Tess E. Wallace1, Andrew J. Patterson2, Roie Manavaki1, Martin J. Graves1, and Fiona J. Gilbert1
1Department of Radiology, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, United Kingdom, 2Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust, Cambridge, United Kingdom
Synopsis
Physiological
fluctuations and motion artifacts are expected to be dominant sources of noise
in BOLD fMRI experiments to assess tumor oxygenation and angiogenesis. This work
assesses the impact of a non-rigid registration algorithm and retrospective
image correction (RETROICOR) on the detection of activation signals in the
breast, both at resting state and in response to a modulated respiratory
stimulus paradigm. Our results suggest that correction for motion artifacts is
associated with a reduction in false-positive activation effects, which can be
further improved by the addition of RETROICOR, confirming the importance of
these physiological corrections in functional parameter estimation.Purpose
Physiological fluctuations resulting from
cardiac pulsation and respiration are recognized to be a dominant source of
noise in blood oxygenation level-dependent (BOLD) fMRI experiments
1. There is growing interest in applying BOLD fMRI techniques outside
of the brain to assess tumor oxygenation and angiogenesis via vasomotor response
to modulated hyperoxic/hypercapnic gas stimuli
2,3. Breathing 100% oxygen and carbogen (5% CO
2, 95% O
2) have opposing effects on vascular tone, as carbon dioxide is a potent vasodilator. However, optical imaging studies have suggested that physiological
fluctuations may confound measurement of hemodynamic response
4. Furthermore, respiratory motion artifacts are expected to be an additional
source of noise, depending on the target site. Physiological noise correction
techniques such as RETROspective Image CORrection (RETROICOR) are commonly
applied in brain fMRI experiments to improve the statistical significance of
activation signals
5. The purpose of this work was to investigate the impact of a
non-rigid registration algorithm and RETROICOR on the detection of activation
signals in the breast, both at resting state (RS) and in response to a
modulated respiratory stimulus paradigm.
Methods
Data
Acquisition: Functional data was collected from eight
healthy female volunteers using a single-shot fast spin echo sequence to
acquire dynamic T
2-weighted images. Scan parameters were as follows:
3T (MR750, GE Healthcare, Waukesha, WI), TR 4000ms, TE 58ms, BW ±83kHz, matrix
size 128x128, FOV 20cm, slice thickness 5mm, single sagittal slice. RS data was acquired as subjects breathed medical air for twelve minutes.
The fMRI stimulus design consisted of breathing carbogen interleaved with oxygen in two-minute blocks, for a
total of 16 minutes (Figure 1). Physiology was recorded using the scanner’s
built in photoplethysmograph and pneumatic belt, and recording was synchronized
with the scan acquisition.
Data
Analysis: Each image series was aligned using a
least squares B-spline non-rigid registration algorithm
6. Physiological noise components were calculated by fitting a 5th
order Fourier series to the image data based on the phase of the cardiac and
respiratory cycles relative to the time of each image acquisition. Subsequent
analysis was performed on four datasets: uncorrected, RETROICOR-corrected,
registered, and registered plus RETROICOR-corrected. A ROI was drawn to
eliminate fat in the outer border of the breast and temporal standard deviation was calculated for each pixel in the ROI. Baseline subtraction of the line of best fit through the data was performed to remove linear drift. The first cycle of data from the activated
scan was discarded to allow equilibration of the gas inhalation regime. Signal
intensity response for each pixel was cross-correlated with a sine and
cosine function at the stimulus frequency (0.0042 Hz). All data processing and
analysis were performed using Matlab version 8.3 (The Mathworks, Natick, MA). Paired
Student’s t-tests were applied to assess the effect of each correction on the
mean temporal standard deviation and the difference in median correlation
coefficient between RS and activated scans.
Results
A significant reduction in mean temporal standard deviation of RS data was seen for both registration (23%) and RETROICOR (8%) over
all subjects (p<0.001). A further 7% reduction in mean temporal standard deviation was seen when RETROICOR was applied to the registered data
(p<0.001), shown in Figure 2. A corresponding reduction in median
correlation coefficient of RS data was also seen after registration (p=0.06). Activation
maps for air-only and oxygen/carbogen scans are shown for a representative
volunteer in Figure 3. Overall, there was a significant difference in median correlation
coefficient between the RS and activated scans before any correction was
applied (p=0.042). However, this difference was significantly improved after
registration (p=0.008) and further improved with the addition of RETROICOR
(p=0.004), but not with RETROICOR-correction alone (p=0.085), shown in Figure 4.
Discussion
Signal intensity changes induced by the
modulated gas stimuli are small, so the temporal signal-to-noise ratio of the
time series is critical for detecting activation effects. Respiratory motion was the dominant source of noise in this study, particularly at the
border between fat and fibroglandular tissue. Registration of the dynamic
series was important in reducing false-positive activation effects, even when
motion artifacts were small. Applying RETROICOR after motion correction gave the
greatest overall reduction in temporal standard deviation of RS data and the
most significant difference between RS and activated scans. Correcting for
physiological fluctuations alone was less effective, likely due to movement of fluctuations
between pixels, which is not accounted for by RETROICOR. These results demonstrate
a reduction of respiratory motion and cardiac pulsation artifacts is associated
with changes in activation parameter calculation, confirming the importance of
physiological corrections in detecting functional changes in the
breast.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by the NIHR
Cambridge Biomedical Research Centre and the Cambridge Experimental Cancer
Medicine Centre.References
1. Kruger G and Glover GH. Physiological noise in oxygen-sensitive Magnetic Resonance
Imaging. Magn. Reson. Med. 2001;46:631–37.
2. Rakow-Penner R, Daniel B and Glover GH. Detecting blood oxygen level-dependent
(BOLD) contrast in the breast. J. Magn. Reson. Imaging 2010;32:120–29.
3. Neeman M,
Dafni H, Bukhari O, et al. In vivo BOLD
contrast MRI mapping of subcutaneous vascular function and maturation:
validation by intravital microscopy. Magn. Reson. Med. 2001;46:887–98.
4. Carpenter CM, Rakow-Penner R, Jiang S, et al. Monitoring of hemodynamic changes induced in the healthy
breast through inspired gas stimuli with MR-guided diffuse optical imaging. Med.
Phys. 2010;37:1638–46.
5. Glover GH, Li, TQ and Ress D. Image-based method for retrospective correction of physiological motion effects in fMRI: RETROICOR. Magn. Reson. Med. 2000;44:162–7.
6. Rueckert D, Sonoda LI, Hayes C, et al. Nonrigid registration using free-form deformations:
application to breast MR images. IEEE Trans. Med. Imaging 1999;18:712–21.