Chengcheng Zhu1, Henrik Haraldsson1, Karl Meisel2, Nerissa Ko2, Michael Lawton3, John Grinstead4, Sinyeob Ahn4, Gerhard Laub4, Christopher Hess1, and David Saloner1
1Radiology, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States, 2Neurology, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States, 3Neurological Surgery, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States, 4Siemens Healthcare, San Francisco, CA, United States
Synopsis
High resolution MRI of the intracranial vessel wall
provides important capabilities for the assessment of intracranial vascular
disease including atherosclerotic plaques and aneurysms. This study developed
and optimized 3D high resolution (0.5mm isotropic) techniques for intracranial
vessel wall imaging at 3T and 7T. The abilities of 3T clinical scanners and 7T
research scanners were systematically compared through theoretical simulations
and in vivo patient studies. We found 3D T1-weighted SPACE sequence could be
used for whole brain intracranial vessel wall evaluation at both 3T and 7T. 7T
provides significantly better image quality and improves the confidence of diagnosis.Purpose
High resolution MRI of the intracranial vessel wall
provides important insights in the assessment of intracranial vascular disease.
3D fast spin echo sequences with a variable flip angle echo train (SPACE,
Siemens Healthcare, or equivalent) is a leading candidate for vessel wall
imaging because it has high resolution and an intrinsic black blood effect. It
has been successfully used at both 3T
1 and 7T
2 with
0.5mm to 0.8mm isotropic resolution. However, a direct comparison between the
abilities of clinical 3T scanners and research 7T scanners is lacking. The long
echo train of SPACE may be associated with a wide point spread function (PSF) that
causes spatial blurring that degrades the nominal imaging resolution, but it
has not been fully investigated. In this study, we aim: 1) to investigate the
effect of refocusing flip angle train design on image quality at 3T and 7T; and
2) to compare the ability of 3T and 7T in intracranial vessel wall imaging in a
small group of patients.
Methods
Theoretical Simulations: Different echo train length (ETL, 40-60) and flip angle train design
(maximal flip angle αmax fixed around 140°, minimal flip angle αmin
from 23° to 47°) were simulated in a custom-designed software (Figure 1).
3T-ETL40 was the scanner default design, and 3T-ETL60 and 7T-ETL40 were custom
designs. Signal evolution curves and PSFs were simulated. Full width at half
maximum (FWHM) of the PSFs was calculated and the relative SNR was estimated by
averaging the first 5 echoes, and the value of 3T-ETL40 was set to 1 as a
reference.
Patient studies: 11 patients with intracranial artery disease
(5 atherosclerotic plaques and 6 aneurysms) were imaged on Siemens 3T Skyra and
7T scanners using SPACE both pre and post Gd contrast injection at a single
scan visit. Scanning protocols are shown on Table 1. Wall to lumen contrast
ratio (CRwall/lumen), contrast enhancement ratio (ER) and the
sharpness
3 of the vessel wall were quantified and compared between field strengths.
An experienced radiologist evaluated the image quality on a 0-5 scale.
Results
Both 3T and 7T achieved good image quality with
high resolution (nominal 0.5mm isotropic) and whole brain coverage within ~10 minutes
scan time. Simulation (Figure 1) shows 3T and 7T have similar SNR (3T-ETL40: 1;
3T-ETL60: 0.95; 7T: 0.98), but 7T has a much narrower PSF (FWHM: 7T: 1.5;
3T-ETL40: 2.6; 3T-ETL60: 2.8). Patient studies (Table 2 & Figure 2-4) show
that the CRwall-lumen at 3T and 7T (3.11±0.74 vs. 3.43±1.61, p=0.45)
and the ER measurements (1.58±0.41 vs. 1.56±0.35, p=0.83, Pearson’s r =0.69) are
comparable. The 7T images are 43% sharper (sharpness: 2.69±0.50 vs. 1.88±0.53
mm
-1, p<0.001) with higher image quality (
score:
3.5±1.1 vs. 2.4±1.1, p=0.002) compared to 3T.
Discussion
To our knowledge, this is the first study that systematically
compares the abilities of 3T and 7T scanners for the imaging of the intracranial
vessel wall. The comparison was performed using both theoretical simulations
and in vivo patients studies. Flip angle train design and ETL can significantly
influence the SNR and sharpness of the images. Previous high resolution studies
1 2 used very
long ETLs (58-116), which can possibly lead to different levels of blurring of
the vessel wall. We found that while a lower flip angle train design and short
ETL significantly reduced image blurring, it also decreased the SNR. At 3T,
high flip angle was used to maintain sufficient SNR, which agree with previous studies
1. Low flip angle design at 3T results in significantly low SNR
(image not shown). At 7T, the inherent high signal allows the use of a low flip
angle design that maintains both sufficient SNR and good image sharpness. This
study focused on T1 weighted SPACE development and optimization
because it is useful for identifying intra-plaque haemorrhage and contrast
enhancement and is time efficient. We found both 3T and 7T could be used to
characterize contrast enhancement, which is often linked to neurological symptoms
4. In
one patient with basilar artery plaque (Figure 4), it was possible with the
improved image quality at 7T to visualize a thick fibrous cap and a large lipid
core, which were not shown at 3T. With continued development, 7T has the
potential to more fully characterize intracranial plaque composition in vivo.
Conclusion
3D T1-weighted high resolution SPACE can be used
for whole brain intracranial vessel wall evaluation at both 3T and 7T. 7T
provides significantly better image quality and improves the confidence of diagnosis.
These techniques have great promise for risk stratification
of patients with intracranial vascular disease.
Acknowledgements
This study is supported by NIH grants R01HL114118 and R01NS059944.References
1.Qiao, Y.
et al. Intracranial arterial wall imaging using three-dimensional high
isotropic resolution black blood MRI at 3.0 Tesla. J Magn Reson Imaging 34,
22-30, (2011).
2. van der
Kolk, A. G. et al. Multi-sequence whole-brain intracranial vessel wall imaging
at 7.0 tesla. Eur Radiol 23, 2996-3004, (2013).
3. Larson,
A. C. et al. Preliminary investigation of respiratory self-gating for
free-breathing segmented cine MRI. Magn Reson Med 53, 159-168,
(2005).
4. Edjlali,
M. et al. Does aneurysmal wall enhancement on vessel wall MRI help to
distinguish stable from unstable intracranial aneurysms? Stroke 45, 3704-3706,
(2014).