015).
18 Lu, H et al. in ISMRM2013.
19 Faller, KE,
Lygate, C, Neubauer, S & Schneider, J. Heart
Fail Rev, (2012).
20 Rial, B, Robson,
MD, Neubauer, S & Schneider, JE. Magn.
Reson. Med. 66, (2011).
21 Bottomley, PA
& Weiss, RG. Lancet 351, (1998).