Katherine Binzel1, Robert Magnussen2, Christopher Kaeding2, David C Flanigan2, Wenbo Wei1, Melanie U Knopp3, and Michael V Knopp1
1Radiology, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States, 2Sports Medicine, The Ohio State University, Columbus, OH, United States, 3Sports Medicine, Pepperdine University, Malibu, CA, United States
Synopsis
Evaluation of
ACL graft healing by combined PET/MR imaging is readily feasible but has
limited quantitative accuracy with use of conventional PET systems. The
application of next generation digital photon counting in PET improves the
quantitative accuracy and precision of assessment of graft metabolic activity.
This advanced imaging modality also holds potential for ultra-low dose PET
imaging, enhancing the clinical utility of such a combined imaging approach for
detailed assessment of ACL graft viability after reconstructive surgery.Purpose
Injury to the anterior cruciate ligament (ACL)
commonly requires surgical placement of a graft in order to restore function to
the knee1. Graft healing is not well delineated by MRI alone2. Therefore a
combined MRI and molecular imaging approach may serve to better evaluate the
process of healing and rehabilitation management, as well as the decision
process to return to sports or athletic activities. Combined conventional
PET/MR has proven feasible for assessment of ACL graft healing following surgery
using conventional imaging systems. We aimed to further evaluate this process
by employing next generation digital photon counting, time of flight PET (dPET)
combined with digital coil MR for imaging and quantification of ACL-graft
metabolic activity.
Methods
10 patients had same day MRI on a 3T Ingenia CX
using an 8 channel knee coil and PET/CT on a next generation (pre-commercial
release) Vereos digital PET system (Philips Healthcare, Cleveland, OH). An
in-house fabricated mold of the MR knee coil was used during PET acquisitions
to ensure identical positioning between image sets. A single bed position
centered on the knees was acquired following a 111 MBq
18F-FDG injection.
Listmode data were reconstructed into dynamic frames of 5 minutes from the time
of injection as well as static frame taken from 60-75 minutes post-injection.
Patients were grouped according to time since surgery and PET data were
quantified using SUV
max measured in the proximal, middle, and distal portions
of the graft, femoral and tibial tunnels, the posterior cruciate ligament
(PCL), and quadriceps muscle for reference. Matched ROIs were drawn in the
contralateral knee.
Results
Co-registration of PET and MR image sets was
readily feasible for all patients. Patients with more recent surgery were found
to have markedly higher metabolic uptake in the graft and bone tunnels than
patients with surgery greater than two years prior to imaging. It was also seen
that with increasing time since surgery the activity level through the graft as
well as surrounding tissues decreased toward values measured in healthy knees.
To a lesser extent, the uptake in the native ACL and surrounding tissue of
patients with recent surgery was found to be slightly higher than the healthy
knees of those patients with longer healing times.
Discussion
Quantitative PET imaging of small structures,
such as ligaments of the knee, has traditionally been limited by severe partial
volume effects in structures at or near the resolution limits of the system.
The introduction of digital photon counting in PET improves the system’s
spatial resolution as well a Time of Flight timing resolution which facilitates
an improved co-registration with high resolution MRI. The improvements helps to
greatly decrease the amount of partial volume effects which can be leveraged by
smaller voxel volume reconstruction. Previous assessment of ACL graft viability
by combined PET/MR has suffered from the lack of quantitative accuracy in
conventional PET imaging. This next phase of the study is seeing improved
quantitative precision, as validated in phantom data, and thus refined
evaluation of ACL graft healing. The distinction between uptake levels in newer
grafts versus those in place longer was more apparent with use of dPET,
allowing greater potential for correlation with clinical markers of graft
healing. Further assessment will also include review of MR image
characteristics in comparison to PET metabolic activity in addition to efforts
at further PET radiopharmaceutical dose reduction.
Conclusion
Molecular imaging assessment of ACL graft
viability is improved by use of digital photon counting in PET which makes it
preferable for combination with high resolution MRI. Enhanced quantitative
accuracy as well as target to background levels provide advanced insight into
graft healing, with the potential for ultra-low dose acquisitions in PET and
faster imaging times in MR, increasing the clinical feasibility of such a
combined imaging approach for this and other sports medicine applications.
Acknowledgements
This research was supported by the Ohio Third Frontier OSDA TECH 11-044
and TECH 13-060 grants.References
1. De Carlo MS, McDivitt R. Rehabilitation
of Patients Following Autogenic Bone-Patellar Tendon-Bone ACL Reconstruction: A
20-Year Perspective. N Am J Sports Phys Ther. Aug 2006;1(3):108-123. PMID:
21522223.
2. Bencardino JT1, Beltran J, Feldman MI,
Rose DJ. MR imaging of complications of anterior cruciate ligament graft
reconstruction. Radiographics. 2009 Nov;29(7):2115-26. doi:
10.1148/rg.297095036.