Synopsis
Here
we present a multi-slice, multi-phase, single-shot fast spin echo sequence with
variable refocusing flip angle and interleaved cylindrical reference navigator
for retrospective respiratory-guided image sorting for the purpose of managing motion
in the context of MR-guided radiation therapy treatment planning.Purpose
MR-based
radiation therapy treatment planning (RTP) may offer a number of benefits over
the existing, CT-based standard of care, such as the lack of ionizing
radiation, and superior soft-tissue contrast for improved target and at-risk
organ delineation. Many challenges
remain, however, with motion management identified as one of the top needs for
MR-based RTP, especially in the chest and abdomen.
1 Various approaches to characterizing
respiratory motion with MRI have been proposed, however this remains an active
area of research.
2,3 The
purpose of this work was to develop and test a multi-slice multi-phase
single-shot fast spin echo (SSFSE, or HASTE, SSH-TSE, etc.) sequence incorporating variable refocusing flip
angle (vrfSSFSE) and an interleaved cylindrical navigator, for rapid,
T2-weighted imaging with retrospective respiratory compensation.
Methods
A
vrfSSFSE pulse sequence was modified to support ungated multi-slice multi-phase
imaging and the acquisition of a single, cylindrical navigator profile between
imaging shots (Figure 1). This navigator
profile was collected as a retrospective reference only, and not utilized for
gating. Phantom and volunteer scanning
was performed on a wide-bore 3.0T MRI scanner (MR750w, GE Healthcare, Waukesha,
WI). T2-weighted images of a phantom
undergoing periodic motion in the S/I direction were acquired with the
multi-slice multi-phase vrfSSFSE pulse sequence and the following imaging
parameters: coronal plane, 3 slices, 40 phases, TR = 677 ms (1.48 frames per
second), TE = 80 ms, FOV = 40 x 36 cm, 5 mm slice, 256 x 224 matrix, ±125 kHz bandwidth, 0.64 effective NEX, 2x
acceleration (ARC, GE Healthcare, Waukesha, WI), and refocusing flip angle targets
4
of 130, 90, 100 and 45 degrees, respectively.
The navigator profile was placed in the S/I direction across the edge of
the phantom. Following informed consent,
T2-weighted volunteer images were acquired for 20 slices and 20 phases with the
same parameters listed above, and with slightly modified parameters, as
follows: full-NEX, 3x ARC acceleration, TR = 458 ms (2.18 frames per second), TE
= 95 ms, and a minimum refocusing flip target of 60°. (Note, the imaging TR
includes both the length of the navigator and vrfSSFSE waveforms.) In all cases, the acquisition order was
interleaved for both slice and phase to allow maximum recovery time between
subsequent acquisitions of the same slice.
For in vivo imaging, the cylindrical navigator was placed across the
dome of the liver to record its position before each imaging shot. The displacements measured at the navigator TE
were interpolated via cubic spline to each respective vrfSSFSE image TE, and
then used to retrospectively sort the images by S/I position.
Results
Phantom
imaging results are summarized in Figure 1, which shows the navigator-derived
position data through time (1a), the same position data, retrospectively sorted
by image location and position (1b). The retrospectively sorted phantom image data for
a single, representative image location is shown in Figure 2, where the green
line represents the phantom’s maximum excursion in the S-direction. In vivo results are summarized in Figure 3,
showing a composite image of all phases for a single slice acquired with a minimum
refocusing flip angle of 90° (3a),
and all phases of the same slice acquired with a minimum refocusing flip angle
of 60° (3b). Figure 4 includes two examples of typical,
intermittent image shading due to cardiac motion for minimum refocusing flip
angles of 90° vs. 60°, respectively.
Discussion
These
results demonstrate the performance of a dynamic, T2-weighted vrfSSFSE pulse
sequence with an integrated cylindrical reference navigator for retrospective
respiratory compensation. As previously
reported
5, the reduced SAR associated with vrfSSFSE cuts the minumum
TR by an approximate factor of 2, which allows higher frame rates for
multi-phase imaging than could otherwise could be safely achieved with SSFSE at
3.0T. The full-Fourier acquisition has been
shown to provide improved sharpness and image SNR
5, though for the
relatively low-resolution acquisition tested here, the sole apparent advantage
of the more aggressive vrfSSFSE protocol (60° minimum flip) is in the
nearly 50% higher frame rate. The shortened
TRs available with vrfSSFSE are achieved at the expense of increased motion sensitivity.
6
As seen in the full-Fourier acquisition, the
liver signal is less consistent due to increased susceptibility to cardiac
motion. In the context of a redundant, multi-phase
acquisition, however, the opportunity to reject such image artifacts is greater
than for routine, anatomical imaging.
Conclusion
We have demonstrated the feasibility of a rapid, dynamic, T2-weighted
vrfSSFSE sequence for navigator-guided retrospective respiratory compensation. We believe this is one approach to motion
management in MRI that may prove to be useful in the context of MR-guided radiation
therapy treatment planning.
Acknowledgements
No acknowledgement found.References
1. McGee
KP, Hu Y, Tryggestad E, Brinkmann D, Witte B, Welker K, Panda A, Haddock M,
Bernstein MA. MRI in radiation oncology: Underserved needs. Magn Reson Med. 2015
Jul 14.
2. Tryggestad
E, Flammang A, Han-Oh S, Hales R, Herman J, McNutt T, Roland T, Shea SM, Wong
J. Respiration-based sorting of dynamic MRI to derive representative 4D-MRI for
radiotherapy planning. Med Phys. 2013 May;40(5).
3. Hu
Y, Caruthers SD, Low DA, Parikh PJ, Mutic S. Respiratory amplitude guided 4-dimensional
magnetic resonance imaging. Int J Radiat Oncol Biol Phys. 2013 May
1;86(1):198-204.
4. Busse
RF, Hariharan H, Vu A, Brittain JH. Fast spin echo sequences with very long
echo trains: design of variable refocusing flip angle schedules and generation
of clinical T2 contrast. Magn Reson Med 2006 May;55(5):1030-7.
5. Loening
AM, Saranathan M, Ruangwattanapaisarn N, Litwiller DV, Shimakawa A, Vasanawala
SS. Increased speed and image quality in single-shot fast spin echo imaging via
variable refocusing flip angles. J Magn Reson Imaging. 2015 Jun 19.
6. Litwiller DV, Holmes JH, Saranathan M,
Loening AM, Glockner JF, Vasanawala SS, Bayram E. Sensitivity of modulated
refocusing flip angle single-shot fast spin echo to impulsive cardiac-like
motion. Proceedings of the ISMRM 2014.