Lucette A Cysique1, James R Soares2, John Geng3, Maia Scarpetta3,4, Bruce J Brew2,5, Roland Henry6, and Caroline D Rae7
1UNSW Australia, NeuRA, Sydney, Australia, 2UNSW Australia, Sydney, Australia, 3NeuRA, Sydney, Australia, 4Reed College, Portland, WA, United States, 5St. Vincent's Hospital, Sydney, Australia, 6UCSF, San Francisco, CA, United States, 7The University of New South Wales, Randwick, Australia
Synopsis
DTI was performed in 40 HIV- men and
82 HIV+ men with comparable demographics and life styles. The study was
designed to recruit chronic HIV+ participants with successful viral control.
DTI was 32 directions; FA values were quantified in each participant in 12
skeleton regions of interest, which have been associated with HIV-related brain
injury. The study present first evidence for complex brain repair processes in
treated and chronic HIV infection arguing for careful multilevel
characterization of HIV+ samples in neuroHIV DTI studies. The association of
neurocognitive function with FA suggests ongoing vulnerability despite
successful treatment.Introduction
The location and magnitude
of fractional anisotropy (FA) reduction measured by diffusion tensor imaging
(DTI) is not consistent across neuroHIV studies probably because of the heterogeneity
of clinical and neurocognitive characteristics in selected HIV-infected (HIV+) samples.
As such there is a lack of understanding of the level of white matter damage/integrity
in
treated and chronic HIV infection
and the role of key demographics, laboratory and treatment effects that are
important factors to consider in the HIV population.
Methods
The study sample included 122 men of whom 40 were
HIV- and 82 were HIV+ with comparable demographics and life styles (Table 1). The
study was designed to recruit chronic HIV+ participants (Table 2).
HIV-associated neurocognitive disorder (HAND) was classified using standard
criteria (Table 2) 1. DWI was
acquired on a 3T Achieva TX (Philips
Medical Systems, Best, The Netherlands) with an 8-channel SENSE head coil. Images
were acquired in the axial plane using a single-shot EPI sequence optimised for
use on this scanner (TR/TE: short/68ms; b=1000s/mm2; 2.5 mm isotropic
resolution; flip angle: 90°; FOV 240x240; 55 slices) in 32 diffusion gradient
directions, plus one a b0 for
diffusion tensor fitting. DTI processing: data were extracted from DWI in
Itrack IDL 2. For each voxel, tensor eigenvectors and corresponding
eigenvalues were computed, and FA values derived. FA maps were then fed into
standard tract-based spatial statistics (TBSS) skeletonization 3. Next
each person’s FA data was projected onto ENIGMA standard space 4. Then,
TBSS skeletons were segmented according to the Johns Hopkins ICBM-DTI-81 atlas, average
FA values were computed in 12 selected regions of interest (Figure 1; ROI,
right and left ROI were averaged, as there were no significant differences)
primarily including brain areas known to be associated with HIV-related brain
injury (Genu, body and Splenium of corpus callosum [GCC, BCC, SCC], Fornix [FX]
anterior and posterior limb of internal capsule [ALIC, PLIC], anterior and
superior corona radiata (ACR, SCR), external capsule [EC], Cingulum [CG], Superior
longitudinal fasciculus [SLF], Uncinate fasciculus (UNC]). Statistical analyses:
Averaged FA values in the 12 ROI were compared between HIV- and HIV+ sample
using MANOVA and a mean response. Effects of age and education were tested
using a linear regression (and an interaction term). Effects of HIV disease and
treatment markers were tested using univariate and multivariate regression. Neurocognitive
functioning was evaluated using three clinically relevant groupings: HAND
versus no HAND; ANI, versus MND+HAD, versus NP-normal, and HAD versus no HAD.
Associations with FA values were tested with ANOVA and Dunnett’s control or
t-test as appropriate. P-value for significance was set at p<.05.
Results
There was no between-group
difference in FA values across the 12 ROI (p=.63,
Figure 2). A negative age effect was found in the ACR (p<.009), EC (p<.02); and FX (p<.001). There was only a trend for an age and HIV status
interaction in the CG (p=.07, Std
Beta=.18) where HIV+ cases had lower FA as a function of age. There were
interactions of HIV status and education in the FX (p<.03, Std Beta=.21; as function of education lower FA in HIV+
versus higher FA in HIV-), the SCR, and SLF (p<.03, Std Beta=-.22; as function of education lower FA in HIV-
versus higher FA in HIV+). Univariate analyses, in the HIV+ group only, showed
that CD4-T cells count was associated with higher FA in the ACR (r=.30; p=.0006); FX (r=.25; p=.03), and SLF (r=.25; p=.03). HIV duration was associated with
lower FA in the FX (r=-.31; p=.004)
and higher FA in the SCR (r=.25; p=.03).
CART duration (r=.27; p=.01) was
associated with higher FA in the ACR (r=.27; p=.01) . CPE rank score was associated with higher FA in the ALIC
(r=.38; p=.0004) and PLIC (r=.23; p=.04), and GCC (r=.23; p=.04). Multivariate model showed that
each biomarker and treatment effects were independently associated with FA
values. Individuals with MND+HAD had lower FA values in the CG (p=.04), FX (p=.007) compared to
NP-normal and ANI cases. HAND cases had lower FA in the FX compared to the no
HAND cases (p=.04). HAD cases had
lower FA in the SCR compared to the no HAD cases (p=.02).
Conclusions
We
present the first evidence for complex brain repair processes in treated and
chronic HIV infection arguing for careful multilevel characterization of HIV+
samples in neuroHIV DTI studies. The association of neurocognitive function with
FA suggests ongoing vulnerability despite highly successful treatment.
Acknowledgements
We would like to thank the participants for their
time on the study. The study was funding by the NHMRC project grant
(568746 ; CIA Cysique) and Career Development Fellowship (APP1045400; CIA Cysique), as well as support from the Peter Duncan
Neuroscience Unit at St. Vincent’s Hospital Applied Medical Research Centre (Head Prof. Bruce Brew).References
1. Cysique LA, Heaton RK, Kamminga J. et
al. HIV-associated neurocognitive disorder in Australia: a case of a
high-functioning and optimally treated cohort and implications for
international neuroHIV research. J Neurovirol. 2014;20(3):258-68.
2. Chung S, Lu Y, Henry RG. Comparison of bootstrap
approaches for estimation of uncertainties of DTI parameters. NeuroImage
2006;33:531-541.
3. Smith S.M., Jenkinson, M. Woolrich,
MW et al. Advances in functional and structural MR image analysis and
implementation as FSL. NeuroImage 2004, 23(S1):208-219, 2004.
4. http://enigma.ini.usc.edu/protocols/dti-protocols/
5. Letendre SL, Ellis Rj, Ances BM. Neurologic complications of HIV disease and their treatment. (2161-5845 (Electronic)).